8 ms·
>> And charging stations are, of course, absolutely dirt cheap to build relative to fuel stations. Really? A normal gas station can handle around 100 cars per
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> And charging stations are, of course, absolutely dirt cheap to build relative to fuel stations.
Really? A normal gas station can handle around 100 cars per hour using a handful of pumps and is refueled by daily deliveries from a big truck. Simple. An electric charge point capable of that will require a massive amount of electricity, electricity delivered over wires. Look into how much it costs to run such a service to a random location in a city. Look at the costs of putting up even a handful of towers capable of delivering a thousand amps peak load. Then look the additional real estate costs need to facilitate 100 cars/hour worth of charging points. Electric 'stations' are very much not drop-in replacements. We need a very different physical infrastructure (ie smaller charge points at every parking spot rather than central stations).
- ajross 6y agoI'd want to see numbers for that argument, because I don't think I'm willing to buy it on assertion. A single, routine, boring 100A building drop is enough to charge 4-5 cars (i.e. "one station worth"), and those wires and infrastructure are already there, and have been for decades.
- sandworm101 6y agoTesla superchargers take about 40 minutes to deliver an 80% charge. Call that a "full" tank. A gas pump can do the same in about 5 minutes (probably less). So to charge/fill the same number of cars per hour as one gas pump you need 8 superchargers. That's a significant increase in real estate area needed. Another approach: A top-end Tesla supercharger delivers around 250kW. So eight of those would be 2000kW or 2 Megawatt, or around 20,000 amps, to give the equivalent number of fills/charges per hour as ONE gas pump. I filled my tank at a medium-sized station this morning that had 8 pumps (4 islands, double-sided). So the drop-in electric replacement would be 8x the numbers above.
- maxerickson 6y agoApplebee's can add charge points without any increase in real estate (as an example). The ongoing logistics of having chargers in the parking lot is pretty different than running a gas station. Which is to say, quickly fueling up at a convenience store probably won't be the only way people charge their vehicles going forward.
- sandworm101 6y agoExactly. I wasn't saying that charging was impossible, rather that drop-in replacements for gas stations are impracticable and certainly would not be "cheap". The widespread use of EVs will require a very different physical infrastructure.
- theshrike79 6y agoNo-one will ever be doing "drop-in" EV replacements for gas stations, why would they?
- marvin 6y agoThis line of reasoning is incorrect. Unlike fossil refuelling, the vast majority of EV charging happens at home. This charging does not load public charging stations at all. Unless your needs are esoteric, you might only charge at a public charging station one out of twenty times. Of course some homes don't have private charging easily available, but that's a different argument.
- uncledave 6y agoVery few homes have anywhere to charge anything in London as an example. I don’t think the model works without knocking cities down and starting again. The two people I know with Teslas have to charge at the local supercharger or park it a quarter of a mile away at the nearest slow charger which becomes a chore.
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoStick a couple of plug sockets in every lamppost in London, add fast charging bays at the end of every road and you’re done.
- sandworm101 6y agoNot what i was talking about. I was speaking about replacing gas stations with charging stations, how the problem is not going to be solved by swapping one for another. I made no mention of other non-station charging options.
- marvin 6y agoWell, my point was that public charging demand per EV will be much lower than fuelling demand per fossil car, which obviously affects the number of minutes per week each vehicle has to spend at the gas station/recharging station, and hence the feasibility of gas station owners to install charging infrastructure. I’m sure there will be exceptions, e.g. in sparsely populated areas. And I don’t think market forces will make drop-in replacement the primary solution, but it will probably be part of the solution.
- ghaff 6y agoMore to the point, I'm not sitting around for 40 minutes at a charging station even once a week to get recharged (and it will be more frequent than that for many). Especially given that offices may be a less regular thing, people need ways to charge when their cars are parked wherever they're parked when they're at home. Even if they eat out a bit that's not a substitute.
- cptskippy 6y agoWhat if you could plug in where ever you park your car? You don't need to stop somewhere for 40 minutes if you're able to charge every where you go.
- gnicholas 6y agoTrue, but I’m not going to want to spend the overhead time to figure out if my car is compatible with some random charger, figure out if the price is favorable (some are by the minute, others by the kilowatt hour), and then plug and unplug just to get the range equivalent of 2 gallons of gas while I’m at a store.
- cptskippy 6y agoTesla is the only one who doesn't support J1772. The compatibility problem has mostly solved itself with the industry adopting CCS, which is backwards compatible with J1772. Teslas sold in North America are the only new EVs without CCS. The reason charger pricing is inconsistent is because there isn't regulation requiring a standard the way fluid pricing is regulated. https://www.nist.gov/document/00-20-h130-iv-c-final-80pdf https://www.nist.gov/document/00-20-h130-iv-c-final-80pdf Both of those issues are easily solved by legislation.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoJust in case anyone failed to read between the lines: all new non-US Teslas have CCS.
- 6y ago
- p1mrx 6y ago100A at 240V can charge 4-5 cars... in about 12 hours. That would be useful at a hotel or workplace, but it won't replace a gas station.
- glial 6y agoOK, maybe the goal should be to relax our assumption that recharging happens at the gas stations, and just spread the load to all the parking lots we can find. Then gas stations could just have the quick-charge versions for more $$.
- smileysteve 6y ago> That would be useful at a hotel or workplace, but it won't replace a gas station. Also useful at any sit down restaurant (even fast food). (which although self driving makes driving while eating safer, was a horrible practice to begin with) Addon; Tracked long trips we took in the SE last year against the Tesla charger map; There was always a super charger within 1 mile of where we stopped for food, were stopped for about an hour, etc. And some in our group also needed bio breaks every hour and a half; aka < 150 miles.
- cptskippy 6y ago> but it won't replace a gas station. It will replace the majority of them. The concept non-EV owners struggle with is that with an EV you don't normally go out of your way to charge it the way you do with an ICE. If you can charge at home, at work, at the grocery store, and at restaurants then why do you need a filling station? If you start your day at 100% because you charge at home then you don't need any of the other infrastructure unless you go on a road-trip. The amount of charging infrastructure need is also based on both demand and use case. A grocery store or restaurant might opt for DC fast chargers because they know customers won't be around for more than 30 minutes, but an office park can use 3-6kw chargers because users are there for 8 hours a day. The EVSEs are smart too so you can balance output based on demand. Have two EVs plugged in, they both get 3kw. Just one can pull 6kw.
- marvin 6y agoThe biggest problem is peak power. The naïve approach is to try to pull 500kW from the grid during the 20 minutes that you have five cars charging, then zero once they leave. This will at best be very expensive, but most likely impossible as the local grid won't support it. So a battery buffer needs to be built into the charging station in order to operate them cheaply, with a smoother load profile that the power company and grid operator will service without exorbitant costs. Thankfully, at least one EV company has already realized this :-) Let's see if more than one of them eventually starts producing enough batteries to support the strategy.
- cptskippy 6y agoThat will be less of a problem than you think. Power demand is already inconsistent throughout the day. Depending on the time of year it will peak around noon or in the evening but overnight the demand is low. When people start charging overnight at home the overnight loads will increase. This will intern allow power companies to increase capacity.
- viraptor 6y agoI suspect new payment plans will get more popular soon. I'm not familiar with the US providers, but in Australia there are already at least two companies allowing you to buy energy at a current, hourly adjusted price. I expect that in a couple of decades "energy cost arbitrage via car charging" will be a normal thing.
- cptskippy 6y agoYou're probably right. In the US there's generally two systems, flat-rate or time-of-use. A lot of people on time-of-use plans are installing battery backups and/or solar to avoid the peak charges. I have a Tesla solar/powerwall setup that's configured for cost savings and it decided that today 100% of solar was going to be back fed to the grid and we've been running 100% off the batteries. Usually the system just switches to batteries during peak.
- turtlebits 6y agoThe problem is that your 100A charging station will take 8+ hours to charge all 4 cars to max (as that is ~L2 charging speed..
- viraptor 6y agoUnless you regularly drain all 4 cars to 0% in 8 hours, this is not really a problem. And if you do, you're likely running some kind of transport company and can afford planning for better charging.
- fiftyfifty 6y agoThis is a false dichotomy, we have to get away from thinking of charging stations like gas pumps. Charging stations can be everywhere: grocery stores, retail stores, office buildings, malls, just about any parking lot or parking garage, hotels, airport parking and on and on. Gas pumps have to have huge underground tanks, and they have to be regularly refilled by large tanker trucks, by their very nature they will be less common and so they'd better be able to service more cars per hour. Charging stations are much smaller and can tie into the grid just about anywhere, there should be a lot more of them and thus they won't need to handle as many cars as a gas station does.
- BurningFrog 6y agoYeah, every parking spot could be a simple charging station. All you need is a power cable. Reusing the land of all gas stations for other things will be a good benefit of all this. Except for San Francisco, where they all will be preserved as historical landmarks.
- akiselev 6y ago> Yeah, every parking spot could be a simple charging station. All you need is a power cable. ...and the infrastructure to distribute the electricity. Back of the napkin math with the mall of America: 5.6 million sq ft at ~14kWh/sq ft per year (rough average estimate of all retail buildings) [1] equates to about 78.4 million kWh/year or 784,000 100kWh Model S's charged to full or 7.84 million charged 10% assuming 100% efficiency. The Mall of America has about 40 million annual visitors so about a fifth would be able to charge their batteries 10% if the Mall doubled its (hypothetical) capacity, which would likely require at least some infrastructure upgrades since we're talking about ~10 MW of extra power - and that's averaged out 24/7/365, in actuality it'll be a much higher peak load since the mall isn't 24/7. I'm not an expert but I doubt the property developer and power companies overbuilt by that much. [1] https://dsoelectric.com/sites/dsoelectric/files/My%20Business/retail.pdf https://dsoelectric.com/sites/dsoelectric/files/My%20Busines...
- kingaillas 6y ago
- dzhiurgis 6y agoThis why a lot of stations are now moving to adding batteries to meet peak demand. Also if you have lots of stalls of cars charing to 100%, you can steal some of their charge and route to someone who needs to get to 80% ASAP. Also, fast charge is very slowed down in cold climates and/or when you are reaching 80%.
- cptskippy 6y ago> Also, fast charge is very slowed down in cold climates and/or when you are reaching 80%. Some EVs with temperature management systems can precondition the battery for charging. This negates reduced charging speeds at extreme temperatures.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoIn theory, yet look at Bjorn's videos and that not always the case with TM3. You can't preheat much when you have 5% battery left! Definitely it's the way forward tho!
- lazyasciiart 6y agoCost to build a gas station includes cost to build a giant storage tank for hazardous material and piping to deliver that to outlets at ground level. Running it may be simple but building it is absolutely not.
- theshrike79 6y agoFor a gas station you need permits to place cubic meters of flammable poisonous liquids underground. For a charging station you need: electricity. And not even huge amounts of it unless you're planning on building a huge charging field with dozens of high-power chargers (300kW+). Even then you can load balance the power with 90's technology to keep up. For peak loads you can have a battery on-site, charged on off-peak hours. And none of this requires hazardous materials permits or safeties for flammable liquids.