2 ms·
An Australia with No Google? The Bitter Fight Behind a Drastic Threat
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"When you put a price on linking to certain information, you break the way search engines work," she said. "And you no longer have a free and open web." - Google "Google and Facebook (along with Twitter and others), however, do not simply link. They frame the work in previews, with headlines, summaries and photos, and then curate and serve up the content while sprinkling in advertisements." - NYT More than that. "Google News" (is it really? they produced none of it) is a series of redirects via cloaked URLs before the user ever sees the true media website URL. That is not linking, that is a process for collecting data on users. With that process Google can collect more data than any single media website. That is not an even playing field on the web. It is also a process for protecting others from using those links by scraping them from Google. As if to suggest it is OK for Google to scrape and to be an interstitial, but it is not OK for others to offer a competing service. Of course Google can also show ads on those interstitial pages if it wanted to. They are the ultimate middleman. What if I start a faster, more direct and more privacy respecting site to compete with "Google News". No redirects, no URL cloaking, no iframes, no ads, no tracking, no data collection. It is better than Google News in every way. How much traffic will "Fast News" get. Why is that. Perhaps the antitrust suits in the US will shed some light on the answer to that question. (Massive payola to be the "default" search, for starters.) Google is not arguing in favour of "all" search engines, it is arguing in favour of itself only. There are lists of URLs pointing to the media websites in every country. It is not as if no one will ever be able to find these websites again if Google does not feature them. Quite the contrary. People will discover more news by going directly the sources. I can write a few lines of shell script that scrape indexes of articles from media websites. I get an RSS feed of the news, from multiple sources. I can also write scripts that automatocally search media websites using the media website themselves. Finding and searching through news does not require Google. Google may be the fastest, largest search but only because every single website allows one company to scrape full indexes to their content wth impunity and that one company pays every computer vendor to make it the "default search". It is nice to have an "all-in-one" solution for searching the web. But this is not a fair situation. It is Google's greed that has pushed things to this point. We cannot blame the media for trying to stand up to this nonsense. Google can stop this law and whatever detrimental effects it may have on others by simply paying for what they are continually allowed to do. Google has mountains fo cash on hand.