3 ms·
> Governments using private companies to decide who deserves to die based on ML algorithms without judge or jury is morally reprehensible. Full stop. Governmen
by sneak 6y ago
> Governments using private companies to decide who deserves to die based on ML algorithms without judge or jury is morally reprehensible. Full stop.
Governments (or, more accurately, human beings acting under color of law) deciding to assassinate people is morally reprehensible, regardless of how the targeting is done.
If "private company" and "ML" are the keywords it takes to get people outraged about assassination programs, I'm fine with that, but let's make sure we know why we're upset.
This is premeditated murder, and throwing around terms like "insurgent" and "rules of engagement" are just a way of legitimizing premeditated murder.
- JackFr 6y agoThere is some nuance. Assume for the sake of argument that the United States has a legitimate interest in fighting the Taliban. Within such an exercise I hope we could agree that there is a distinction between lawful violence and unlawful violence. People of goodwill can disagree about where to draw that distinction. But 'rules of engagement' is not a mealy-mouthed weasel word. It's how we describe this distinction. (It may be likely that you don't accept under any circumstance that the US has a legitimate interest in fighting the Taliban. That's fine but it's a different discussion.)
- lrvick 6y agoThere are plenty of things that are legal but unethical. It is incredibly critical every citizen be capable of choosing -not- to do things that are legal and would benefit them, because they find them unethical. This is how majority held ethics graduate to becoming laws.