5 ms·
> Where the politics turns into a fight between "use government to achieve public policy goals" versus "destroy government, except for the police and security f
by rayiner 6y ago
> Where the politics turns into a fight between "use government to achieve public policy goals" versus "destroy government, except for the police and security forces", the "destroy government" faction get to make the actual governance worse and have forfeited any ability to make useful or constructive criticism.
You've got the causation backwards. The "destroy government" folks came into existence because governance was poor. Don't forget that in the 60 years between 1932 and 1994, Democrats controlled the House for all but 4 years, and the Senate for all but 10. Every now and then a Republican would get elected President to pump the brakes a bit, but Congress makes the laws, and since Democrats controlled that even wildly popular Presidents like Reagan couldn't meaningfully roll back any of the FDR or Great Society era programs. Its not like people didn't have ample opportunity to sample what the "use government to achieve public policy goal" folks were selling.
There's not a single American city that has public services as well-run as even a second tier German city. These are one-party places like in California or New York, where Democrats control both houses of the state legislature, and the executive, and the municipal government. Here in Maryland, Democrats have controlled the state legislature continuously for a century. Since 1969, we've had just two moderate Republican governors (who got elected to pump the breaks a bit on otherwise unbroken Democratic control). Around the country, people are streaming out of New York, California, and Illinois, to places like Virginia, Georgia, Arizona, and Texas where the government doesn't try to do much but at least the taxes and property prices are low. (The #1 reason Virginia turned Democrat is migration into what used to be a well-run Republican state. Georgia and Arizona flipped for the same reason, and the same is happening to Texas.)
As someone who leans center-left on "government should provide services" it's not clear to me why American government is so bad. My hunch is that Democrats aren't really interested in governing. We have a new Democratic President. What's at the top of his agenda? How about reforming Medicaid to make it easy to sign up (vast numbers of the people who are uninsured are actually eligible for Medicaid but don't sign up)? Following up on the extremely popular $600 checks to permanently expand unemployment benefits? Instead we're going to spend Biden's entire term fighting over a divisive amnesty bill.
- pjc50 6y agoI thought the "destroy the US federal government" folks came into being at the time of the Civil War, because the government was trying to end slavery, and this has essentially poisoned US politics for a century and a half. The federal government had to tread on the states repeatedly to get them to end official and unofficial apartheid. The war continues over the statues of the traitors. The economic turmoil of 1929 onwards caused chaos that sent a lot of countries into Fascism; the US avoided collapse at that point, but at the cost of wealth confiscation which has also left huge scars in the politics (this is where the goldbugs come from). (It's not clear how you could "roll back FDR or the Great Society"; the world is a very different place! But in order to get to "better governance" I guess the society has to get past running street battles with white supremacists)
- rayiner 6y agoI mean that’s how it happens, right? The refrain is always: forget that solid blue states do a miserable job with things like education, transit, and housing, which are almost completely within state jurisdiction. Look over there some redneck in South Carolina wants to keep confederate statues! Accountability of government is something we’ll get around to once we’ve purged society of all “isms” and “phobias.” Democrats are so resistant to the idea of holding Democratic administrations accountable that the police killing of George Floyd in a city that had zero Republicans on the city council, but two socialists, in a state that hasn’t voted Republican for President in half a century, somehow became a referendum on the evils of a Republican President that has almost zero power over the operation of police departments. I understand why party leadership operates this way. I don’t understand why rank and file voters put up with it. There is nothing that poisons the pro-government agenda more than the fact that Democrats don’t have a single place they can point to where they can say: “see, big government works great and the higher taxes you’ll pay will be worth it.” They’re reduced to pointing to places like Sweden and Denmark. Meanwhile, Republicans can point to New York City, etc., and say “see, big government doesn’t work.” And that’s not an unfair criticism!
- tptacek 6y agoAs a lifelong and committed Democrat I pretty much agree with all of this. On the other hand, I'd love to be able to vote for a sane Republican for statewide office in Illinois, but every cycle, without fail, the Republican candidates are doctrinaire in the mold of the national party. One very small good thing you can say about the Democrats in one-party states like Illinois is that they don't all seem to have national aspirations.