3 ms·
>> implying that living users could train a digital replacement in the event of their death. I've seen this so many times in science fiction that I am disappoi
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> implying that living users could train a digital replacement in the event of their death.
I've seen this so many times in science fiction that I am disappointed that MS can claim IP over such a scheme. It is like, after centuries of writers writing about it, applying for a patent on "flying machines". I understand that patent law may in fact protect such things, broad concepts that innumerable people have dreamt about for decades, but it shouldn't. At most it should grant monopoly to a specific implementation rather than sequester the entire field.
On the other hand, let MS have it. All that science fiction points to such schemes going either going horribly wrong or being sad and pathetic. Let MS keep shooting that same foot.
- jawns 6y agoPatents aren't a claim on the idea itself, but on a specific implementation. There are many, many ways that sci-fi has conceived of this working. Any patent has to articulate a method for achieving it, and the patent only covers that particular method. That said, if a sci-fi novel were to go into great technical detail about how to train a chatbot to emulate the way a dead loved one communicates, and Microsoft were to copy that method exactly, it's possible that the novel could be treated as prior art.
- sandworm101 6y agoThe patented method will be "digital information --> into computer --> result. Or "social media information --> computer->result". Or it will be "trained by person still alive --> computer --> result". Patent law tends to overreach in new/novel fields.