3 ms·
>> You could limit the initial torque in software, but that’d kill the joy of the EV. All electric cars are torque-limited. They simply have to be. A static
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> You could limit the initial torque in software, but that’d kill the joy of the EV.
All electric cars are torque-limited. They simply have to be. A static electric motor, of the type needed for higher speeds, given full voltage would not only snap bits of the drivetrain but rip apart its own mounts. So they are all limited to various degrees.
The limiting factor on low-speed power for EVs isn't the motor. It's the strength of the drivetrain and ability of the battery system to provide the necessary current/voltage without cooking something.
- luma 6y agoIs this still true with the use of SynRM motors (as deployed by Tesla)?
- sandworm101 6y agoAll electric motors boil down to magnets pulling and pushing on each other to make movement. Whether the torque protection is via software, circuitry, or mechanical wizardry doesn't really matter. They all need it somewhere to prevent static magnetic forces from pulling everything else apart.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>All electric cars are torque-limited. They simply have to be. A static electric motor, of the type needed for higher speeds, given full voltage would not only snap bits of the drivetrain but rip apart its own mounts. So they are all limited to various degrees. Electric motors are far, far, more forgiving to drive-train components than sporty vehicles with manuals and medium duty trucks of equivalent power levels because there is no clutch to dump. Sure it's not quite as forgiving as an automatic transmission but it's close.
- sandworm101 6y agoNo. Electric motors are potential torque beasts. That is why they, ALL of them in cars, are mated to motor controllers. The controller may be integrated into the motor assembly so as to give the impression that the motor is tame, but the reality is that every electric motor has the potential for damaging/dangerous levels of torque. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_controller https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_controller "A motor controller is a device or group of devices that can coordinate in a predetermined manner the performance of an electric motor. [...] regulating or limiting the torque, and protecting against overloads..."
- birdyrooster 6y agoWell wouldn't the controller also be used to distribute the inverted power to the poles of the stator in sync with the rotation of the hub? I am pretty sure the controller could be there whether or not it was specifically modulating the torque to be lower.
- elihu 6y agoMotor controllers are necessary with AC motors to supply the 3-phase AC that the motors need in sync with the motor's rotation. (DC motor controllers are simpler, but I don't think DC motors are used in any modern commercially-produced EV.) This generally requires some amount of software. The motor generally has current and voltage and RPM and temperature limits, and the motor controller keeps everything within those limits. But the motor controller isn't there just for that reason, it's there because the motor couldn't function without it. DC motors are different; those you could just literally replace your gas pedal with an on/off button and wire it straight from the battery to the motor. Not that that's a good idea.
- thehappypm 6y agoWhat? Electric cars have far better low-speed torque than ICEs. How do you think Teslas can do 0-60 so fast?
- harpiaharpyja 6y agoI don't think you understand the GP comment. All electric cars are torque-limited certainly != electric cars do not have good low-speed torque. It is precisely because electric motors are capable of such high torque that they have to be torque limited.