4 ms·
They're comparing apples and logitechs. I wouldn't be surprised if the iphone cameras have had a billion dollars of development invested in them. But a large
by m463 6y ago
They're comparing apples and logitechs.
I wouldn't be surprised if the iphone cameras have had a billion dollars of development invested in them. But a large portion of this is on the software/firmware side which logitech doesn't benefit from.
That said, we all reap the benefits of this because phone camera hardware has been driven down in cost considerably since phones first got cameras. There just needs to be more open software to help out, maybe like machine learning exposure, focus, color and more. Then even low-margin webcam companies will have good performance.
- coldtea 6y ago>I wouldn't be surprised if the iphone cameras have had a billion dollars of development invested in them Which is neither here, nor there. There are tons of dirt cheap (often cheaper) compact cameras on the market with better quality that most webcams, and have been for years. Including equally small as webcam options. There are also tons of dirt cheap Android phones with far better camera quality in an even more constrained space (for the camera module) than a webcam. There are also embedded laptop cameras with better quality than most $100 and plus webcams. As a sibling comment said: "I use OBS Studio's output as virtual camera - and among the inputs I use cheap old Android tablets with DroidCam OBS over IP on Wi-Fi... They cost less than a USB webcam and deliver much better image quality." There's absolutely no reason webcam makers couldn't build a better product using components found in 5+ year old phones... Even if it was expensive, the problem is there's not even an expensive $300 or $500 webcam with quality compared to a years old Android or iPhone smartphone of equal price, or a compact camera. Heck, webcams sold as $1000 and $2000 "enterprise" webcams, in bulky enclosures to sit on a desk or large TV, have some more conveniences (to fit the enterpise moniker), but same (crap) image quality.
- m463 6y agoThe article is directly comparing apple iphones against logitech webcams. iphones benefit from: a processor that costs more than the entire webcam. A firmware and software stack with a billion dollars behind it.
- coldtea 6y ago>iphones benefit from: a processor that costs more than the entire webcam. A firmware and software stack with a billion dollars behind it. Still the camera is great alone, even without "computational photography". And similar IQ quality can be had in competing Android phones for years -- some costing the same or less than a premium $200 or $300 webcam. Anyway you slice it or dice it, this is not a "good cameras are expensive" issue.
- chrismorgan 6y agoApple still ships bad webcams on their laptops. There seems to be a big class divide between phone cameras and webcams.
- lhnz 6y agoShouldn't the rise of remote work change this?
- llampx 6y agoIt hasn't done so so far.
- lhnz 6y agoYes, that's what's strange to me. Either laptop manufacturers are missing a trick that would help them compete, or people don't really care about picture quality in remote video calls.
- llampx 6y agoI think its more that laptop manufacturers don't care because no other OEM has made a selling point of it. Its a virtuous circle - some people care about a specific feature, some OEM makes it a selling point, more people start talking about it, OEM B calls an emergency meeting and asks for the feature to be in their new laptop line, they spend advertising $$ promoting it, more people get to know about it and ask for it, more OEMs start including it.
- bluGill 6y agoMost people don't care about web cams at work. Most of my meetings I'm looking at a power point, or some other screen and so the person speaking isn't an issue. A few people enable their camera all the time, but not everyone. In the few meetings I've been in where everyone is asked to turn on their camera so we can see each other (in some sort of team terms) at least one person says they are in a family situation where they cannot. Cameras are a must when calling grandma. In an office situation they are at best a nice to have.
- bluescrn 6y agoEven Apple was recently mocked for putting a 720p webcam in their latest 2020 MBP/MBA (while their phones sport clusters of cameras each in silly-megapixel territory)
- toast0 6y agoUgh. 720p is plenty of pixels for the use case, if the sensor is good quality. If the sensor is not good quality, more pixels won't help. Sensor size is a better first approximation of quality than pixel count.