3 ms·
> if you push too far there won't be a union any more, because a portion of those states will walk away from a union As the lopsidedness of representation grow
by triceratops 6y ago
> if you push too far there won't be a union any more, because a portion of those states will walk away from a union
As the lopsidedness of representation grows ever more pronounced, it increases the probability that federal law and policy will diverge significantly from the views of the majority of the nation. This will likely increase disenchantment with the federal government even further, which is just as great a danger to the union. Surely you agree that this situation isn't ideal either, even if the Constitution says it's supposed to be like that?
- jki275 6y agoThey already have. If the people don't want things to be that way, they can pass amendments to change it.
- triceratops 6y agoThey can't though. The states that would lose representation have the most incentive to block amendments. Amendments aren't done by referenda.
- jki275 6y agoAmendments are done by the consent of 2/3s of the states, as is spelled out in the document that governs the union of such states. If you don't want to call that a "referenda", I think you're incorrect, but it doesn't really matter.
- triceratops 6y agoStates != people. People have to vote directly in order for it to be considered a referendum.
- jki275 6y agoIt's a referendum of the states, as was agreed to by the states when the union was formed. It doesn't have to be people voting directly. It shouldn't be.