4 ms·
The thing with antifa (the “anti fascists”) is that their techniques are indistinguishable from fascism: If you say one thing out of line publicly, they hound
by hedora 6y ago
The thing with antifa (the “anti fascists”) is that their techniques are indistinguishable from fascism: If you say one thing out of line publicly, they hound you for the rest of your life.
Like deplatforming, the goal is to deprive people of their right to speech. That’s fundamentally anti-democracy.
Its sad that Antifa became the thing they hate; if the big internet providers follow suit, it’ll be a disaster.
- AshWolfy 6y agoI love when people say this, while on the left we are having debates about if we place too much of an emphasis on deradicalizing and rehabilitating the far right
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The thing with antifa (the “anti fascists”) is that their techniques are indistinguishable from fascism: If you say one thing out of line publicly, they hound you for the rest of your life. I see no evidence of that being true in any substantive way. I’d be surprised if there aren't some people somewhere who fit that description and identify with the antifascist movement, which is a big, diverse, decentralized movement. But I don't see it happening in any significant degree. > Like deplatforming, the goal is to deprive people of their right to speech. No, it's to get other people to exercise their right to free speech to not amplify harmful voices.
- hedora 6y agoHere’s a description of the history of Antifa from the Anti-Defamation League. Note that Antifa is an specific group of self-identifying people, not just everyone that’s against fascism. They have a flag. They’ve been around since the 80’s. Some are violent, some just harass. This is according to the anti-defamation league. The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) has also condemned Antifa in the past: https://www.adl.org/antifa https://www.adl.org/antifa The people you are describing probably are more closely aligned, ideologically with SPLC and ADL (unless they spend their evenings doxing neo-nazis, and shopping for equipment for their next violent counterprotest). I have been donating to and referring people to non-violent anti-fascist groups for years. That’s very different than supporting militant extremists. (Trump designated Antifa a terrorist organization, and I refuse to use that word to describe them.) > No, it’s to get other people to exercise their right to free speech to not amplify harmful voices. So, compelling speech is better than silencing people? Where will it end? Surely the criteria isn’t Republican vs. Democrat. Lets go with “supports violence” Violent far left militants definitely exist, and are “harmful”. Shall we silence them? The ADL and SPLC condemn them, but are also clearly sympathetic. Shall we silence them too? If not, perhaps we should stop them from supporting harmful protests. Antifa could use this map to physically attack lawful groups on the right: https://www.splcenter.org/hate-map https://www.splcenter.org/hate-map Perhaps it should be taken down, at least? I donated money to help create the map. Should I be put on a list and prevented from getting a job?