3 ms·
Simply withdrawing their business presence from Australia would not necessarily remove their liability or remove them from the jurisdiction of Australian courts
by pseudolus 6y ago
Simply withdrawing their business presence from Australia would not necessarily remove their liability or remove them from the jurisdiction of Australian courts. The lack of a business presence is not always a shield against long-arm jurisdiction.
- dheera 6y agoYes but could they do anything? As you said, the lack of a business presence in China was not a shield, and the consequence is that China just blocked them. Australia would be more than welcome to do the same. (But hee hee, we secretly know their citizens would protest if they set up a national firewall.)
- splaytreemap 6y agoHow exactly do you think Australia is going to enforce this mandate if Google has no presence in Australia. Are they going to have the military invade California?
- gamblor956 6y agoWe have treaties addressing issues like these, and generally it is an accepted principle of international law that a country can regulate a company that chooses to business with its citizens.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoBut Google would not be doing business with Australian citizens. It would be serving them webpages, but it would not take nor give them any money. That said, I'm skeptical that such treaties exist. Would you like to point a specific instance of such a treaty out?
- gamblor956 6y ago"Serving them webpages" is a business activity under international law. The consideration is the ads they show alongside search results. As for resources on such treaties, visit the OECD website and you'll be inundated with the model treaties that form the basis of the actual treaties between countries. (Some treaties involve many parties, most are between two nations.) Since you're not paying me, I will simply point out that under America's tax treaty with Australia, the Technical Explanation would note that providing services to another country's citizens is an activity covered by the treaty, and Australia's tax office has plenty of documentation saying the same.