2 ms·
This doesn’t seem like a rational move. Are they going to withdraw from Saudi, from Turkey, any other place that imposes their own laws? If they do, I’d love
by mc32 6y ago
This doesn’t seem like a rational move.
Are they going to withdraw from Saudi, from Turkey, any other place that imposes their own laws?
If they do, I’d love to see Bing and the Duck go in and earn their keep.
Honestly, seeing Twitter, Amazon and now Google do things because it makes them “mad” to me shows they have too much power. I hope the EU puts their foot down and reigns them in.
On the other hand, news orgs can’t have it both ways. Google does not owe them money to index them.
Why can’t Google just not index news sites but provide other services?
- Silhouette 6y agoWhy can’t Google just not index news sites but provide other services? Perhaps their lawyers have a problem with the principle or some ambiguity around it, maybe concerned that search engines could end up retrospectively being found to owe significant money to sites they didn't anticipate, perhaps very many sites they didn't anticipate? I'm hardly a fan of the way big tech firms, Google included, sometimes act, and I do think freeloading based on others' content is a real problem that needs addressing. However, from the legal wording I've seen quoted so far this potential law appears to require a site like Google to pay up merely for linking to content hosted elsewhere, the most basic element of the WWW. If a news site doesn't want people linking to it, maybe the WWW isn't the medium it should use to publish its material?
- mc32 6y agoI think I’m on the same page. The law is ridiculous for requiring remuneration for providing a link but Google and other tech giants wield too much unchecked power and they need to be regulated, maybe broken up.
- plorkyeran 6y agoThis law specifically forbids them from not indexing news sites, because that's exactly what they did when other companies tried similar laws.