14 ms·
Google threatens to withdraw search engine from Australia
- Barrin92 6y agoNow I want this law to happen for the sole purpose of seeing if Google actually flinches. It seems like a silly threat given that there's now a fairly large amount of small search engine providers who would probably thankfully step into that market
- r00fus 6y agoThis law applies to them too. It could essentially create. blackhole of search (at least as it applies to the news sites).
- Barrin92 6y agoI don't think Google opposes the law itself in good faith, because it basically just demands that Google negotiate with media entities for a price-sharing agreement when it comes to showing their content. The Australian search market is obviously still a billion dollar business, the law is not literally 'unworkable' and Google probably knows this. What else is Content ID on Youtube? Third party revenue sharing agreements for content already exist on Google's own platforms. What Google is afraid of is the precedent it sets for other countries to do the same and eat into their search revenue because it would dispel the myth that tech companies cannot be regulated, that's the real danger here.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y ago> it basically just demands that Google negotiate with media entities for a price-sharing agreement This is not an accurate summary of the law's effects. Yes, that's part of what it says. But if they can't come to an agreement, Australia gets to set the price sharing amount. And declining to link to news content isn't allowed, so if it costs Google more than the news is worth, well then it's effectively just a tax that applies to only a single company. This is like if I, the mayor, said, you must negotiate with this man to rent some rooms of your house. If he doesn't like the price you give, I'll decide what it is. No, you can't choose not to rent rooms to him.
- r00fus 6y agoThe inability to decline linking would be truly draconian. Which part of the law states that? (edit:clarity)
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoMaybe I was looking at an older version of the law. The version posted at the top only requires non-differentiation -- that Google cannot decline to index a business because it requires payment. So Google would have to stop indexing news in Australia altogether, but then could avoid payment. That being said, I have seen reporting before that suggests that delisting news, even all news, would not be sufficient to avoid paying under the law.
- hpoe 6y agoOn the one hand I'm usually pretty anti Google most of the time On the other hand without looking at the actual law I remember when the Aussie prime minister said "the laws of mathematics are all well and good but in Australia the laws of Australia take precedence." When taking about backdoors for encryption that only the police could use. A tough spot to be sure.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwitaway1235 6y agoGood for Australia.
- pseudolus 6y agoThey can threaten but ultimately it would be a self-defeating move as, after they withdraw, the sky won't fall and other countries will quickly come to the conclusion that crossing Google is a viable option. A dangerous game for Google and a potential win for alternative search engine options.
- creato 6y agoHow long until Murdoch comes for his cut of bing and DDG's revenue too?
- tziki 6y agoI doubt this law explicitly only applies to Google.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoThat is not true. The law applies to who the Treasurer of Australia decides it applies to.
- dheera 6y agoAustralians won't need alternative search engines. Google can just withdraw their business presence from Australia but continue to provide search. If after that Australia wants to block Google like China that's on them.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoWould above mean Google stop serving ads in Australia? Clearly it's still in Google interest to serve them from afar but there must be some legalities about that. Previously Adwords for Australia was "run" and billed from Singapore for the tax benefits and they were pressured to end this. And a plethora of marketing businesses will go batshit on the government if they force Adwords out of Australia. Adwords is a huge part of the industry. We're going to see this sector struggle for a while if they need to re-adjust.
- iseanstevens 6y agoI would like to see this happen - Getting reasonable placement on Google search has become about giving them money for Ads, or focusing on SEO over content.
- kaishiro 6y agoSorry, but what does this comment have to do with the proposed bill and it's impact on being charged for proferring up news articles?
- fogetti 6y agoThis is counterproductive in an English speaking country. There is a few similarly good alternative like Bing for example. In non-English speaking countries though this strategy might work.
- koonsolo 6y agoBing would be subjected to the same law
- swiley 6y agoMeh, I can't even get to google anymore when I'm visiting my parents. Connecting over cellular (the only option there) just gives me a captcha.
- ipsum2 6y agoNot surprisingly, the article claims are inaccurate. > Australia is introducing a landmark law to make Google, Facebook and potentially other tech companies pay media outlets for their news content. No, Australia is trying to get Google to pay any time they link to a news website. The bill text is here: https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;page=0;query=BillId:r6652%20Recstruct:billhome https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display..... > (1) For the purposes of this Part, a service makes content available if: 19 (a) the content is reproduced on the service, or is otherwise 20 placed on the service; or 21 (b) a link to the content is provided on the service; or 22 (c) an extract of the content is provided on the service. I wonder what will happen to the Google Australia offices.
- NolF 6y agoIs not even a landmark law... Spain and Germany did it first... My understanding is it didn't work too well for publishers due to the decreased traffic...
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIndeed, the problem is that Google is incredibly powerful, and one country at a time fighting them doesn't work. Google cuts them off until they back down. We basically need a large group of countries to agree, at the same time, to make the same demands, to give Google no choice but to comply, or exit the business. (To some degree, the EU is capable of doing this, but enforcement and interpretation of EU directives can be a bit piecemeal.) It's time for countries to start treating Google more like an enemy foreign power than a mere company, especially if it wants to act on that stage.
- Silhouette 6y agoIsn't the point here that Google did exit the business when local laws required it to do so, but that turned out to hurt the media who were previously complaining more than it helped them?
- koonsolo 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mc32 6y agoThis doesn’t seem like a rational move. Are they going to withdraw from Saudi, from Turkey, any other place that imposes their own laws? If they do, I’d love to see Bing and the Duck go in and earn their keep. Honestly, seeing Twitter, Amazon and now Google do things because it makes them “mad” to me shows they have too much power. I hope the EU puts their foot down and reigns them in. On the other hand, news orgs can’t have it both ways. Google does not owe them money to index them. Why can’t Google just not index news sites but provide other services?
- Silhouette 6y agoWhy can’t Google just not index news sites but provide other services? Perhaps their lawyers have a problem with the principle or some ambiguity around it, maybe concerned that search engines could end up retrospectively being found to owe significant money to sites they didn't anticipate, perhaps very many sites they didn't anticipate? I'm hardly a fan of the way big tech firms, Google included, sometimes act, and I do think freeloading based on others' content is a real problem that needs addressing. However, from the legal wording I've seen quoted so far this potential law appears to require a site like Google to pay up merely for linking to content hosted elsewhere, the most basic element of the WWW. If a news site doesn't want people linking to it, maybe the WWW isn't the medium it should use to publish its material?
- mc32 6y agoI think I’m on the same page. The law is ridiculous for requiring remuneration for providing a link but Google and other tech giants wield too much unchecked power and they need to be regulated, maybe broken up.
- plorkyeran 6y agoThis law specifically forbids them from not indexing news sites, because that's exactly what they did when other companies tried similar laws.
- King-Aaron 6y agoI'm not the biggest fan of Googles near-monopoly, but as an Australian I am seriously concerned by the Murdoch monopoly. These laws wouldn't even be in consideration if it weren't for old Rupe pushing the blatantly pro-murdoch government for it.
- offby37years 6y ago"Private companies can do what they want"
- radicalriddler 6y agoNot sure if you're mocking the twitter censorship of Trump (after reading your post history, it would seem you are), but it's not concerning that Rupert Murdoch "wants" to do it, it's concerning that he has the power and influence over our public government to get it done. Apple meet Orange.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tehjoker 6y agoThis is called a "capital strike" and it is an attack on national sovereignty. A mere dictatorially run company can tell an entire democracy what to do?
- missedthecue 6y agoShould Australia be able to force US companies to do what they want?
- lvs 6y agoWithin their jurisdiction? Yes absolutely. That's call the rule of law.
- Silhouette 6y agoOne interesting possibility here would be if Google closed down all Australia-based operations -- no more offices, no legal presence, no employees -- and offered its services to Australians purely over the Internet from somewhere else. At that point, Google wouldn't necessarily be within Australia's jurisdiction any more, and all Australia could really do would be either attempt to block access to Google services that was desired by its citizens (and look like China Lite) or attempt to exert some form of leverage on the host nation(s) from which Google was then offering its services (and since that list would presumably start with the US and possibly be followed by lots of places that want to do business with the US, good luck with that one).
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoBut Google won't be in their jurisdiction any more, right? So everything is working as it should? Not a capital strike on democracy. Simply Google and Australia deciding to go their separate ways.
- missedthecue 6y agoI think that's called slavery. I'm not talking about having rules. I'm talking about forcing them to work and continue to provide services when they don't want to.
- cromwellian 6y agoFrom the text of the bill "(1) For the purposes of this Part, a service makes content available if:... 21 (b) a link to the content is provided on the service..." This is pay for linking. It means anyone linking to a content provider is putting themselves at financial risk. Even if Google withdraws from Oz, whoever becomes the "Baidu" of Australia will essentially be faced with the same issue: They would have built their user base because user search engine demand is driven by content on the internet, one of the main purposes of a search engine is to provide links to that content, and this law exposes any search that links to content to claims on their revenue. Of course, small sites need not worry, we hope, unless people can use the law to launch frivolous lawsuits and nuisance claims, but whoever would replace Google (even DDG) would face the same claims from news providers. The reality is, the news business has been disrupted by the internet. They used to face competition only from a few local or regional competitors, but now the internet puts them into competition with all news providers around the world at the touch of a button. There's no going back to the way things were. In much the same way that music and tv got disrupted by Spotify and Netflix's models, the publishing world needs new business model, and trying to siphon off search engines I don't think is sustainable. They need a Spotify for News. And by that, I mean, content publicly discoverable, but paywalled behind a subscription service, that needs to be super low overhead. A number of distributed mechanisms have been tried, by both Google, and others, at micropayments, but it seems to me that micropayment systems have largely failed for some reason.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoConsidering the two leading search engine companies are in the Fortune 25, I think it's absolutely sustainable to siphon off search engines. They make a massive amount of pure profit, and are amongst the richest companies in the planet in raw cash on hand. And it's also very fair, because search engines are, functionally and fundamentally, content scrapers. Everything they have and everything they offer is done by consuming the work of others.
- Aerroon 6y agoBut search itself isn't the paying feature for either company. If they say "no, thank you" then what do you replace it with? A worse search engine that also loses money? How do Australians come out ahead in this?
- dcw303 6y agoThe way the bill is written is disappointing because it conflates two different things together: For the purposes of this Part, a service makes content available if: (a)the content is reproduced on the service, or is otherwise placed on the service; or (b)a link to the content is provided on the service; or (c)an extract of the content is provided on the service. I think most of us would agree that a search engine being charged for providing links (b) is pretty dumb. But with the rise of content embeds and republishing (a/c), it's a completely different scenario when Facebook is sucking up your content for the benefit of their users. So while I feel this is a raw deal for search engines, it is about time that social media platforms paid their dues.
- tamrix 6y agoAs someone from Australia. I'm okay with this. Let's be real Web search isn't that new or special anymore. Before you cry that Google has the best results, the results are actually fed by data mining users. If we all jumped onto Bing tomorrow, after enough usage, it will have the same results as Google. Amp and Chrome dominating the market is reason enough to ditch Google before it continues to abuse its monopoly like this.
- Mayzie 6y agoAs someone else from Australia, I am not, not is anyone else I have spoken to. Yea, Google needs to be reigned in, but not like this, not with corrupt legislation handing free money to old established news organisations in an attempt to keep them afloat. You do realise other search engines will likely have to comply (or leave the country) too, right?
- denismi 6y agoIf the proposal was to treat Amp, or excessive embedding of content on social media feeds etc., as effectively piracy and prosecuting on that basis then I'd be open to it. But I just can't get behind what is being proposed in any way because it is so absurd and arbitrary. As a supporter of a free and open Internet, I can't see how the logical conclusion of requiring websites to reimburse the other end of a hyperlink for the privilege of linking to them could possibly be a good thing. As a user of the Internet in Australia, I am concerned about what the obvious sovereign risk of the Treasurer having this power to arbitrarily punish web companies does to the availibility of services to Australian users. As a software developer in Australia (albeit one who hasn't worked directly in web tech to date), I am concerned about the damage this does to the tech industry, and subsequently my employability and income, in this country. And most of all as a political citizen of Australia, I am deeply troubled by the idea of giving politicians the power of deciding which media organisations do/don't have the power to arbitrarily extort money out of FAANG as a significant revenue stream.
- Fordec 6y agoFrom a link in another thread[0]: "But iterated games sometimes require a strategy that deviates from apparent first-level rationality, where you let yourself consider lose-lose options in order to influence an opponent's behavior." "Or, in layman's terms, sometimes you have to be a crazy bastard so people won't walk all over you." [0] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/still-alive https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/still-alive
- exabrial 6y agoPlease, Usa next. How do we sign up?
- justaguy88 6y agoThis will give oxygen to those who could build an alternative
- koonsolo 6y agoWhy would you want to build an alternative that is subjected to those same laws? If google can make money, they will. If they can't, they won't. If they pull out of that market, maybe it's a good indicator of the potential benefit of starting such a company.
- jjcm 6y agoAside from the spirit / intent of this law, the way it is written is extremely poor / downright dangerous. Whether or not this law applies to your business online is not based on a set of metrics/rules/requirements, it's based on whether or not the Treasurer[0] of Australia decides it is: https://i.imgur.com/7RSqXDJ.png https://i.imgur.com/7RSqXDJ.png As a company owner you can wake up one day to find that your company is now listed as an official designated digital platform corporation in the Federal Register of Legislation[1] and your finances have completely changed. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasurer_of_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasurer_of_Australia [1] https://www.legislation.gov.au/Browse/Results/ByRegDate/LegislativeInstruments/Asmade/201/0/0/Principal https://www.legislation.gov.au/Browse/Results/ByRegDate/Legi...
- pfundstein 6y agoThe whole thing looks like a desperate money grab. The primary purpose of a search engine is to provide links to content related to the user's search. This gives the content providers visibility. From my understanding this law requires that the search engine pay for listing some media companies as relevant search results. The law also makes it illegal to simply not list those media companies as relevant results. This strikes me as utterly ludicrous.
- nieve 6y agoIt does look pretty awful: "Although the Treasurer, in making the determination, must consider whether there is ‘a significant bargaining imbalance between Australian news providers and the group comprised of the corporation and all of its related bodies corporate’ the determination is not invalid for failure to consider this (s 52C(3))." So there is only one factor they're required to consider for that portion, but they can choose to ignore it without apparent consequences. You can tell this was written specifically as a blatant money grab, something more legitimate would have factors beyond "because we say so" even if only to provide cover.
- mancerayder 6y agoSo... When is news.duckduckgo.com / .au coming out?
- Mayzie 6y agoDoubt it ever will, as DDG/<insert any other search engine here> would be forced to pay up and comply with this ridiculous legislation. Easier to just not bother with a country as small as Australia.
- malwarebytess 6y agoI think that clearly something needs to be done though I don't know what. Something has to give. Search engines are absolutely a parasitic business, for the mere fact that they could not exist without the content they scrape, index, and serve to users. It would be permissible if Google didn't make a profit by doing these things, but they do. So--something needs to be rebalanced. Either search needs to be a public service, non-profit, or there needs to be a profit sharing or some new licensing scheme or law that the content owners are subject to.
- splaytreemap 6y agoIt's the exact opposite of parasitic. Search engines scrape your site so that they can help users find your site. If you don't want Google scraping your content, add a noindex directive or robots.txt to your site and Google won't scrape it or link to it.
- malwarebytess 6y agoAt best it is symbiotic. But the imbalance in power makes it parasitic as Google will absolutely leverage its power to make sure they receive the most out of the arrangement. I think parasite fits better since the content creator can exist without google, but google cannot exist without the content creator.
- ryan-allen 6y agoWhy can't Google simply not return news articles from Australian publishers and be done with it? People will just go to abc.net.au or smh.com.au or news.com.au directly, if that is not their habit already.
- plorkyeran 6y agoThe law explicitly does not allow them to do that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Silhouette 6y agoAn interesting related story that has been hitting the news this evening: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/01/google-agrees-to-pay-french-news-sites-to-send-them-traffic/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/01/google-agrees-to...
- zaptidizap 6y agoMaking a search engine is not as hard as building traffic for it. G quiting au would make it ez.
- NotChina 6y agoDoit! The repeat in he USA!
- dang 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25789773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25789773
- Mayzie 6y agoRespectfully, that is not the same thing. The news article from the OP (and why there's so many today), is because Google just confirmed (/threatened) that it will. That other article from a week ago is just speculation.
- dang 6y agoIt's possible I missed a nuance but I'm not seeing the difference between 'speculation' and 'threat' as significant enough to support a substantively different discussion, which is the criterion we use in such cases: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22significant%20new%20information%22%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=follow-up%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- Mayzie 6y agoWhy is this thread marked as a dupe, despite having many more comments than any other submission / not being merged? And where is a link to this dupe? Now it's just going to be buried.
- stunt 6y agoThe only way to make it work is asking more countries to join. They should plan this together.
- koonsolo 6y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but search engines make money by selling (some) links. Now all of a sudden, governments are expecting them to pay for links? And when the search engine says "Sorry, that's not a good business case for us, we won't be operating in your country", that is considered a "threat"? Look, companies want to make money. If you don't allow them to make money, they won't operate. Is it that hard to understand?
- FrozenVoid 6y agoI think they're going to exit the market until Australian legislation changes, Google will fight it on principle, since the law is essentially adding "link rent" to web searches(and uncertainty to legality of linking itself). However, whats more interesting who will replace them: Yandex(used by DDG) and similar engines(Baidu?) will not be strongarmed by Australian government to pay for links, giving them a competitive advantage..
- dbetteridge 6y agoIf the Australian government wants to try and force Google to make payments that exceed the revenue they get in Australia and is effectively preventing simply de-listing news sites (this is in the code). This seems like a reasonable approach to me. I don't agree generally with a lot of Googles business practices but I feel like this is just a desperate attempt to increase profits by the Murdoch media in Australia. As has been said elsewhere, if news sites don't want their content to be indexed/smart-carded by Google they can set that in their page headers and robots.txt The problem is they want to have their cake and eat it too, they want all the traffic passed through Google but they also want to effectively be paid for the users that never visit their site (Whether or not they ever would have). Disclaimer: Am Australian