2 ms·
> The proper solution would be to publish the code along with the paper so that others could directly review it. Ideally, the raw data would also be published,
by musicale 6y ago
> The proper solution would be to publish the code along with the paper so that others could directly review it. Ideally, the raw data would also be published,
Definitely. Some journals and conferences have badging for papers that also submit their digital artifacts, and also for experiments that have been independently reproduced.
Personally I'd like to see entire journals or conference sessions where the code and experimental data for every paper are available for review.
Sometimes authors can't submit their code for corporate IP reasons and data for privacy or other reasons, but the more digital artifacts that can be submitted, reviewed, and built upon, the better.