3 ms·
> The workflow for modern scientific research always seems so amateurish from the perspective of basic software development. It's sad but it's true. Although t
by mhh__ 6y ago
> The workflow for modern scientific research always seems so amateurish from the perspective of basic software development.
It's sad but it's true. Although there are fundamental pressures that come because academia is academia, I pretty firmly believe that this can be fixed culturally too.
Ultimately, I think people in some fields enjoy programming but view it to be either beneath them or beneath their paper. This is clearly not the case for Computer Science, but I noticed a few papers in the tire society journal which presented promising results but with absolutely no source code.
One slightly ugly truth is that a lot of academics don't really know how to program properly or how computer actually work (Again, outside CS for obvious reasons). I'm reminded of the Imperial Covid Model's bugs as a fairly easy example.
As to culture-question - the obvious solution is to start requiring disclosure of almost all materials and data used to construct a paper - for instance if Hendrik Schon had to publish the data behind the curves in his graphs his fraud could've been spotted almost immediately.
- tehjoker 6y agoI've gotta say, I don't read conservative papers, but I follow news closely, and up to this day I didn't know about the bugs. The media landscape is crazy. However, it looks like they've been updating the model (and are at version 10 on github). I have no idea what their results look like now.
- esyir 6y agoI think the catch here is that people in academia who like cs/eng rapidly leave academia for the much better paying sde/data science roles. Then what you have left are the people who care less about the code, at least in aggregate.