3 ms·
<i>For anything that isn't a car you're gonna want gears for the same reason electric drills have gears. Think of it like low range.</i> Not with modern motor
by Animats 6y ago
<i>For anything that isn't a car you're gonna want gears for the same reason electric drills have gears. Think of it like low range.</i>
Not with modern motor controls. For the last 20 years or so, most new locomotives have used 3-phase AC servo drive motors. It's striking to see one exerting enormous torque to get a train started, yet the Diesel engine generating the power is barely above idle.
Also, no wheel spin. All the wheels can be synchronized electrically. This almost doubles the useful traction.
Early Teslas had a two-speed transmission. It was a flop. The shock loads on gear shifting were too large and the transmissions wore out rapidly. Tesla had to replace all of them. The big advance was liquid-cooled motors. Finally a way to get rid of the excess heat fast enough that you could use full power at zero speed if desired.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoLocomotives have a very different relationship with weight than road going vehicles do. Of course an economy car will have a single speed transmission but vehicles that need to put out peak power at both low speeds and high speed (e.g. the Taycan, and an F250) are going to benefit greatly from a way to optimize for multiple speed ranges.
- XorNot 6y agoI doubt it. There's no reason to bother doing the research to add another mechanical component which can wear and fail early, when you can just put a more powerful electric motor in. That's the thing: the incentive structure has changed. The better use of time and research dollars is going to be just upgrading that motor till it's adequate. There's a logical cap on the maximum road speed you need to accomodate, so the problem is eventually "solved" in practical terms.
- bluGill 6y agoWe have already put the effort into making transmissions though. Not a lot off research dollars needs to go into the problem at this point. It might or might not be worth it, but transmissions that last as long as the car with no maintenance are common (oil changes are recommended, but few people do).