7 ms·
I wouldn't be surprised if at some point some manufacturer made a car with optional "stick shift" - with a stick that's just some switches and the effect on dri
by detaro 6y ago
I wouldn't be surprised if at some point some manufacturer made a car with optional "stick shift" - with a stick that's just some switches and the effect on driving behavior/torque/... entirely done in software. (Right now electric is hot and new, so nobody is doing much to make an electric car pretend to be something it's not, but that could switch around when electric is the standard)
- gambiting 6y agoThere is a car exactly like this....in China. It's used for driver training, and I suspect it will start being popular elsewhere. In all of EU if you pass your licence on an automatic(which nearly all electric cars are) you can't drive a manual, you have to pass your licence in a manual car. And that's why that car was created, to allow people to pass their test in a manual vehicle and have a licence that allows driving them, even though the vehicle is electric. https://jalopnik.com/this-chinese-electric-car-designed-for-driving-schools-1844071179 https://jalopnik.com/this-chinese-electric-car-designed-for-... "The various inputs of clutch and shifter work with software in the car that cause it to behave like a manual, ICE car, with shift points, simulated engine sounds, and it can even “stall” if you let off the clutch too quickly."
- alasdair_ 6y agoPart of me wants to create a fake gearbox and clutch kit for an automatic car that does absolutely nothing, but looks convincing to driving examiners. You can just change "gears" when you feel like it without any actual effect and the clutch is just a dumb pedal.
- ThePadawan 6y ago> and the clutch is just a dumb pedal Thus completely negating training on a manual? Learning how to effectively use the clutch pedal to me was like, 90% of learning to drive.
- jusssi 6y agoAccelerating to a highway would be a dead giveaway to an examiner. Those who learn to use the clutch well enough in the mandatory 20 hours to do it as smooth as automatic gear are few and far between. And obviously they are the ones who wouldn't need to fake it anyway.
- taneq 6y agoYeah, it'd be like when a TV character "plays" a guitar with dubbed music without moving their left hand.
- alasdair_ 6y agoThis is a complete aside, but I was extremely impressed by the NPCs in the Cyberpunk 2077 video game, where every tune they play has correct movements on the guitar for each chord.
- bluGill 6y agoI would think the examiner can also tell because the car does change acceleration, and the engine noise changes. That said, as an American who prefers a manual, I'm not sure why Europe cares so much. It is a skill to learn, but it isn't that hard to learn: I've taught a few people. They have some rough starts (and avoid hills for a while), but the need to shift isn't something that affects how they drive once they get off my street.
- gambiting 6y agoAt least here in Poland you can only take the exam in the car provided by the testing centre, you can't have the exam in your own car(with some exceptions like when you need to have a car adjusted to your disabilities)
- Tor3 6y agoI believe that's the case all over Europe. That the US apparently or supposedly allows taking a car driver's license exam in your private car is.. extremely surprising.
- gambiting 6y agoIt's not in UK(I realize it's not part of the EU any more, but even when it was it was the same). You take the exam in your own car or a car provided by the training school. The exam centres don't have cars.
- nix23 6y ago>your own car or a car provided by the training school. The exam centres don't have cars. Same in Switzerland.
- ryanmercer 6y ago>That the US apparently or supposedly allows taking a car driver's license exam in your private car is.. extremely surprising. At last here in Indiana, you have to provide your own car to take the driving test in.
- Ancapistani 6y agoUS drivers’ licensing is much less rigorous than Europe’s as I understand it. In Arkansas, where I live, I got a “learner’s permit” at 14 having passed a short written test. I got my full license at 16 after passing the road test, which consisted of driving for perhaps ten minutes with a cop in the passenger’s seat. I had to drive around the parking lot, navigate and park between traffic cones, then drive the testing route. The testing route started in an industrial part of town with very little traffic and consisted of driving about a mile to a residential neighborhood, circling the block, and coming back to the testing center. I remember being surprised that I didn’t have to demonstrate parallel parking or even driving on a highway. I think I “studied” for the written test by skimming the handout brochure at school during lunch, and had no issues. The driving test was a joke; I’m very confident my 7-year-old could pass it today based only on her having driven utility vehicles (e.g., a Kubota RTV) around our family’s property and having watched us drive from the back seat. Apparently Arkansas revised the licensing system in 2009, and now there is an “Intermediate” license for people under 18. That license is restricted from driving from 11pm to 4am (with exceptions), prohibited from using a cell phone while driving (with exceptions), and all passengers must be wearing a seat belt. If you’re married, in the military, have graduated high school (or equivalent) or have been legally emancipated you can get your full license at the age of 16 years and six months. This discussion had me curious about how the very different licensing regimes might impact outcomes, so I looked up some statistics on motor vehicle fatalities. US (2018): * 12.4 per 100k residents * 14.2 per 100k vehicles Europe (2016) * 9.3 per 100k residents * 19 per 100k vehicles Poland (2019) * 7.7 per 100k residents * 13.5 per 100k vehicles Honestly, I don’t think there’s a substantial impact. The US has 838 vehicles per 1k residents compared to Poland’s 719. I strongly suspect that US drivers drive substantially more miles per year on average, which would more than account for the per capita numbers. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...
- kindall 6y agoSubaru CVTs already have essentially this feature. The transmission doesn't have gears (duh, it's continuously variable) but it still has the ability to manually shift to predefined ratios.
- Cd00d 6y agoAnd it's horrible. I was a dedicated manual driver, but 3 years in an Outback with CVT and flappy paddles - it's miserable as an analogy of shifting. You can trigger several "down shifts", but there's some elastic feel in the system that doesn't convert to slowing the car via engine revs or give the feeling of immediate power. I gave up on the paddles early on.
- tshaddox 6y agoTheir CVTs also use these simulated gears during normal automatic driving, presumably just to make it feel more like a traditional automatic (which it mostly does, to my untrained senses). Apparently this is important to the car-buying market, although I don’t understand why.
- wtallis 6y agoCar reviewers love to complain about how a CVT lets the engine rev up to high RPMs and just stay there the whole time you're accelerating. Which is of course the entire point, but some people apparently prefer that their car spend lots of time at suboptimal RPMs, probably so that they don't have to break the habit of flooring it unnecessarily.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoIt's completely subjective but it just sounds wrong. Like being in a car with a slipping clutch. Apparently enough people feel the same the it's easier to fake real gears than change the market.
- bluGill 6y agoAccording to physics an ICE is most fuel efficient at 90% throttle and low RPM. At high RPM, or lower throttle positions you lose efficiency. So if you want maximum fuel efficiency you need to put the throttle to the floor, but stay at low RPMs. Thus the CVT is not doing the right thing for fuel efficiency. (though I'm not sure if the difference is worth measuring) Obviously the exact numbers varies a bit from engine to engine.
- bacon_waffle 6y ago> nobody is doing much to make an electric car pretend to be something it's not This is actually one of the aspects of the Leaf that most impressed/surprised me - Nissan put a lot of thought in to making it behave like an ICE car with an automatic/CV transmission. For example, when the car is in D mode, sitting on flat ground, if you take your foot off the brake, it'll roll forward at low power. Similarly, taking your foot off the accelerator while rolling faster will apply just a little bit of regeneration.
- fy20 6y agoThe Prius has that too. It doesn't need to, but as you say, they wanted it to feel like a regular car.
- viraptor 6y agoIt makes more sense to me to be honest. If I want to roll just a little bit to get a better position in a parking box, I don't want my foot to leave the break or be super careful about accelerating. I want to just barely move / not-be-stopped, and this implementation works just fine.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoYeah, my father-in-law drives an automated manual car which doesn't do this automatically. It's actually a strange car to drive because of that, it also changes at a snails pace so you have to drive pretty leasurely. Our car which is the Ford Power shift dual clutch system which changes pretty much seamlessly and does creep on its own.
- alasdair_ 6y agoDon't all electric cars do this? I know all Teslas have this option (you can disable it in settings if you wish).
- sokoloff 6y agoElectric motors have maximum torque from 0 RPM, which removes most of the need for a transmission. Think of it as a transmission being a patch for a limitation in a combustion engine. If you were switching from electric to ICE, you’d need to invent this patch.
- elihu 6y agoAnd yet... for whatever torque the motor supplies at 0 RPM, you could have 4 times as much torque with a 4:1 1st gear. As I see it, a manual stick EV would be pretty good in combination with a modestly-powerful drive system like what's in the Nissan Leaf, as opposed to something like a high-end Tesla (where you have enough power that shifting gears doesn't matter as much).
- varjag 6y agoThere's no need. We're very much EV-only since 2014, am yet to drive one that is underpowered in any practical driving circumstances.
- rlpb 6y ago> And yet... for whatever torque the motor supplies at 0 RPM, you could have 4 times as much torque with a 4:1 1st gear. There's no point. The tyres can't provide that much traction. My Leaf wheelspins if I put my foot down at 0 RPM (until the traction control kicks in to moderate the torque). I assume it has no gearbox.
- elihu 6y agoThat's actually something I've wondered about. It seems like what you're saying may be true, but on the other hand you have cars like the White Zombie. (I know it's builder, John Wayland; he's giving me advice in my own more modest conversion.) The car started out as about a 1500 pound 70's Datsun, and with a dual-motor setup and some expensive batteries it can supposedly do 0-60 in about 1.7 seconds or so. If the Leaf is already at the point where adding more power doesn't help because you'd just spin the tires, how do cars like the White Zombie get around that? The Leaf is front wheel drive I believe whereas the White Zombie is rear wheel drive. That probably accounts for some of it. Maybe the WZ also has a limited slip differential and some kind of high-traction tires? I don't know; drag racing is pretty far outside my area of expertise. (Another random anecdote about the White Zombie: according to John, he always wanted to have a transmission, but they kept breaking whenever he tried to use one, so eventually he just settled on direct drive.)
- taneq 6y agoI've always wanted to replace the gearstick in an AWD electric car with a torque split lever that controls both acceleration and braking distribution and basically gives you thrust vectoring. Pull it back under acceleration and you can spin the rear wheels, or under braking and you can do a handbrake turn. Push it left or right in a turn to control drift angle. When stationary, go full left or right to skid steer on the spot. The stunts you could do with such a setup would be insane.
- danans 6y agoMany EVs already work this way. Mine has 6 "speeds" controlled by paddle shifters that create "engine braking" by changing the regenerative braking level. It is 100% a software/UI thing because if I press the brake pedal moderately it does the exact same thing, but continuously instead of in discrete steps.