8 ms·
Electric motors don't need a transmission. Adding a stick shift is just adding complexity for no benefit. It's more stuff to maintain and more parts to break
by jandrese 6y ago
Electric motors don't need a transmission. Adding a stick shift is just adding complexity for no benefit. It's more stuff to maintain and more parts to break and is going to make the car slower due to parasitic losses and inefficiencies.
If you're shooting for 200kph+ speeds there might be a time where a simple high/low transmission may be helpful, but that's supercar territory.
Interestingly, Formula E cars have a 5 speed gearbox, but mostly because the rules says they have to.
- mywittyname 6y ago>Interestingly, Formula E cars have a 5 speed gearbox, but mostly because the rules says they have to. This is no longer required. A few teams stuck with the five speed, but most have dropped to three or four speeds. The Formula E cars still need gearboxes because there isn't a single gear ratio that can provide optimal acceleration between 0 and 175mph with an 18,000 RPM redline. The massive powerband of the motors means that they don't benefit from as many gears as piston engines do, but there is still a benefit to having more than one gear. The next generation cars will go dual-motor, presumably each with different final drive ratios: a shorter gear on the front motor for low-speed power, and a taller rear end gear for top speed, but this is speculation on my part.
- ben-schaaf 6y ago> This is no longer required. A few teams stuck with the five speed, but most have dropped to three or four speeds. Even in the 2nd season there were teams with 2 gears and since the gen 2 car most are on one now: https://www.electronicspecifier.com/news/analysis/latest-generation-of-transmissions-for-formula-e-season-2020 https://www.electronicspecifier.com/news/analysis/latest-gen...
- elihu 6y ago> Electric motors don't need a transmission. Adding a stick shift is just adding complexity for no benefit. That isn't true. Having low gears gives you more torque with less current at slow speeds. Most EVs take the philosophy of "it's easier to just use a more powerful motor than deal with a transmission". But that doesn't mean that a transmission wouldn't be helpful (especially if you want good performance out of a more modest motor, or with fewer batteries that can't produce as much current).
- agumonkey 6y agoHonest question, isn't a gearless EV very very sufficient for the average use case ? I liked the idea of near no mechanical intermediate. I also read that Porsche kept a 2 gear for higher max speed. I understand the mechanical advantage in some cases but it seems quite fringe now.
- nickik 6y agoThis is a strange way to look at it. The assumption seems to be we want to keep the motor cheap but then connect it to a transmission and that is supposed to be cheaper then simply using a slightly better motor? Pretty sure its isn't and that's why 99% of EV don't use them.