3 ms·
The judge went so far as to explain why Parler's motion fails on all of the points, not just the "likelihood of success on the merits". That's a pretty irate ju
by jcranmer 6y ago
The judge went so far as to explain why Parler's motion fails on all of the points, not just the "likelihood of success on the merits". That's a pretty irate judge: they're going out of their way, incurring more work upon themselves, to berate you.
The only surprising things here are a) it took the judge a week to deny this motion, and b) AWS hasn't asked for the case to be transferred to arbitration (given the mandatory arbitration clause in the TOS somewhere).
- akersten 6y ago> (given the mandatory arbitration clause in the TOS somewhere). This was the most surprising angle to me - that the case didn't fail prima facie on this clause alone. I guess at least it serves to really emphasize how bad of a case they brought.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The judge went so far as to explain why Parler’s motion fails on all of the points, Well, actually, they said that it could pass on irreperable harm, but that was somewhat mitigated by the fact that much (but not all) of the harm could be addressed by money damages. It did fail the the other 3 elements, and the balancing test in the alternate Ninth Circuit criteria.
- someguydave 6y agoIn the balancing test the judge asserted that granting the TRO would do damage to AWS, which is laughable. The bias here is clear.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe harm to AWS is in "interfer[ing] with AWS’s ability to prevent its services from being used to promote—and, as the events of January 6, 2021 have demonstrated, even cause—violence." I wouldn't call that a laughable claim...
- someguydave 6y agoPlenty of people have posted similar or worse things on Twitter without moderation by Twitter or much shame to Twitter's upstream service providers. Also, can you draw a direct causal line between AWS hosted Parler posts and actual violence that took place on Jan 6th?
- tptacek 6y agoProbably†, but they don't have to. AWS's AUP sets the bar for what is or isn't acceptable on AWS, and AWS has 64 pages of Parler posts that contravened that AUP, many of which AWS warned Parler about and got no response. † We'll all know soon enough, since Parler got dumped by a trivial IDOR vulnerability almost the moment AWS gave them notice they were going to be taken offline.
- someguydave 6y agoYes, but apparently the work of drawing causal inference is unneeded because the judge already assumed it in her ruling, perhaps using her amazing oracular or exploit powers.
- curryst 6y agoI actually agreed with you until I read the order. It's about public good. Parler is arguing that Amazon is part of a cartel and that that's harmful to public, so the injunction restores fairness to the market. The judge finds that meritless because they have no evidence that the cartel exists, and so the injunction does nothing for the public good. I'm certain the factual errors about AWS hosting Twitter's feed didn't help. Amazon argues that Parler had a role in the insurrection, so banning them is in the public good. Given the amount of content from the insurrection on Parler, it seems more likely than not that at least one person there was influenced by Parler. There is no requirement that absolute proof be shown, the judge is weighing probabilities here. It also helps Amazon that injunctive reliefs are considered an extraordinary measure, so Amazon wins by default unless Parler can reach a significant bar. This was a moonshot, and Parler knew it. They're asking for a strong legal response based on a pretty flimsy case. Even if what they are saying is true (which I strongly doubt, but what if), they simply don't have the evidence they need to get this relief.