3 ms·
You are trading off cost, though. According to that paper I referenced, the SMART reallocated sector count is just binary (the critical threshold is 1 sector).
by jeffbee 6y ago
You are trading off cost, though. According to that paper I referenced, the SMART reallocated sector count is just binary (the critical threshold is 1 sector). Drives with non-zero counts are much more likely to fail but 85% of them are still in service a year later. If you proactively replace them you may indeed have avoided some surprise failures but it's actually not a great deal more effective than replacing drives randomly, and it costs money.
Also we haven't even discussed the online disk repair phenomenon, in which you take a "failed" disk, perform whatever lowest-level format routine the manufacturer has furnished, and get another 5 years of service out of it. This is done without ever touching it.