5 ms·
FWIW, the Netherlands is now under curfew: "Further, one person will be allowed to walk their dog on a leash at a time. However, Rutte asked that people not tr
by DonHopkins 6y ago
FWIW, the Netherlands is now under curfew:
"Further, one person will be allowed to walk their dog on a leash at a time. However, Rutte asked that people not try to skirt the rules by arranging for a "loaner dog" if Parliament approves the curfew. "
"If you're going to pass around your dog among the whole family so everyone can go out late into the night, that's just really stupid."
https://nltimes.nl/2021/01/20/rutte-curfew-undesirable-needed-netherlands-ban-flights-uk https://nltimes.nl/2021/01/20/rutte-curfew-undesirable-neede...
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat is the danger of a single person walking by themselves, sans dog, outside at night? It seems like half the government reactions to lock down is a good idea based on the understanding of virus transmission, and the other half is just security theater. Does this hurt the government's own efforts? Any reasonable person will understand that they aren't hurting anyone by walking outside near no one. Or two people from the same household walking their dog at night near no one. This may make people generally less likely to follow all the rules, because they see that half the rules are just made up nonsense.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoI have similar misgivings about this policy. One possibly reasoning that I've seen, and that isn't entirely implausible, is that there is still significant transmission going on in private gatherings, which tend to happen in the evenings. These curfews would then be attempts to curb such behaviour.
- bluesign 6y agoEnforcement. You need to be able to set rules, you can enforce easily. If you allow single person walking, what will you do if you see 2 people close to each other. People will always try to avoid the rules, so in this kind of stuff enforcement is really hard. Better to have hard but short lived restrictions.
- gpvos 6y agoThe idea of a curfew is that there are as few possible people outside, so there is some chance that the police has the capacity to check on those who are there. Yes, it's very unpleasant, but may be necessary in some cases.
- m000 6y agoThe rationale of the government is that they want to reduce casual house gatherings. Walking out in a winter night in the Netherlands is hardly a leisure activity. If you're walking outside at night, chances are you are going to, or returning from a social gathering. So while unpleasant, the amount of security theater isn't particularly high.
- jacquesm 6y agoAnd also: the dog has to be on a leash, which is a physical link between two objects, one of type 'dog' and one of type 'man' to avoid accidental one-to-many relationships between an instance of 'dog' and multiple instances of 'man' (as in 'mankind'). You are not allowed to put multiple leashes on the same dog. And you are also not allowed to claim that a dog that is sans leash is yours.. Enterprising folks are already offering their dogs for rent. Insert rust joke about the borrow checker here... Even more enterprising folks are researching whether walking cats is permitted and whether small rodents can be typecast to the class of 'dog'.
- rory 6y agoNo need to typecast as long as you can teach the rodents to bark, since the police should be using Dog Typing anyhow.
- DonHopkins 6y agoLike the opposite of Rover and Wag, a gig economy for dogs instead of people, where they deliver you a dog to walk during coronavirus curfews: Deliverpoo, aka Poober Walkies: 24/7 doorstep delivery dog rental, guaranteed well fed and ready to go. Need to go out for brisk jog through the city at night to meet up with a drug dealer or pimp? Rent a fully loaded Doberman or German Shepherd to accompany and defend you. Feel more like a slow romantic moonlit walk along the beach? Rent an adorable economy wiener dog.
- mssundaram 6y agoCooping people up in the winter is how we used to believe would cause illness to spread. Why are we doing it on purpose now?
- tremon 6y agoIt's an indirect measure. The target of the measure is not to prohibit being outside (although that is the first-order effect), but to prevent mixing households. The real reason is that you're not allowed to coop up with guests in your home, but the police is not allowed to enter private residences and enforce that. So the night-time curfew is now being floated as the one thing that they can enforce to discourage people spending their evening with friends. Of course, it does nothing to discourage day-time visits, and I suspect evenings-with-friends will now turn into adult sleepover parties, but I guess we're still big on symbolism. In my opinion, it'd be better if the government just declared the battle against Covid lost. They've tried for a year to appeal to the better nature of our citizens, and those citizens have democratically elected not to care about Covid. But at the same time, I know that openly tossing the towel will only lead to more people ignoring the measures.