3 ms·
If we can expect more surprises like this, movement will have to be curtailed till we’re sure we have things under control (like SARS). We can’t have the whole
by mc32 6y ago
If we can expect more surprises like this, movement will have to be curtailed till we’re sure we have things under control (like SARS).
We can’t have the whole world economy in lockdown because a new strain spread because prior immunization is ineffective against the variant.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoIt would seem that the horse is already out of the barn. Flights would have needed to be curtailed much earlier. In addition, we're seeing similar mutations popping up independently in geographical areas - seems to be evolutionary pressure in these directions.
- mc32 6y agoUnderstood, but if we can contain the mutations regionally, it’s better than having them spread globally.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoThe rise of these variants shows that we have to do a much better job with genomic analysis and surveillance and we have to be willing to be more proactive about shutting down travel to/from regions where these variants show up. I'm just not sure we have the political will to do what the science would suggest - we didn't for the original covid-19 and as it spread around the world political leaders of all stripes were slow to listen to the scientists. I guess I'm not sure that's going to change.
- Loughla 6y agoI think you lost me. How can we have an unfettered economy, not limited by lockdowns AND contain mutations regionally? These two statements you have made seem to be at odds with one another. Or am I overthinking/underthinking this?
- mc32 6y agoOne affects the global economy, the alternative affects a local economy, for example.
- Loughla 6y agoThe local economy is the global economy. Things I make here get shipped there, unless my business is shut down because of local mandates. Then nothing gets shipped over there. I think you're oversimplifying and I can't figure out how to explain myself.
- mc32 6y agoLet’s say you produce wine in France. France has a new variant. We shut France down. You’re French and live there. You’re affected. I’m in Mauritania, I keep on working unaffected by your shutdown. You’re saying it’s preferable to have your economy, my economy and everyone else’s economy because... it’s better for you if we all get shut down?
- Loughla 6y agoNo, I'm saying a local shut down in the economy may/does have impacts further reaching than the local economy, and that your statement is flawed. Shutting down local economies is exactly what shuts down global supply chains/economies. It's not like you can carve France out of the global economy and act like they don't exist for three months. It's not as simple as you're saying, is what my point is.
- mc32 6y agoOk I won’t dispute this assertion, I will assert that a focused local lockdown is better than a global lockdown.
- beamatronic 6y agoWith total and complete mask compliance.
- beamatronic 6y agoIf you COORDINATE lockdowns and everyone works in harmony they can be very short. You could even schedule them in advance.
- icedchai 6y agoGetting everyone to work in harmony is basically impossible. If a politician goes on the news and say you need to stay home for 2 weeks starting next Friday, what do you thinks going to happen? Mass panic buying and looting? People refusing to do it because it's a conspiracy? Mass protest events encouraging super spreading? By the time this is all over, 2 weeks has passed...
- mc32 6y agoChina. A totalitarian state with massive centralization can’t get everyone to do things in unison. Imagine the rest of the world, save North Korea .
- sjg007 6y agoMy guess is we will need to FDA approve the mRNA vaccine development platform so we can develop a cocktail of spike mRNA vaccines and you will take 1 or more of them. We will need some kind of rapid clinical trial procedure to get updated mRNAs tested.. I am not sure what they do with the yearly flu vaccine in this regard but a similar approach is necessary. Then we will need a rapid surveillance program as well. We will also need to update / create more antibody treatments like Regeneron's. But that's a lot of technology to solve the wear a mask and social distance problem. We need to keep the fire from spreading because it will just come back and burn down the things it missed the first time. I suspect we will be dealing with rolling covid lockdowns for the next 10+ years.