7 ms·
Did the state department issue an announcement or ask Twitter to do this? Otherwise Twitter is interfering in foreign diplomacy and governments, be they legal,
by mc32 6y ago
Did the state department issue an announcement or ask Twitter to do this?
Otherwise Twitter is interfering in foreign diplomacy and governments, be they legal, illegal, authoritarian or democratic.
Twitter should not be making these calls. This is a decision for the State Department to make.
- dragonwriter 6y agoTwitter is exercising free speech rights, the same as when it suspended Trump's account. People need to stop acting like Twitter is supposed to act as an organ of the US government.
- redwine11 6y agoNeed to lose section 230 protection then. Can't be an editorial and have liability protection.
- borski 6y agoThey aren’t editorializing; they are arguably trying to remove potential liabilities from their service. If you walk into my bar and start screaming racist nonsense, I am well within my rights to ask you to leave the bar, and I do not have to let you back in. That doesn’t also suddenly make me liable for the nonsense you spewed.
- redwine11 6y agoCorrect because you could be potential liable if you did nothing, right now they have no liability and the ability to have editorial control.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Need to lose section 230 protection then. Can't be an editorial and have liability protection. The entire point of section 230 is to enable editorial control so long as you aren't the content creator/submitter without the kinds of civil liability tied to “publisher” status otherwise, for both platforms and users on those platforms who are empowered to act in ways which have editorial impact. And a one-sentence “you can't do X and Y” isn't really a substantive argument against Section 230.
- redwine11 6y agoMy understanding is they receive liability protection because they have no real editorial control, instead acting like a ISP
- dragonwriter 6y ago> My understanding is they receive liability protection because they have no real editorial control, Your understanding is wrong. They receive liability protection for editorial decisions as a means of removing the disincentive for them to exercise editorial control that would otherwise exist.
- redwine11 6y agoYou are correct, that is how the law is currently constructed, that is why I am for section 230 reform. They should not be able to objectively edit content as they see fit while also being given liability protection. Give them the option, you get liability protection but can not censor free speech or you do not get liability protection and can edit content as they see fit. Right now they have their cake and can eat it too.
- Udik 6y agoHmm.. That makes me wonder. Do "free speech" rights apply when it's not your speech? I mean, Twitter is not an editor, whatever it publishes is not its speech, it's someone else's.
- mc32 6y agoYeah it’s as if they’re saying that indeed they agree with all the Tweets they don’t moderate since it’s “their speech”.
- jasonv 6y agoNo. They can agree, not agree, have no opinion, have no consideration, not even see. They can also take the position that some things they really, really can't abide.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Yeah it’s as if they’re saying that indeed they agree with all the Tweets they don’t moderate Nope, publishers often (sometimes with explicit notice to avoid doubt) publish things they disagree with because they think there is value in publishing it. They often also exercise their free speech/press rights to not publish other things they disagree with, even if they are submitted to them for publication.
- andrewprock 6y agoThat's where things are getting confused. Anything Twitter publishes is 100% their speech, and they have a free speech right to say what they like, and not say what they don't like.
- mc32 6y ago? So if someone gets defamed (me too entanglement) by someone else via Twitter it’s on Twitter and not the actual person who defamed the other?
- andrewprock 6y ago
- pb7 6y agoIt’s just a website. The world spun before it and it will continue spinning after it.
- mc32 6y agoYeah, it’s just a coffee shop, you can go buy your pastry elsewhere, the world won’t stop.
- pb7 6y agoYes... you can. Why are you acting like this can’t happen today? Any store can turn you away for any reason that isn’t a protected class.
- mc32 6y agoForeign governments are a protected class within the governmental community. Can Twitter ban members of protected classes if they don’t ban all members of a protected class, can the coffee shop do the same?
- gruez 6y agoThe same foreign governments that regularly get sanctioned? Doesn't seem very "protected" to me.
- mc32 6y agoRight, but it’s not Willy-nilly. There is a process and chain of command, etc. It’s not something someone in the state department wakes up and decides, eh, I don’t like what Castro said. Let’s sanction them now. No, they have to offer reasons and go through chain of command.
- gruez 6y agoYou seem to be conflating "protected" with "requiring diligence before action is taken". You simply can't fire someone for being in a protected class. No amount of "process and chain of command, etc" is going to change that. It's not like you can't be fired by a manager willy-nilly for being black, but if it goes all the way up to the CEO it's totally fine.
- AlexandrB 6y ago> Otherwise Twitter is interfering in foreign diplomacy and governments, be they legal, illegal, authoritarian or democratic. This is giving Twitter way too much credit (and too much power). When did a stupid 280chr “microblogging” platform become a channel for foreign diplomacy? To make an absurd comparison, should we consider the politics subreddit a diplomatic venue too?
- joshuakelly 6y ago> When did a stupid 280chr “microblogging” platform become a channel for foreign diplomacy? Approximately in 2009. That's the date of the first known public example of the State Department influencing Twitter operations for diplomatic purposes. In that case, it was to lobby Twitter to delay a scheduled shutdown because of events happening in Iran. > To make an absurd comparison, should we consider the politics subreddit a diplomatic venue too? Any highly trafficked site co-ordinated and administered in the United States is, yes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pengaru 6y agoTwitter's users are essentially volunteer contributors on a privately owned and operated web site, and Twitter has every right to do as it pleases with whatever content it hosts. This is basically whining about the actions of mods on a free web forum. Maybe governments shouldn't be using some poorly run private sector web site to communicate with the public.
- whimsicalism 6y agoPerhaps we can have a discussion about the power of various private actors without resorting to calling critiques of that power "whining." FWIW, I think you are confusing what is legally permissible today with the normative statement by GP that Twitter shouldn't be the one making these calls.
- ardy42 6y ago> Otherwise Twitter is interfering in foreign diplomacy and governments, be they legal, illegal, authoritarian or democratic. > Twitter should not be making these calls. Twitter should totally should be making the calls. If the CCP wants to put a big propaganda poster in my front yard "for diplomatic reasons," I'd tell them to fuck off. Neither I nor Twitter have any obligation to carry the messages of any regime. If they want to do diplomacy, they can send a representative to the State Department. If their government wants to communicate, let it use mechanisms it actually controls.
- mc32 6y agoMy problem is that this is a decision for the state department, not a blogging platform to make.
- ardy42 6y ago> My problem is that this is a decision for the state department, not a blogging platform to make. I disagree with that strongly. If it was the State Department's decision, I'd have to host the CCP's propaganda in my yard until State Department told me to take it down. Twitter isn't interfering with government-to-government diplomacy, so there's no diplomatic issue here.