3 ms·
I think this is a good example of why in-kind benefits programs are a problem, and if you want to relieve the effects of poverty you should just give people mon
by pjc50 6y ago
I think this is a good example of why in-kind benefits programs are a problem, and if you want to relieve the effects of poverty you should just give people money.
There was a recent UK scandal over the food boxes being handed out as a substitute for free school meals while schools are closed; it was immediately obvious to anybody who has ever shopped for their own groceries that the intermediary company was taking the £30, skimming off most of it, and providing a deeply inadequate result: https://www.dw.com/en/food-parcels-for-kids-spark-outrage-in-uk/a-56217308 https://www.dw.com/en/food-parcels-for-kids-spark-outrage-in...
(I note that even in the British NHS, dental and optical services are not completely free at the point of use: https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/dental-costs/understanding-nhs-dental-charges/ https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/dental-costs/unders... )
- randompwd 6y agoI think you just made a case for why news outlets shouldn't write articles based on random tweets without verifying anything- that lie is now fact in some peoples minds: > Chartwells, the school catering company that supplied the package, claimed the photograph showed five days of free lunches, not 10, and the charge for food, packing and distribution was £10.50 not £30, https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/jan/12/food-parcel-first-policy-under-pressure-after-outcry-from-parents-in-england https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/jan/12/food-parce...
- pjc50 6y agoThat's what they claim, but is that actually true? Anyway, the campaign got the policy changed; Starmer went and looked at the DFE guidence to check that the expected parcel really was that bad. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2021-01-13/debates/C803B575-B4A6-43A2-A036-E4C716636D69/OralAnswersToQuestions#contribution-1A3673DA-B3BB-4CCA-8B01-B07903530361 https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2021-01-13/debates/C80...
- bluGill 6y agoThe problem is the poor I want to help most are the poor who cannot take care of themselves. Those who can take care of the money (as opposed to giving it to scammers) can also figure out how to get more and just need the government out of the way. (this is the conservative lower taxes point). What is left is a lot of people with mental issues who can never take care of themselves and wouldn't use the money to do it. The money needs to go to some ??? that will take care of those people.
- pjc50 6y ago> Those who can take care of the money can also figure out how to get more and just need the government out of the way. (this is the conservative lower taxes point) Yes, and it's evidence-free nonsense, because many of those people are either not earning at all, often for very good reasons, or earning below the lower tax threshold. You might be able to make a case for abolishing sales tax/VAT, but at least in the UK food is already exempt from VAT.
- camjohnson26 6y agoThat’s a dismissive attitude. There’s plenty of people who are poor through flaws in the system and no fault of their own, and there’s also plenty who are stuck in patterns of addiction where free money will exacerbate that.
- throwaway2245 6y agoIt's hard to understand how you can take this point of view if you've ever met an average poor person. (The "poor who cannot take care of themselves" are a minority who require different support) One definition of poor is that people do not have access to enough money to meet their needs. And, poor people cannot meet the needs of getting more money: tasks such as education, job search, etc, are limited by an immediate need to get rent, food, and warmth. If the government "gets out of the way", the safety net of being near-guaranteed to cover rent, food and warmth, will also quickly get out of the way, exacerbating poor peoples' problems.
- bluGill 6y agoAs Adam Smith observed, excess money tends to go into rent. The poor in India sleep on a sidewalk. The poor in the US have a 2 bedroom apartment with running water and a TV. Both sets struggle to make ends meet (I struggle to make ends meet sometimes, and I'm clearly well above average in the upper middle class with 6 months of emergency savings that I dare not touch), so struggle to make ends meet is NOT what it means to be poor. Everybody will try to make their lives better. Anyone who isn't careful will end up spending so much on little things that they can't afford the basics at the end of the month. I've been poor (for the US - a much higher standard than poor elsewhere!), and I have no desire to go back. I will agree the poor who cannot take care of themselves are a minority. However I maintain that given money to the rest won't help because they will spend it on things like a nicer apartment. Worse I fear that their attempt to get a nicer apartment will make rent go up and in the end they spend more money on the same apartment - thus making that extra money an indirect handout to the rich.