3 ms·
The free market is a really simple feedback system that, in any real-world implementation, can just as quickly lose the "mutual self-interest" part, or replace
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
The free market is a really simple feedback system that, in any real-world implementation, can just as quickly lose the "mutual self-interest" part, or replace "cooperation" with "coercion". The very problem with the clinics you described - that's the free market in action.
The problem here is that there is no way for society at large to send corrective feedback, "holy shit you're totally abusing the rules and what you do is immoral", and have it actually impact said clinics' behavior. This mechanism exists naturally in small groups, but money and scale destroys it.
- WalterBright 6y ago> that's the free market in action Government paying for things is not the free market in action.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIn your story, government acts just as a customer on the market. Mere presence of a government doesn't make a market not free.
- tomatocracy 6y agoGovernment is not spending its own money but that of taxpayers present and future - an agency-style conflict of interest. This is then made worse by the fact that the party who receives the services purchased (the patient) is someone different again who has no skin in the game at all. This is a recipe for market failure and not something I'd describe as a "free" market, even if it is a market.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Government is not spending its own money but that of taxpayers present and future - an agency-style conflict of interest. The government is spending its own money it collected in taxes[0]. Whether it is more like a thug or more like an embodiment of the collective will of society is immaterial. It's just another customer on the market. > This is then made worse by the fact that the party who receives the services purchased (the patient) is someone different again who has no skin in the game at all. This is the exact same scenario as an advertiser paying a company to expose me to advertising; I have no skin in that game either, and I'm subjected to something I do not necessarily want. But nobody would say it's not "free market". Hell, in the case of the clinics, the situation would be identical if the party paying for the procedures was not the government, but a billionaire philanthropist. In fact, nothing about a free market precludes such scenarios, where the choices available to a buyer are dependent on the deals made between the seller and some third parties. -- [0] - The concept that "government has no money" is silly outside the quite obvious reminder that government is mostly funded by its subjects.
- nickpp 6y agoThe government’s money are unearned money, confiscated from taxpayers. There is a saying about this kind of income: "easy come, easy go". You can be sure that "the subjects" this money was taken from would be much more careful about spending it. Not convinced? Just look at the way government borrows: no sane person would sell her future like that. Also, just ask a politician how worried he is about spending money "for his constituents". I know stadiums made for tiny towns, boulevards for undriven neighborhoods, and so on and so forth...
- TeMPOraL 6y agoSure. But that's neither here nor there, as the market is an equal opportunity institution. It doesn't ask whether you got your money by providing goods in exchange, or confiscated it from your subjects, or won it in a casino, or robbed a bank, or stole it from your employees' pension fund, ...
- nickpp 6y agoIt is there, since such a large player as a government throwing around unlimited money will inevitably distort and corrupt the market. Look at what is going on in the stock market right now since the fed started buying assets in spring.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoSure, but that does not apply to the case we're discussing - which is a government paying clinics for procedures. You could substitute "a billionaire philanthropist" for "a government" and the outcome would be exactly the same. Now if you want to talk free markets in general, then I want to point out that in the real world, a free market cannot thrive without some sort of government that ensures social stability and enforces contracts. Without such government, the market would quickly degenerate into trading violence alongside currency, and either disintegrate or... end up producing a government. Ultimately, "private enterprise" and "public governance" don't have a clear boundary between them - they're two modes of the same phenomenon, people negotiating with each other.