5 ms·
> But blaming the clinics doesn't work, because the actual problem was the government set things up so that the rise of clinics to exploit the rules was legal a
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
> But blaming the clinics doesn't work, because the actual problem was the government set things up so that the rise of clinics to exploit the rules was legal and inevitable.
The obvious solution would be for the government to punish the clinics for acting against the spirit of the law. But that approach brings in a huge potential for abuse. We're in a bind.
If we can solve this, this will be the biggest breakthrough for civilization ever since the invention of hierarchical structures many millennia ago. Hierarchies and codified laws were what allowed us to stop living as isolated groups of ~150 people[0] and go on to build a global civilization. But these came at the cost of not being able to exploit our innate social skills to cooperate with each other. Bureaucracies, rules and metrics are thus an inefficient and barely adquate mechanical substitute for trust.
If we could somehow scale trust, scale social skills, so that people would naturally respond to incentives that are uncomputable and not expressible through bureaucratic apparatus - like "don't do stupid shit", or "really, don't cheat" - we'd enter a golden age.
Alas, I have no clue how to do that.
--
[0] - Yes, the Dunbar's number. Past which you no longer have the case that everyone knows everyone else, and interpersonal dynamics stop being strong enough to ensure mutual cooperation.
- WalterBright 6y ago> I have no clue how to do that. Free markets are remarkable in their ability to get people to cooperate in their mutual self-interest.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoFree markets can only exist in this way until they are much smaller than the whole economy. The moment they are the economy they are heavily prone to monopolisation.
- nickpp 6y agoOn the contrary, the larger the market, the more the competition and thus the less danger of monopolization.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWealth begets wealth. It compounds. The larger the market, the more space there is for a company to take the lead, put up barriers to entry, and focus on snuffing out any would-be competitors.
- nickpp 6y agoOnly governments can put barriers of entry into a free market, usually through regulations.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoNot true. See [0] for a list of examples, which contains several cases of barriers to entry that do not involve governments in any way (except as the entity that allows contracts to be enforced and the market to exist in the first place). -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barriers_to_entry#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barriers_to_entry#Examples
- nickpp 6y agoHalf of those examples need to be sustained by the government to actually act as barriers. And all of them ignore the creativity of the entrepreneurial mind when incentivized by the fabulous profits to be had in a monopolized market. A nice example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_Henry_Dow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_Henry_Dow
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThe free market is a really simple feedback system that, in any real-world implementation, can just as quickly lose the "mutual self-interest" part, or replace "cooperation" with "coercion". The very problem with the clinics you described - that's the free market in action. The problem here is that there is no way for society at large to send corrective feedback, "holy shit you're totally abusing the rules and what you do is immoral", and have it actually impact said clinics' behavior. This mechanism exists naturally in small groups, but money and scale destroys it.
- WalterBright 6y ago> that's the free market in action Government paying for things is not the free market in action.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIn your story, government acts just as a customer on the market. Mere presence of a government doesn't make a market not free.
- tomatocracy 6y agoGovernment is not spending its own money but that of taxpayers present and future - an agency-style conflict of interest. This is then made worse by the fact that the party who receives the services purchased (the patient) is someone different again who has no skin in the game at all. This is a recipe for market failure and not something I'd describe as a "free" market, even if it is a market.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Government is not spending its own money but that of taxpayers present and future - an agency-style conflict of interest. The government is spending its own money it collected in taxes[0]. Whether it is more like a thug or more like an embodiment of the collective will of society is immaterial. It's just another customer on the market. > This is then made worse by the fact that the party who receives the services purchased (the patient) is someone different again who has no skin in the game at all. This is the exact same scenario as an advertiser paying a company to expose me to advertising; I have no skin in that game either, and I'm subjected to something I do not necessarily want. But nobody would say it's not "free market". Hell, in the case of the clinics, the situation would be identical if the party paying for the procedures was not the government, but a billionaire philanthropist. In fact, nothing about a free market precludes such scenarios, where the choices available to a buyer are dependent on the deals made between the seller and some third parties. -- [0] - The concept that "government has no money" is silly outside the quite obvious reminder that government is mostly funded by its subjects.
- gspr 6y agoI agree with what you write, but I'm also spitballing stopgap measures: Are there downsides to having governments instead contract healthcare capacity? Has this been tried? By this I mean that instead of the government paying each hospital (or in this case dentist) for each procedure, the government pays each hospital (or dentist) to keep a certain capacity for each kind of procedure available. The hospitals are obliged to provide up to that capacity at no extra cost to the government. Any demand beyond it, goes into the backlog (and turns into a political issue). Surely I'm missing some downsides…
- Tarq0n 6y agoWe do this where I work (municipal social work and housing with care) and it really does remove some of the incentives to up-code and over-produce on the part of the provider in the short term. In the long term there's still some incentive to take on extra clients for the care providers so they have a better negotiating position for their next contact.
- kcolford 6y agoI think you might run into the issue of whether or not that capacity is actually being provided or just reported. You can definitely track that a procedure was done: you have the patient that you can contact to verify, bills for the materials that were needed, and bookings that guarantee no one was operating on multiple patients at once. If you just pay for capacity regardless of whether or not it's used, how do you know that they aren't just turning half of all patients away at the door and claiming that they provide the full capacity? There's political unrest about not enough capacity but your healthcare providers are saying no one's coming in and still taking the full amount of money.