6 ms·
I can’t see my way to blaming government for this. Either these operations were indicated but unlikely to happen otherwise (the government program was effective
by sokoloff 6y ago
I can’t see my way to blaming government for this. Either these operations were indicated but unlikely to happen otherwise (the government program was effective) or not medically-indicated (at which point private clinics are torturing poor people for profit which is abhorrent on so many levels).
- giantDinosaur 6y agoThe point isn't that the clinics are not morally culpable, but only that they are a natural response to government incentives over which the government has exclusive control.
- sgift 6y agoDoing something morally wrong is not a natural response. It is a natural response option. To paraphrase Jurassic Park: [Clinics] were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should. Not everyone chooses to do something morally wrong, just because "I'm allowed to! And it makes life easier!"
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Not everyone chooses to do something morally wrong, just because "I'm allowed to! And it makes life easier!" But plenty choose to do something morally wrong because "I have to put bread on my table, and I'm about to go out of business because I can't compete with everyone else doing the immoral thing". This is the mechanism by which the market eliminates ethics from our lives, step by step. If doing something slightly wrong gives you a competitive advantage, you'll take it or you'll get outcompeted by everyone else who do.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoThe government incentives were clearly going to result in private-island driven dinosaur experiments. If the incentives had been to welcome such genetic experimentation in a controlled manner then regulators would have noticed the predatory behaviour of the velociraptors before it became a problem. Again, it's about risk/incentive management, not about judging those who dare to go too far. The T-Rex will eat you even as you shake your fist at its unethical re-creator. Better to not merely hope that everyone chooses the friendliest route by virtue of human nature.
- mattcwilson 6y agoYou are absolutely right - it’s an option. If we keep setting up situations where people have an unethical option, I’m not sure we should act surprised by them taking it. We can, it’s an option, but it seems naive. The government had the option to think through their policymaking more fully. What accountability should they have for that? If we award points for “trying, with good intentions”, and not for “actual outcome” we are in for a lot more bad outcomes from earnest triers.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoHow does one define "morally wrong"? Honest business by eastern Massachusetts standards would have you labeled a swindler in southern Indiana. There are large swaths of the US where "if the option is there then there's no shame in taking it" and "if you don't cash in you're only hurting yourself because someone else will" are just how normal business is done.
- WalterBright 6y agoYou can't write a bureaucratic regulation that accurately replaces a judgement call. For example, I have various dental problems. With each one, the dentist would lay out the options - effectiveness, how long they'll last, the price, how painful the procedure is, what the recovery time is, etc. There is no right answer. Different people make different choices. (I've often picked an option that wasn't the dentist's recommended one.) Medicine is almost never (Condition A => Treatment B).
- ricardobeat 6y agoIt doesn't seem like the regulation was ever intended to replace that judgement call; just support the doctors' decision. We are not machines ruled by logic, and in the end everything that ends up in the justice system is judged by intention and/or merit and not 'the letter of the law'.
- galangalalgol 6y agoIs that true though? If something is technically legal like this, they get found innocent. When its technically illegal, mandatory minimums insure they go to jail for far too long. Someone once said there are legal traditions where intent of the law could be used to find guilt, and it had a name, but the US and UK are much more like machines.
- ricardobeat 6y agoI believe both the US and UK (as do most western countries?) have 'common law' systems, where jurisprudence / case precedents are heavily relied upon. Whenever there is doubt on the legality of something, that court decision will set the tone for others to follow, and go higher up the justice system as needed. The main point was that you can't simply blame the law for failing to 'replace judgement'. Most laws rely on some amount of common sense to be interpreted.
- robertlagrant 6y ago> I can’t see my way to blaming government for this. They get to take money from people backed by the threat of locking them in a box if they don't. They are responsible for making sure that money is spent extremely effectively.
- mattcwilson 6y agoWho defines “medically indicated” - the government, or the clinicians?