11 ms·
Gary Numan: 'One of my songs got over a million streams – I got £37'
- djaychela 6y ago"There are more avenues today than I have ever seen in my time doing this job." - Jason Iley, chairman and chief executive of Sony Music UK and Ireland Like a number of comments made by record industry people about this, that may be factually correct, but it's missing the point. There definitely are more avenues than before. But almost none of them pay any money. Streaming has removed most small bands' way of making money, by selling CDs directly to their fans. Most of them will just stream it, and won't realise the tiny amount of revenue this generates for the artists. Paying the artists you actually listen to - rather than slicing the cake up into infinitely small slices - needs to be looked at. Most people assume their money goes to who they listen to, not the artists who everyone listens to the most.
- yokaze 6y agoI wonder if a law enforcing more transparency couldn't help here. It is in the interest of the music labels and the streaming companies to maximise their profit, which means minimise the pay-out to the artists. Customers have to be very motivated to be able to make an informed decision. And most often they probably aren't really motivated and happily chose the cheaper option. But I have hope, if the impact of the customers choice on their favourite artists is directly visible, it will create more pressure to increase the payout. E.g. each time you listen the song on A, the artists gets X, if you buy the song the artists Y.
- dinglejungle 6y ago> Paying the artists you actually listen to This is what Bandcamp is.
- djaychela 6y agoI agree, but nearly everyone I know has either Spotify or Amazon music. And also most of them don't really care about this. I've been a musician since I was 13 and have made most of my income over my life from either recording, teaching or playing music, so I guess I have more of a dog in this fight. I think it needs to be that the majority-used systems are made more fair - as with most things, people won't sacrifice ease of use for equity!
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoThe solution is to pull your music off the platforms and charge your own price for it. You will likely find that no one purchases it and you get forgotten because very few people want to pay more for music when there is unlimited music available at a cheaper price. You can’t force people consume your content and that they pay more for it. There is such a massive supply of music that naturally the cost will be quite low.
- csunbird 6y agoDoesn't spotify already distribute your subscription money to artists, based on your listens?
- dinglejungle 6y agoYes, but it's much more likely your money is going to record labels rather than artists with something like Spotify. With Bandcamp, you are typically directly paying the artists, and you can always pay above the minimum price set by the artist if you wish.
- hobofan 6y agoCDs aren't the only merch to sell and all the other stuff (shirts, etc.) is easier to produce than ever and very profitable, and I feel like most people are well aware of that being one of the most direct ways to support their favourite artists.
- 72deluxe 6y agoThis is true, but a tiny proportion of people buy merchandise compared to music. You will always find the t-shirt stand easily accessible at a gig for the artist despite the thousands of people at a venue, so believing that t-shirt sales will someone keep the artists profitable is likely wrong.
- hobofan 6y agoI don't have the personal experience from gigs with "thousands of people", as the only ones I've been to were not that huge, and at those the merch stands were always swarmed. If you are playing for an audience that big you are probably already good on ticket sales alone (which also tend to become more expensive once a certain audience threshold is crossed). I also wasn't just guessing/assuming that, but relaying what I've been told by friends who are musicians (see also my sibling comment).
- Uehreka 6y agoI hear this argument a lot, but never from musicians. I think it might be a factoid that music listeners spread around because it makes us feel better about what seems like an irreversible movement in the industry (which benefits us, since we get to pay less money for music). But in the end, if we want to incentivize artists to focus on making good music (as opposed to merch) we should probably be paying them for the music. That’s not to say we can will the current streaming trend out of existence (we can’t), but we shouldn’t necessarily let ourselves feel good about where this is going.
- hobofan 6y agoThis isn't just a random factoid that I picked up, but what was relayed to me be multiple friends from bands that make part of their living off of music, and that mostly from merch. They are not in big well-known bands, but merch makes them enough money to pay their costs and also take time out of their freelance jobs to work on their music. They do sell some CDs, but never made a lot of money off of that (they haven't been around in a time where CDs mattered), and when I asked some of them once they said that they estimated that the loss of CD sales probably cancels out with the cheaper production costs of shirts. For most bands that are not huge, they never made a lot of money with CD sales (in stores, not at the concert venues) anyway, as most of that money went to the labels anyway. The bulk of money was always in concerts and merch. There are some reasons for criticizing streaming services and how they shape the music industry, but I don't think that replacing CD sales with less well paid streaming fees are a big one. That really only hits musicians that are already well beyond making a living off of music. I personally don't like the focus on merch for funding creatives either (this also includes Youtube creators and similar), as I don't really need that many t-shirts personally that I would buy one from all of them. I rather buy their music via Bandcamp or donate to them via their Patreon.
- f311a 6y agoThe founder of Patreon had the same problem, he lost most of his income from a band. That's why he created Patreon.
- konjin 6y agoThere's a difference between a $20 CD and a $10 all you can listen to music account with no commercials. The artists are getting less money because music is worth less today. Technological change is making that job obsolete in the same way that illuminated manuscripts have become obsolete.
- elmo2you 6y agoI am tempted to agree with what you say. I do believe that modern technology has lowered (financial) barriers to access art, no doubt. However, if it's only artists that appear to be mostly suffering from this new reality, while big (record/copyrights/tech) corporations still appear to be doing very well, I'm inclined to argue that this is probably more about unfair distribution (even more than it traditionally already was) than about the argument you put forward. No matter how you slice that cake, if in the end artists have to struggle to get by while others make a killing from exploiting their creations, then there is something fundamentally wrong. Personally, I think that today it might even be more wrong than it has been for a long time.
- rob74 6y agoWhat job? The job of the artist? I sure hope not! I mean, ok, we don't have illuminated manuscripts anymore, but we still have typographers, illustrators (for books), painters etc., so the job has evolved, not disappeared completely. What technological change will eventually make obsolete are probably the record companies...
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoA lot of scholarly publishers today, even very respected names, no longer provide typesetting and expect authors to do all the work and provide a camera-ready PDF. The whole scene of publishing genre fiction directly on Amazon also eschews quality typesetting and often even basic editing and proofreading. Just saying. There are a lot of jobs today that the market apparently no longer wants to pay for, even in the book world.
- marvin 6y agoIt’s not just that. The distribution models also discriminates against small bands. If the four bands I’ve listened to in December received 70% of my Spotify subscription payment, this would be much less of a problem.
- Closi 6y agoYour post seems to blame the streaming companies rather than the record companies. 1 million streams in Spotify generally nets you c£2,740 - so in Gary Newman's case the issue is presumably the record label taking a huge £2,703 cut. Independent artists can sign up directly with Spotify and get paid per stream, and Spotify's payment model is pretty transparent (they take a 30% cut of subscriptions and share the rest by time listened).
- dazc 6y agoI am currently paying Amazon something like £15 a month for myself and one family member to access their streaming service. Since we tend to listen to the same handful of curated channels and albums month in month out, I'd say we're overpaying for the convenience by a considerable sum. Yes, it is true we have an unlimited choice of alternative tunes to listen to but the reality is that we just don't.
- lukeramsden 6y agoThis is why multiple ways of paying for music are so important, because for my £14.99 a month on Spotify I've listened to (since 2020-03-01) 2,733 different artists[0]. That would simply not have been possible under the traditional business model. I think a comeback for buying music should happen, but this streaming model is so incredibly fertile for discovery of new artists that I think even with such low cost-per-listen rates it's still good value to artists. [0] According to my Last.fm.
- at_a_remove 6y agoIt probably is fertile for discovery of new artists, but that conversion rate -- it might as well be all of that fantastic "exposure" you'll get by doing my website for free.
- lukeramsden 6y agoI've been to concerts of artists I simply would not have discovered if it weren't for Spotify, their curated playlists, and their algorithm. I can absolutely guarantee this for my personal circumstance These artists have been from all over the globe, my favourite being The Chats from Australia which I went to see in Manchester. Exposure in music is much more genuine than in design/development like you say since the concerts have always been a significant portion of the income for artists (AFAIK).
- DivisionSol 6y agoI've been thinking about this a bit. Compare a 1million view YouTube video (arbitrary $3/CPM(1000 views), so $3000), take the 16% cut in the article and you get $480. So Gary Numan's work is roughly valued one less magnitude than a YouTube video. I think that's a shame, but, it's not that far off. Now you could argue Music isn't the same as a Video, but in my mind Videos can be just as timeless and classic as a tune. Streaming/advertising creates that nice race to the bottom which evens the playing field (a view is a view is a view, a listen is a listen is a listen, 100 or 100000 it's all the same,) but people who are used to entrenched interests keeping prices high will be shocked.
- intricatedetail 6y agoIt's race to the bottom for payouts. The owners are still rolling in Bentleys and sip champagne.
- DivisionSol 6y ago30% distribution fee is standard across so many things. Steam, AppStore, and it looks like Spotify as well. Seems like the ones losing out are those that are signing record deals, giving over 41% (or 54%? The %s don't add up to 100 in the article,) to a label who... Just puts them on Spotify? Spotify is in a good position to cut out record labels by working with artists directly.
- intricatedetail 6y agoI think anti competition bodies should look into it. It sounds like a market fixing if everyone charges the same.
- BorisTheBrave 6y agoGiven videos are usually 10mins and music 3.5 mins, and youtube adverts are both more frequent and more targeted, that might even explain the last factor of 10.
- friendlybus 6y ago
- pjc50 6y agoHow does this compare to being played once on the radio to an audience of 1m?
- Thiez 6y agoIn the US artists are not paid for being played on the radio at all, only the songwriters. So that's an easy answer: $0.
- rwmj 6y agoBBC Radio 1 (the mainstream UK pop station) pays about £13 per minute of airtime, so if it's a 3 minute pop song, about 40 quid, or about the same as Gary Numan says he received here. (Source, which also has audience figures: https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/bbc-radio-1-is-paying-songwriters-26-less-per-minute-than-it-was-5-years-ago/ https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/bbc-radio-1-is-paying...) (As the sibling answer says, it will depend on whether he's the songwriter or not)
- 72deluxe 6y agoThis is distributed differently according to the station, and distributed according to the size of the artist I believe. I have a friend who worked out all the times he was paid on the radio over the years and sent a list off to the BBC and got something like £5 from it due to him being a small artist. Not very sustainable.
- iamben 6y agoI wish streaming was compared to radio more. I think so many artists compare streams to sales directly, but I think a radio comparison is far more apt (even if not quite right).
- pjc50 6y agoExactly - for a lot of people it's used as wallpaper in the same way. They turn on Spotify and do eight hours of work, twenty days a month. 9600 minutes of music for which they pay $10. A tenth of a cent per minute. We can argue about how much of that tenth of a cent should go to performer/songwriter/label/Spotify/GCP, but I think increasing it is doomed.
- unhammer 6y agoWould be interesting to hear how much smaller artists make on sites like Bandcamp in comparison (but I can't find Gary Numan there, only remixes!)
- vladjjj 6y agoI think Bandcamp takes a 10-15% cut of the price you pay to the artist, but yeah, it's mostly independent labels.
- vladjjj 6y agoStreaming is racketeering.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> The label heads told MPs their cut from streaming was a fair reward for the risks involved in developing artists, recording, marketing and distribution. Smooth, but also a juicy lie because: Labels haven't paid for new artist development since Napster was shutdown. New artists learn their craft on their own dime and record their first (or more) album in their bedroom. There is no cost for marketing or distribution with streaming. Recording costs are subtracted from artists' payments by labels. What the label head deliberately left out is that new deals are "360 deals", meaning the whole pie, where the label gets additional revenue streams: streaming royalties, live performance, merch and often Patreon (pays the rent for a lot of artists) payments. Regarding the £37 for 1 million streams, that would take some forensics to unravel. But factors are if Numan doesn't own his masters, what the separate songwriting credits are, and that US streaming services operate with legal rules that disadvantange artists when paying for streaming. The artists who've done well at capturing value are Steve Vai (self-managed, as advised by Frank Zappa) and Joe Bonamassa (dedicated boutique artist mgmt.) It gets real thin after that. Source: I know Youtube music artists and have done the math with them. I tell them not to sign label deals (be their own publisher), and as a result they're all cash flow positive while following their artistic vision - with no lawyer surprises.
- kuu 6y agoIf the label doesn't offer the artist anything and they can do all by themselves, don't sign a contract with them. As simple as that, nobody is forcing new artists to join the labels...
- redis_mlc 6y agoCorrect, and that's what I tell artists. But it's not black and white what the whole story is, and it's not simple. Label heads shouldn't be providing false testimony about label benefits to maintain their edge, especially since they even control streaming services like Spotify (I didn't see that mentioned in the article.) https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spotify-listing-factbox/factbox-spotify-opens-up-on-ownership-and-clients-in-listing-files-idUSKCN1GD5PX https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spotify-listing-factbox/f... 1) If you're trying to be libertarian, understand that a 20 yo artist doesn't have the legal resources to negotiate a contract against the labels' unyielding armies of lawyers. 2) Also, signing a contract is not the same as enforcing one. Labels don't follow their own contract terms on payouts, so there is no good faith on their part. 3) If your second or third albums don't sell well, labels often just stop answering your phone calls. Yet the artist is stuck in the terms of a zombie contract, and often that will block (end) their career. The Goo Goo Dolls were advised by their first lawyer that, "It's slavery. Don't sign it." After their first multi-platinum album, they still "owed" $300,000. "Free markets" or not, why is that allowed to continue for decades? "The band filed suit against Metal Blade, claiming they had not earned any royalties from their album's sales, which was attributed to a "grossly unfair, one-sided and unenforceable contract" which had been signed by the band in 1987." The Dolls won by refusing to record their next album until there was a contract that wouldn't ruin them. They were ok sleeping together in one van, but not losing money despite massive sales. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goo_Goo_Dolls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goo_Goo_Dolls
- bzb6 6y agoNow Cars is stuck in my head, arrrgh
- Aeronwen 6y agoMine too, but not his version. Go figure.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoIn 2008, Benn Jordan (aka The Flashbulb and other pseudonyms), got tired of iTunes making money from his music and receiving no revenue for it, that he personally shared his new album "Soundtrack To A Vacant Life" via BitTorrent. He attached a text file to the release, explaining how he makes essentially no money from iTunes and other platforms distributing his music and invited people to buy the album from his website directly. And that strategy seems to have worked. Radiohead released their album "In Rainbows" exclusively online and invited people to pay what they want. As a result they made much more money than they usually made with that release.
- hansjorg 6y agoHe (Benn Jordan) recently posted a very interesting YouTube video where he discusses how streaming is working out for him and other artists like him now. "Should we hate Spotify?": https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MXudOLStaXA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MXudOLStaXA
- 29athrowaway 6y agoRelevant article from The Onion: Spotify celebrates 100th dollar given to artists. https://www.theonion.com/spotify-celebrates-100th-dollar-given-to-artists-1844943985 https://www.theonion.com/spotify-celebrates-100th-dollar-giv...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- h0nd 6y agoI remember a time I was able to buy a CD for 10 bucks and could play all the tracks infinitely, no questions asked.
- garbagetime 6y agoI think you can still do that.
- spiderfarmer 6y agoThe people who want to go back to the "glory days" of CD's are forgetting that struggling artists existed in that day and age too. A lot of indie artists pressed a small run of CD's for a couple grand and never even broke even. Still happens today. I have multiple wannabe artists in my family. For a lot of people making music should really stay a hobby. They are not very original in their music and lyrics. Or simply not very good. Or very good for a small niche. It's still possible to succeed, but not just by putting out CD's and expecting to sell them all for a nice profit. You need to explore the other options available. Like teaching, living room concerts, blogging, vlogging, etcetera. If it's purely about producing and getting your art out to people, there has never been a better time. Just do what you like to do and get it out there. Who knows, you'll be streamed a lot somewhere, like my brother in law's songs are streamed a lot in Brazil without ever visiting that country. Many open source developers are happy working on their hobby for "free". Some artists should do the same.
- andoma 6y agoThis is the correct answer
- keiferski 6y agoMost people "are not good" because our political system is centered around making money, not on mastering an art form. Many societies did this in the past, but as it's "no longer economically viable," no one cares today. Today, in order to master an art form and actually make something worthwhile, you have to be entirely self-motivated. > Many open source developers are happy working on their hobby for "free" Really not a good comparison. Open source developers tend to have no issues finding paid work, often because they worked for free on open source. The same scenario doesn't exist for artists.
- disgu 6y ago> Many societies did this in the past, but as it's "no longer economically viable," no one cares today. Can you name a few?
- 6y ago
- ArtTimeInvestor 6y agoIf you put and ad on Youtube and want a million people to watch it, you probably have to pay ... $1000? $10,000? $100,000? I dunno. But I know you will not receive money for it. The question is: Is a song a product or an advertisement? I tend to think it is an advertisement. Every young musician dreams of becoming a star. Not so much to pay their bills but for the fame. I think the free market prices things right. You cannot demand people to pay for watching your advertisements. Nonetheless, I wish artists would put their output on their own websites. This centralization in giant silos where people consume music mindlessly and get showered with additional ads devalues their art even further.
- tgv 6y agoIf the song advertises an artist, what does the artist have to produce to make money? And Numan isn't really dreaming of becoming a star. > I think the free market prices things right. Right for what?
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoNone the less there is a question of whether the record labels and streaming companies are using their near monopolies to extract more from artists than they could in a competitive market.
- 72deluxe 6y agoSince the artist gets paid an order of magnitude less than the minimum wage, it isn't extraction of value/money from the artist - it's extortion.
- Closi 6y ago> I think the free market prices things right. You cannot demand people to pay for watching your advertisements. I think you are getting confused between 'the free market' and 'free as in beer'. You can get people to pay for listening to music, that is a very well established business model.
- donquichotte 6y agoThat does not align with my experience. On Christmas 2019, I recorded an album [1] of 9 "Snake Jazz" songs, each 30 seconds long, as a joke on a Rick and Morty episode. Published the album on CD Baby, and had them distribute it on all available platforms. Publishing cost me 80$. Now, about a year later, I have earned 0.47$. 0.33$ of it come from Spotify, where I raked up a full 131 listens, averaging at 0.25 cents per listen. 0.25cents * 1e6 would amount to 2500$, which is admittedly still not much, but two orders of magnitude off from what is reported here. That being said, I believe the main source of revenue for bands has been concerts in recent years (not 2020 though), with ever-increasing prices charged for live performances. I gladly accept that though - it is quite appealing to cut out the middle-man that were Music Studios up until the early 2000s. With the barrier of entry to record an album ever-decreasing (using a Roland Octacapture, Reaper DAW, a Shure SM57 and lots of sweat you can get far), pretty much anyone can record an album in decent-ish quality in the comfort of their home, there is no more appeal to pay expensive studios to do a recording for you. [1] https://music.youtube.com/browse/MPREb_2nw3eEydV25 https://music.youtube.com/browse/MPREb_2nw3eEydV25
- 72deluxe 6y agoTrue, unless you play the drums and don't want your neighbours to hate you forever and ever!
- cheph 6y agoIf Gary Numan does not want to make his songs available for streaming, can he do that without us having to know about it? How is this something relevant for HN?
- yomly 6y agoNo one seems to mention that a million streams is actually not that high. It's a big number but if 10k people listen 100 times that's not huge. Good music is typically listened to multiple times - if you really like a song and you listen 3 times a day you're at 90 listens in a month already. That's probably not sustainable but you start to see how 1 million is impressive but also quite achievable.
- Snild 6y agoEvery time I hear this kind of complaint, I wonder what kinds of horrible deals they've made with middlemen. I have some music available for streaming. In November, I had a total of 5126 streams, which gave me 14.611 USD. If we extrapolate that to 1 million streams, it would be $2850, but Gary is saying he's getting less than 2% of that. The aggregator I'm using (my only middleman) takes 15%, already subtracted from the numbers above. Gary's middlemen apparently take over 98%. That sucks, but it doesn't appear to be the fault of the streaming services. One caveat to note about these numbers is that the value of streams seem to differ a lot between countries. It's possible that Gary has more listeners than I do in less-lucrative countries. I don't think it could cover the whole difference. The most likely explanation is that Gary's record company is taking most of the money, and/or he has to split it with others who were involved in the creative process. If anyone is interested in my earnings data (further analysis, charts, peer review, whatever), it's available here: http://dolkow.se/files/streams_nov20.xlsx http://dolkow.se/files/streams_nov20.xlsx
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoI think you are on the money. The article doesn’t say why he got paid so little and just repeats the same non info and says streaming services should pay more. But like you said, they do pay far more than what he got so the money is going somewhere else and isn’t the fault of the streaming services. There are apparently labels which do nothing but help you get in to the streaming services and charge next to no fee but then you lose out on the services they provide.
- Snild 6y agoOh, and I assume that the big labels have better deals with Spotify than my small aggregator does -- earning a better per-stream rate.
- jbob2000 6y agoMy partner and I recorded a Christmas album in our basement and put it on Bandcamp for "pay what you want including $0". We made over $400, but as of today, it's only been downloaded/streamed 500 times. I'm sure if Gary asked around his friends and family what they'd like to hear on his next album, he could probably make more money.
- top_sigrid 6y agoTo be honest I do not get all this complaining about streaming revenue. Don't get me wrong, I would love for musicians to be paid a higher amount for being played but this is just what the music industry has evolved into, also because this is the model that listeners have chosen. My point is that the way it works now also comes with huge benefits for artists. Some years ago there has been no way to get played and discovered a million times as an indie artist. Today this is possible. Streaming services have replaced radios in many parts and it is possible for nearly everybody to get traction in that system. What also has changed is where artists make their money, which today is more in playing live and selling merch. It is true that in former times artists got much more for being played or selling records but this was reserved for artists signed by big lables and it was hard to get into that business. As an anecdote, I remeber hearing Alfa Mist play live in Berlin and in disbelief stated how surreal it feels to play a sold out show in Berlin. He told how he some years ago was just for the heck of it recording and releasing an album together with his brother from their homes. Without them expecting it the album was catching on all over the world and they could tour it and live from it. I feel this sums up how streaming can be a big chance for artists.
- PeterStuer 6y agoFor those interested in how all these royalties work, I'd recommend reading "The Definite Guide to Spotify Royalties" by Jeff Price. https://vi.be/files/research/the-definitive-guide-to-spotify-royalties-by-jeff-price-3.pdf https://vi.be/files/research/the-definitive-guide-to-spotify... [pdf] To quote directly from the introduction: "When I began to write this article, I thought it would be a quick one. Yes, I knew there was a lot of confusion and misinformation about Spotify royalties in the world, but I naively thought, no problem, I’ll just lay it all out in a quick couple of pages. I could not have been more wrong. The complexity of Spotify royalties is, frankly, insane. So insane that it took me over a month and 40 pages (before including diagrams) to explain it all. No artist, label, songwriter, distributor or musician should be required to have a depth of knowledge of this complexity to understand a very simple question: “How much do I earn when my music streams on Spotify?” There should be a simple, easy to understand answer. But there’s not. And to be blunt, it’s not really Spotify’s fault, nor is it the music industry’s fault, or the fault of U.S. Copyright laws. But when you put all three of these things together, you get a weird franken-monster royalty schema that has resulted from a new music business model built on consumers paying to have access to music, rather than paying to own it. For each step described in the royalty calculation process, it took another step to explain the step preceding it, and the one preceding that one, and furthermore, the reasons why each step exists. Each step, in and of itself, makes sense, but together they are like peeling layer after layer of a never-ending onion."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pan69 6y agoThere is quote from Mick Jagger who said: > … it is a massive change and it does alter the fact that people don’t make as much money out of records. But I have a take on that – people only made money out of records for a very, very small time. When The Rolling Stones started out, we didn’t make any money out of records because record companies wouldn’t pay you! They didn’t pay anyone! Then, there was a small period from 1970 to 1997, where people did get paid, and they got paid very handsomely and everyone made money. But now that period has gone. So if you look at the history of recorded music from 1900 to now, there was a 25 year period where artists did very well, but the rest of the time they didn’t.
- eyelidlessness 6y ago0. I fucking love Gary Numan. 1. I’m not remotely surprised. 2. Because the recording artist economy has always been fucked[1]. 3. Because Gary Numan is more known for his influence than his work (like Leonard Cohen). 4. Because people wanted Taylor Swift so much she gave in even though a young twerp could see the scam. I know it’s a pandemic and we can’t go to live shows, but y’all. If you want your beloved music to survive and thrive. Go to (virtual) shows. Buy shirts and posters. Follow your artists and buy what they’re promoting. Record sales and streams are promotional marketing, you’re paying marketing executives for them. [1]: https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-problem-with-music https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-problem-with-music
- 8bitsrule 6y agoIf Numan had gotten £37,000 for a million streams (30 seconds or more), that'd be 3.7 pence per listen. Hardly an unreasonable ask. "Tony Harlow, chief executive of Warner Music UK, cautioned against disrupting the system. 'This is an evolving situation,' he said. 'It is being well-governed by a market that is efficient and nimble and it doesn't need any change.' " Ooo ... now there's a surprise. If musicians would get together, create their own streaming service, they could pay a very good wage to people to run it, quit the system, never feed the fat, fat whales again, and certainly pocket 1p a listen.
- runamok 6y agoMusic is awesome but it's also a commodity with more content being generated every day than we could ever consume. It's simple supply and demand.