3 ms·
> but the result was an actual standard Was it though? At a minimum i think a "standard" is a document detailing the behaviour of at least two competiting impl
by bawolff 6y ago
> but the result was an actual standard
Was it though? At a minimum i think a "standard" is a document detailing the behaviour of at least two competiting implementations sufficiently that you could use it to make a new implementation that was interopable. I don't think that was true of W3C standards in the pre WHATWG days. Compare it to say the HTTP rfcs, which i think did meet that standard.
- beojan 6y agoNot necessarily. The C++ standards committee for instance happily standardizes features with only one (or zero) existing implementations. It has to, because such implementations would be extensions that standard compliant code can't rely on.
- int_19h 6y agoOpera would be a good example of a third independent implementation successfully competing with the primary two (IE and NN/Mozilla). I remember switching browsers back and forth several times back then - I was an Opera 6 user, then moved to Firebird/Firefox shortly after it was released, then back to Opera 7/8/9, then to Chrome. It was a fairly brief period, unfortunately - roughly between IE losing definitive market dominance, and Chrome acquiring the same.