4 ms·
I do not live in Vienna - I live in Montréal. We have a system that is a mix of a structurally HDB-like provincial system, municipal housing systems, private co
by sudosysgen 6y ago
I do not live in Vienna - I live in Montréal. We have a system that is a mix of a structurally HDB-like provincial system, municipal housing systems, private construction, private/public cooperation, and rent control.
If your issue is that public housing is run by racist people, the solution is to have it run by non-racist people. This tends to be easier when people that live in public housing are more diverse and have a larger electoral impact.
The way that we handle the downsides of rent control is by allowing landlords to break the rent-control cycle by doing major renovations, and by making rental contracts basically all end at the same date which allows for a much lower friction in moving.
While the author may very well want it, unless they make it their #1 priority, they won't actually implement it as there is much more resistance against public housing than to anything else. The end result will be that the "compromise" will be no new public housing and simply zoning relaxations at most, with continued increase in rents.
- astrange 6y agoThere is public housing happening in CA. Actually, there's an unusual amount of it this year because of the opportunity to convert a bunch of newly bankrupt hotels into housing (https://www.hcd.ca.gov/grants-funding/active-funding/homekey.shtml https://www.hcd.ca.gov/grants-funding/active-funding/homekey...). Besides that, the left-NIMBY alliance means there's noone to directly oppose public housing. The left supports it because they actually want it, and the NIMBYs pretend to be leftists and like using "this should be public housing" as their excuse for why nothing else should ever happen - presumably they don't expect public housing to actually appear, but they run low on excuses if it does. Not much new construction of it happens in SF though, because construction costs in are very high, and there's not much land zoned to allow apartments because they don't want new housing of any kind, public or not. > The end result will be that the "compromise" will be no new public housing and simply zoning relaxations at most, with continued increase in rents. SF's main problem is most of it is zoned for single-family houses despite being a city, so that would be great actually.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIn the long term relaxing zoning for high density doesn't seem to do much for rent by itself. Even very high density cities, when left to the free market, continue to see massive increases in the price of rent until people start moving out, such as Hong Kong. Now of course, relaxing zoning is important and necessary, you can't have a city with single family housing. It's just not a sustainable solution.
- Kalium 6y ago> Now of course, relaxing zoning is important and necessary, you can't have a city with single family housing. It's just not a sustainable solution. Much of SF's voters see this as the greatest of heresies. The honest and earnest expectation is that SF can, should, and shall remain mostly detached single family homes forever. They vote accordingly, and often make common cause with the left-NIMBYs. Perhaps unsurprisingly, this has not produced a sustainable state of affairs.
- sudosysgen 6y ago"Left-NIMBYs" are not opposed to increases in density. What they are opposed to is short-sighted pure free market solutions, which is what would happen if they gave way. Strategically, the current situation is preferable to deregulation of housing, which will not only not fix the rent problem, but also reduce quality of life and displace existing communities. The solution here is to make an alliance with the progressive left for an actually effective solution that implies increasing density, while building public housing and having well-tuned rent control systems in place.
- astrange 6y agoBut they are opposed to increases in density. This article is a response to Nathan Robinson (a guy who goes around dressing like a plantation owner) writing an article that poor people should not have density because they deserve to live in picturesque SF Victorians too. (Which, if they're public and you give them out for free, excludes whoever doesn't get there first.) The entire point of the left-NIMBY alliance is that the NIMBYs want everything to look like the 50s farmland it was when they were born, and they get this by pretending to be leftist and calling it "not affordable housing".