4 ms·
Same experience. They always back down. Not to continue an old argument, but to continue an old argument, these are the good medallioned guys who are regulated
by patio11 15y ago
Same experience. They always back down.
Not to continue an old argument, but to continue an old argument, these are the good medallioned guys who are regulated by the state so that they can't scam you. This is supposed to provide an advantage over e.g. Ubercab, where the perils of unregulated capitalism would allow a driver to cheat you. But they still try to scam you and their medallion is not going to get yanked for it. Meanwhile, Uber solves this technologically: they can't run payment scams because the system doesn't trust drivers with any part of the payment flow aside from hitting "The Ride Is Over."
- tptacek 15y agoSo: * Regulations need to catch up to Uber, fast. Uber is good. * Cabs should be regulated, for public safety and consumer protection. They're a unique intersection of low-barrier-to-entry, vulnerable-consumer, and serious externalities. * Cabs are not well regulated now. * I am ambivalent about business plans premised on "everyone recognizes that reg X is broken, so we'll force the issue by ignoring the reg and going right to market". If Uber gets to, maybe so do investment banks.
- gojomo 15y agoUntil there's evidence of abuse, why do "regulations need to catch up to Uber, fast"? (Unless by 'catch up to' you mean 'legalize unconditionally'.) Perhaps smartphone-dispatching, sticky reputations, and non-cash payments solve all the safety and 'consumer protection' issues better than the corrupt, captured, regulatory-commission system. That regulatory system, despite decades (or centuries!) of head-start, has resulted in a situation where "cabs are not well regulated now".
- hartror 15y agoUntil there's evidence of abuse, why do "regulations need to catch up to Uber, fast"? The ideal of course is regulators are proactive in regulating, rather than waiting for the horse to bolt before deciding the door should be kept closed. The Ubercab situation is a strong signal to regulators that the landscape is changing and they should be considering changes.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe ideal of course is regulators are proactive in regulating, rather than waiting for the horse to bolt before deciding the door should be kept closed. This is a good idea in the case of low probability, high impact events. For example, counterparty contagion in the financial system or oil spills. But in the case of low impact events, it's pointless. Take a few obvious precautions (e.g., track all the drivers) but otherwise just wait for problems to arise before fixing them. The risk of an unregulated system is very low - a few consumers get scammed out of $12. The risk of regulation is very high - many consumers may be deprived of a considerable consumer surplus (i.e., they may not get a ride at all, or may be forced to overpay for a regulated cab).
- tptacek 15y agoConsumer protection is one goal of taxi regulation, but public safety is another.
- temphn 15y agoRight wing autocrats talk about security, left wing autocrats talk about safety. What they really invariably do is take away freedom.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- hartror 15y agoI am more worried about public safety than consumer protection personally. I know in my city there has been a lot of crime associated with our heavily policed taxi industry, the opportunity for these threats to both passengers and drivers exists with a business like Ubercabs as well.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYou don't think a cabbie using Uber knows that there is an electronic record of them picking up a passenger? If anything, Uber is safer than yellow cabs. But lets suppose this really were an issue. There is a simple solution: charge each taxi a flat $10k/year license fee (with no cap on the number of licenses issued). Use the proceeds to hire full time undercover taxi inspectors. That gets you about 1 inspector for every 10 cabs. Assuming each inspector rides 10x/day (i.e. 5 hours/day riding, 30 min/ride), each taxi will be inspected every single day on average.
- temphn 15y agobut most regulations are useless and serve only the bureaucrats who proposed them, and there is little scrutiny on the tens of thousands of pages in the federal register. democracy is highly inefficient for this purpose. no one is going to elect obama to change EPA regulation 1.2.093 or whatever. so the only way to sunset a bad rule in practice is to incentivize flagrant public nullification.
- tptacek 15y agoI do not agree that most regulations are useless, or that they serve only bureaucrats.