8 ms·
Turn off that camera during virtual meetings, environmental study says
- melling 6y agoAnother little idea... Why can't we just stop using coal all over the world? http://h4labs.org/ive-got-another-stupid-idea-to-deal-with-climate-change/ http://h4labs.org/ive-got-another-stupid-idea-to-deal-with-c...
- bioinformatics 6y agoI think it would be great, all the Zoom servers in China might be moved to some place with better standards.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoBecause it takes work and capital to replace that generation with cleaner alternatives. It's already being done; have you considered working towards speeding up the transition?
- melling 6y agoI’ve been waiting over 20 years. You might not have noticed but we are increasing the number of coal power plants globally. The decrease in natural gas prices has accelerated the closing of coal in the US, ... anyway, I would suggest that you look into this a little more. We’ve know about this problem for quite some time https://www.forbes.com/sites/williampentland/2014/11/30/why-google-stopped-trying-to-make-renewable-energy-cheaper-than-coal/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/williampentland/2014/11/30/why-... None of these little ideas come close to the damage done by coal power
- Dma54rhs 6y agoAnd why poor people don't stop being so poor while you're at it.
- mmglr 6y ago> Just one hour of videoconferencing or streaming, for example, emits 150-1,000 grams of carbon dioxide (a gallon of gasoline burned from a car emits about 8,887 grams), requires 2-12 liters of water and demands a land area adding up to about the size of an iPad Mini. Out of curiosity what is the water used for? Is it from hydroelectric power? Also, what is "land area adding up to the size of iPad Mini" referring to?
- supertrope 6y agoPower plants use water as coolant. Coal fired plants and nuclear plants with their cooling towers. Oil and natural gas takes water to produce.
- Rochus 6y agoI don't know if this is significant compared to other, much more effective measures (see e.g. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aa7541 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aa7541), or other energy wasters in IT (see e.g. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320436353_Energy_efficiency_across_programming_languages_how_do_energy_time_and_memory_relate https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320436353_Energy_ef...).
- stunt 6y agoWe aren't particularly efficient species if you look at anything that we do.
- manfredo 6y agoI think a lot of these claims can make sense on paper, but often don't really add up to meaningful impact if actually implemented. Hypothetically, turning off your webcam reduces overall network traffic and would reduce the resources required to deliver adequate connection speeds. But in reality, modest reductions in internet traffic won't impact the datacenters and network infrastructures that have already been built. A more likely outcome is that network traffic is used for other applications. Similar situations exist when pointing to the environmental impact of meat production, for example. Not consuming meat would reduce transportation of feed, and transportation accounts for almost all of the carbon emissions from meat production. But that only actually reduces emissions if we assume that the total amount of transportation would go down, rather than the same transportation capacity being used for other goods.
- orev 6y agoIt doesn’t get into the details of what “processing” means, but I suspect the processing of the video data itself adds significantly to the overhead. Cameras may (probably) don’t have hardware video encoders for the best codecs, so the processing on the CPU would use quite a bit of power. And on the servers, depending on what you’re doing, there’s a lot of mixing and reprocessing that may need to be done on the streams. My own laptop isn’t that old, and the fan spins up often enough on calls that you know the CPU is chugging more than usual.
- bawolff 6y agoVideo conferencing is real time. You don't have the latency budget to do really intensive CPU based encoding (although ibviously there is still encoding). Hardware acceleration for video encoding is also quite common in many consumer products.
- Tarsul 6y agoThe assumption that freed capacity would be gobbled up by other consumption (100% of it) is a strong one that I wouldn't agree on. Reducing consumption (e.g. internet, meat) means that less would be produced in the long run, thus it does have a positive impact on the climate. We can talk about details or exceptions but the general idea that less consumption = less consumption [sic] = less climate warming is firm. I think the greater point is that we have to look at a long time horizon with long lasting changes to really see this, that's why we as humans have trouble implementing these changes.
- unforeseen9991 6y agoKill all humans, environmental study says.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoWhy stop there? just cancel the meeting entirely and your meeting emissions drop to zero.
- thallium205 6y agoWhy stop there? Just zip yourself up in a body bag and die. Do you hate nature?
- t-writescode 6y agoDoesn’t this work out to just mean our electronics grid needs to become more carbon neutral, especially in places that house internet infrastructure and data centers? It doesn’t seem like “use less YouTube and video chat” is the most impactful answer here. Also, the comparison to 1 gallon of gas is a bit disingenuous when a car probably uses 2 or more gallons of gas when driving continuously for an hour (60mph, 30mpg)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- supertrope 6y agoTalk about missing the forest for the trees. Turning off ones camera will make business leaders less willing to permanently virtualize some meetings. Getting on a plane, riding a taxi, and using a hotel & convention center is a lot more emissions than video chat.
- jsjohnst 6y ago> Talk about missing the forest for the trees. Exactly. I’d need to do some homework to prove it, but my theory is more power is used every second for Bitcoin than an hour’s worth of videoconferencing worldwide. That said, we have to start somewhere, but is videoconferencing really the thing that’ll have any positive impact on CO2 emissions? Edit: Per this source[0] (no claims to its accuracy), a single transaction on Bitcoin causes nearly 300kg of CO2 to be emitted. So compared even to the high point of the article’s range (aka 1kg per hour meeting, though the included chart shows ~1/10th that for Zoom), that’s multiple orders of magnitude higher, per transaction. [0] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption Edit 2: I did some further research and multiple seemingly solid sources give conservative estimates of Bitcoin electricity consumption in the range of 80-100TWh per annum. To put that number in perspective, that’s more electricity per year than all of Google’s servers worldwide combined since its founding over twenty years ago (estimates put that number around 75TWh). I’m not going to keep digging, but based on the numbers I saw, I have a feeling Bitcoin uses more electricity per year than AWS, Google, FB, Microsoft, and Apple’s data centers combined per year. I’ll leave it to you to decide if Bitcoin is worth it and you should just turn off your webcam next time you’re on a videoconference to save the environment!
- frankenst1 6y agoBitcoin's high electricity usage comes from finding the block (header), not from processing the transactions inside it, i.e. the same energy is used to find a block with 0 transactions or 10,000 transactions. So, more transactions don't cause higher electricity usage. All miners run similar hardware and software so the only way to be competitive is to find cheaper energy sources, which is why Bitcoin mining scoops up energy that is either very cheap, renewable or would be wasted otherwise (e.g. remote hydro power plants). So, electricity consumed on the Bitcoin network has a much smaller CO2/Wh impact than what you would expect on average. If any publication fails to acknowledge any of these key points in estimating Bitcoin's environmental impact, I would be very cautious in trusting their conclusions.
- ironmagma 6y agoThe original study says a car driving using 1 gallon of gas is 9 times worse than running video conferencing for an hour. My car burns 1.5 gallons in an hour (and that's with highway efficiency), so that means driving for an hour is 13.5 times worse than running a virtual meeting. Considering my commute used to be 45 minutes each way, videoconferencing seems pretty reasonably better than the alternative.
- angry_octet 6y agoThis is the kind of trash study, designed solely as PR fluff, that does so much damage to science. The fact that this was published almost instantly ( https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921344920307072?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09213... ) in a journal with an IF of 8 makes me concerned for the entire field.
- throwdbaaway 6y agoSo, was it irresponsible for youtube/facebook/netflix to push for vp9/av1 at a time when most hardware couldn't decode it efficiently?
- aaron695 6y agoThese studies are just toxic to the community. They are simply not true when you look at the data. Researchers are incentivized to look at the larger estimates along the way. They are almost always not as large as claimed. Jobs and life is hard, working remotely takes an emotional toll in parts, putting this on top on people doesn't help their well being. There's no point saving CO2 emissions if it breaks you as a human or you have to go back to the office. If universities really care, how about they start creating open codexes that allow more effect use of our resources rather than these studies. I get there are patent issues with things like H.266. How about universities theorise on how to fix the patent problem and how to speed up the process. We got a vaccine in a year, how do we do that in working groups? Turning off the camera in meetings is often a good idea, see other articles on that.
- maxerickson 6y agoThis kind of analysis is pretty slippery. I live next to Lake Michigan. Power generation here doesn't consume any water, it adds a bit of heat to it and returns it to the environment in otherwise the same condition. There's likely some evaporative losses, but we have precipitation throughout the year (it gets moderately dry for a few weeks in May and sometimes in October). The land footprints should be expressed in servings of rice or something (so that people can compare their internet usage to something they aren't going to stop doing).
- bawolff 6y agoStudies on how much carbon data transfer actual use tend to be all over the place, i dont think a single study should be treated all that highly until the various studies start agreeing with each other