3 ms·
On the other hand users are generally pretty poor at managing software themselves and as long as it works they'll happily and probably ignorantly run something
by duxup 6y ago
On the other hand users are generally pretty poor at managing software themselves and as long as it works they'll happily and probably ignorantly run something that is not secure already and needs an update.
- wolco5 6y agoThat would cover users who are poor at managing software. Being able to turn them off would require someone to be good at managing software. Why remove control from those users?
- duxup 6y agoI want to think that folks who would chose that option would be responsible, but the amount I hear from other developers who defer updates on Windows 10 to the maximum (1 year...) and still are upset when they have to reboot makes me think that even experienced users present a risk.
- ziml77 6y agoI don't want to be saying that we should remove control, but I actually do think it's reasonable to. Even on a single-user device, security issues are not isolated. An infected machine will likely be used for things like spam and DDOS. If you make something available for people to toggle that improves their experience, people are going to take advantage of that even if they don't really grasp or decide to ignore the consequences. In the case of updates the improved experience is not being nagged or forced to restart an application or the whole OS. And unfortunately the only way to really gatekeep that control to people who know what they're doing is giving it enterprise pricing.
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> users are generally pretty poor at managing software This is an assertion which begs many questions. Who are these users? What do you mean by "generally"? What do you mean by "poor"? What do you mean with "managing software"? Which software specifically? Why is "managing software" hard? What are specific case where this might be true? Is this statement falsifiable? For instance, how does age, social background, education level, language, culture,... factor into the experience of "managing software"? Sure, the problem can't be software itself in it's entirety? See, statements like these tend to break down once you start digging into the murky nuances and specificities of reality. Moreover, accepting them at face value tends to reinforce a belief which isn't based on fact: that the users of digital technology can't manage their devices, and therefore shouldn't be confronted with managing their devices. ... which is then translated and implemented in interfaces and systems that simply lack the functionality that gives users fine grained control over what is or isn't installed. Over a longer term, this promotes a form of "lazy thinking" in which users simply don't question what happens under the hood of their devices. Sure, people are aware of the many issues concerning privacy, personal data, security and so on. But ask them how they could make a meaningful change, and the answers will be limited to what's possible within the limitations of what the device offers. A great example of this would be people using a post-it to cover the camera in the laptop bezel. People don't know what happens inside their machine, they don't trust what happens on their machine, and there's no meaningful possibility to look under the hood and come to a proper understanding... so they revert to the next sensible thing they have: taping a post-it over the lens. The post-it doesn't solve the underlying issue - a lack of understanding which was cultivated - but it does solve a particular symptom: the inability to control what that camera does.
- duxup 6y agoI honestly am not at all sure what you mean by much of that. Demographics don't change the fact that if you don't automatically update software, many users simply won't. That's bad.
- jjkaczor 6y ago... in the usual pedantry of HN your use of "poor" was interpreted to mean socio-economic, rather than... "just bad at something"...
- duxup 6y agoOh I see. That's, weird, but thanks for letting me know.
- Someone 6y agoI don’t see how one could parse ”On the other hand users are generally pretty poor at managing software themselves” and assign that interpretation to “poor”.
- duxup 6y agoI agree, but the user who responded to me seemed to talk about demographics as if I had meant "poor" as in not having much money. The internet is global, sometimes I think things get lost in translation.
- CaptArmchair 6y agoThat's a reductionist reading of my comment. I'm challenging your initial assertion that "people are poor at managing software". That's not enough of an explanation to support the second part of your claim: > and as long as it works they'll happily and probably ignorantly run something that is not secure already and needs an update. Are they poor at managing software because they are ignorantly running insecure software? Or are they ignorantly running insecure software because they are poor at managing software? The replies so far take the entire context out of the picture and reframes the issue to "Users use their devices the 'wrong way'." and this can only be solved through technological advances. I'm here questioning and challenging those assertions.