3 ms·
The fuels in the rocket. The fuels in the support vehicles. The fuels for the platform. The fuels in the helicopters. Even if all of them are produced from
by sandworm101 6y ago
The fuels in the rocket. The fuels in the support vehicles. The fuels for the platform. The fuels in the helicopters. Even if all of them are produced from solar power, a 747 needs less than 1% of the same total fuel per passenger. No matter how it is fueled, a ballistic rocket needs orders of magnitude more energy than conventional flight. It is not an energy-efficient means of realworld transport.
- jackric 6y agoThen price in carbon neutral fuel production to the ticket. There will be passengers rich enough to pay it. If you've got a problem with that I imagine your real issues are about status envy not environmentalism.
- sandworm101 6y agoLol, I'm no communist but I do appreciate that market forces alone will never address the carbon/energy problem, let alone the wider problem of pollution overall. Just because someone has the money do to so doesn't mean that we should support them burning away the energy to light a small city simply to get to their vacation spot a few hours faster than on a private jet.
- jackric 6y agoHow about reaching a dying father a few hours faster? A middle class person might judge the extra $5-10k (from savings) worth it. If SpaceX/energy company deploys a new nuclear power plant (and one day fusion) to provide the energy, why should you care? It's a new energy source and not competing away your personal idea of worthwhile energy use.
- eyesee 6y agoNot sure where you're getting these figures. Here's an analysis which estimates CO2 emissions from Starship for E2E will be roughly similar to those from a 777 flight based on fuel consumption. Depending upon how the methane is generated it could be a carbon-neutral flight. This doesn't include support vehicles, but that would be quite speculative at this stage. https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/12/spacex-rocket-emissions-similar-to-large-jets-crossing-the-oceans.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/12/spacex-rocket-emission...
- sandworm101 6y agoLook deeper at those numbers. Net fuel consumption/emissions is different than "rocket emissions". Rocket fuel isn't diesel. The emissions from the actual rocket in flight do not capture the total emissions generated in the creation/preparation/compression of rocket fuels. Some rockets produce literally zero carbon during flight (liquid hydrogen + liquid oxygen = water) but that doesn't mean plenty of coal/oil wasn't used in the creation of those fuels.
- m4rtink 6y agoYep - pushing air away for 12+ hours at high sub sonic speeds might indeed be less efficient than a sub orbital flight where you exit the atmosphere in a couple minutes and cover most of the distance without meaningful air resistance in the vacuum of space.
- sacred_numbers 6y agoDo you have any numbers to back that up? A 747 burns 10-11 tons of fuel per hour and carries about 360 passengers. For a 12 hour flight, that is about 350kg of fuel per passenger. Starship's tanks hold approximately 250 tons of fuel and 950 tons of liquid oxygen. In order to match the per passenger fuel efficiency of a 747 they would need to carry about 700 passengers. Starship has about 20% more internal volume as a 747, so it seems likely that they would be able to fit at least the same number of passengers. That puts them at about 50% of the fuel efficiency of a 747. In addition, methane combustion produces 2.75kg of CO2 per kg of fuel, while kerosene produces 3kg CO2 per kg of fuel. If they are able to fit 20% more passengers than a 747 due to the larger internal volume then they would be within about 66% efficiency on a CO2 emissions per passenger basis.
- sandworm101 6y agoAs I replied to others, rocket fuel is very different. The total carbon emissions include not just the fuel used by the rocket but the fuels used to create those fuels before the flight. Liquid oxygen is not carbon-free as creating liquid oxygen requires lots and lots of energy. So too methane which is heavily refined/compressed/cooled, processes that take more energy, create more emissions, than burning the fuel itself during flight. The fuel for a 747 is not nearly as energy/carbon-intensive to create.