6 ms·
I'd be somewhat more interested in a program like this if it were being run by someone I believed actually wanted in good faith to improve education/business, r
by _delirium 15y ago
I'd be somewhat more interested in a program like this if it were being run by someone I believed actually wanted in good faith to improve education/business, rather than having ulterior political motives. Thiel is quite open that his main motivation is that he thinks universities promote politics he dislikes, so he'd like to destroy them for that reason. He also claims that in doing so he'd improve education, but it seems like a secondary motivation. My guess is that he would be willing to accept education even getting slightly worse as a tradeoff, if it got rid of the negative influence (in his view) of universities for libertarian politics.
(See Woz and Salman Khan for examples of education reformers who seem to have education reform as their actual #1 goal.)
edit: Of course, as full disclosure I'm in academia, so perhaps have my own ulterior motives. =] But honestly I think Salman Khan's approach is a bigger threat to the higher-education status quo than Thiel's is, mainly because it's much more scalable. So from a pure self-interest point of view I ought to dislike that one more!
- szany 15y agoSource? I hope you're not implying that the point of the Fellowship is to destroy academia.
- krasmark 15y agoI'm not sure this is exactly a source, but this article by Thiel tends to imply that he thinks the system is pretty broken : http://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/the-education-of-a-libertarian/ http://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/the-educa.... And then Thiel has talked about the education bubble (links on HN previously, too) : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2431431 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2431431. Thiel is definitely pro "different" from the current system. I think the idea of promoting more entrepreneurial activities earlier is great, but it seems very anti-university/higher ed in his vision rather than as an alternative path.
- szany 15y agoSee my comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2584159 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2584159
- hugh3 15y agoI don't think Thiel is naive enough to think that anything you can do with twenty people and two million dollars will "destroy" academia, but he does seem to have an agenda and the desire to prove a point. The point, however, is silly. Cherrypick the twenty brightest students you can find, give 'em a bunch of money and all the connections that come from having Peter Thiel invested in your success, and I'm sure that a lot of 'em will do well. But that doesn't scale.
- rowaway1 15y agothe spread of startup accelerators in the style of y combinator suggests that the entrepreneurship-as-education model is growing. not going to scale to everyone, but that's not the point. the point thiel's making is that entrepreneurs fare well without school, perhaps better, because when they're not in school taking instruction, they're in the world building things. if that's true, what's silly about it? if it's true that we're hampering entrepreneurship by keeping a special breed of human being tied up on class during 4 of their prime years, when we could accelerate entrepreneurship by giving them money to start things, then that's actually quite a profound mistake. so if thiel's project succeeds to the point where more such accelerators pop up, siphoning entrepreneurs out of school to achieve success without a degree, then he's made a profound point.
- alexandros 15y ago"Thiel is quite open that his main motivation is that he thinks universities promote politics he dislikes, so he'd like to destroy them for that reason." [citation needed]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- kenjackson 15y agoActually your theory about Thiel matches mine. In fact several months ago I noted on HN that we'll see a full attack on academia by the right through the 2012 election. Some of it overt, but much of it subtle, e.g., it's not our intellect that makes us a great country, but rather something no one can accurately measure, like our ability to empathize. Regarding his politics, he's given multiple accomodating interviews to National Review, the founding conservative magazine in the US. And you can just look at his public donation record -- it's more than a quarter of a million dollars -- 100% Republican. Of course he won't come out and say, "I'm trying to dismantle higher education as part of a larger political agenda", but at least to some (including myself), the evidence is striking.
- wheels 15y agoI find it really disingenuous to paint someone as intelligent and quirky as Thiel with the "bah, republican" brush. In terms of where he's putting his money, bear in mind that he's a multi-billionaire; donating a quarter million for him is not a substantial capital commitment. I wouldn't even call Thiel's goals fundamentally political; he's trying to shape society and throws money at things that he believes will bend it more to his liking. I don't think he gives two shits about the survival of either of the dominant American political parties.
- kenjackson 15y agodonating a quarter million for him is not a substantial capital commitment. Most of his donations were the maximum allowed by US law. I wouldn't even call Thiel's goals fundamentally political You don't work with the National Review, the Cato Institute, and consistently donate (and to only one political party) if its not fundamentally political. he's trying to shape society and throws money at things that he believes will bend it more to his liking. Umm, yeah, that's what all politicians are doing. My point is is that he's working through and with the conservative political system to make this happen, as their goals are aligned. Take someone like Salman Khan, OTOH, who is also trying to make a big change, but seems to be taking a much less political approach.
- kiba 15y agoHe's dedicated to the cause of eliminating death and aging. That's good enough for me. In order to eliminate aging and death, you must have an educated and ambitious populace who can mobilize resources to wage war on mortality. Yes, he's a techno-libertarian, but like all great techno-libertarians he's interested in killing what kill human beings and crystallizing human potential. Aubrey de Grey even mention libertarians as one of the group that is most supportive of his work. Why libertarianism and anti-aging/anti-death and technology in general goes together? I have no idea.
- rhizome 15y agoHe's dedicated to the cause of eliminating death and aging. That's good enough for me. Ridiculous. Anybody who professes commitment to "eliminating death" is hiding a tax-shelter.
- samtp 15y ago>eliminating death This is a pointless exercise that is doomed to failure. Sure, we may be able to extend a person's life to 200 or 300 years. But will we be able to cure all future diseases (for the next million years), eliminate accidents, natural disasters, and sudden body failure? What about when the sun burns out in a few billion years? Will we be able to successfully colonize another planet while keeping the same safety precautions for human life? Death is as much a part of life as birth. It will not be eliminated unless you eliminate life. To think otherwise is a denial of reality.
- puredemo 15y ago>Death is as much a part of life as birth. It will not be eliminated unless you eliminate life. To think otherwise is a denial of reality. The immortal Turritopsis nutricula jellyfish would beg to differ.
- kiba 15y agoThere will always be people who murders other, doesn't mean we should never try to lower the possibility of murder. Same thing with death. We should lower the possibility that you will die within in the next 5, 25, 100, and thousand of years, or even million.
- archgoon 15y agoHi, I'm always a bit confused whenever people talk about how the Khan Academy is revolutionary. How is it significantly different than the MIT Open Courseware? Is it just felt that the quality of the lectures is so much better?
- nerfhammer 15y agoKhan Academy is designed entirely for singular at-home study, where OCW is sharing course materials meant for MIT classes which are often difficult to follow if you don't have access to the labs, recitation, textbooks, readings, etc. that are meant to go along with the lectures.
- iandanforth 15y agoI'm curious, have you used both? Did you find them equal? When I've them I find myself using Khan academy for longer periods of time than I originally intended and OCW for shorter periods of time. Genuinely curious about your experience!
- Eliezer 15y agoI was there during some of those dinner-table conversations. Topics that were raised: Number of for-profit and non-profit founders who didn't get all the way through college; how successful founders and interesting people seem to be missing the "imitation gene" (Thiel's term); how the standard system filters out different kinds of innovative people at each step of the process; how making it possible to bypass a single stage of the system might have a multiplicative effect on the total number of innovators who survive to adulthood with their creativity intact. Topics which were not raised, at all, not even in the slightest: Universities having a left-wing influence. I'm genuinely shocked at the amount of vitriol and conspiracy-theorizing which Peter Thiel is getting over this.
- arram 15y agoCan you elaborate on what he meant by 'imitation gene'?
- Eliezer 15y agoPeople who found interesting companies are more likely to fail-to-conform in other ways as well, which is why other venture capitalists don't fund them - they want jeans, not someone wrapped in a towel. People who engage in standard trendy forms of "nonconformity" that everyone immediately recognizes as "nonconformist" are called "dangerous" or "edgy" or "innovative". People who lack the imitation gene are called "weird" or "crazy". That's probably not exactly the way Peter Thiel would phrase it - I'm uncomfortable speaking for others - but I don't think he'd disagree.
- bugsy 15y ago> Thiel is quite open that his main motivation is that he thinks universities promote politics he dislikes, so he'd like to destroy them for that reason. _Delirium, could you please provide a citation both where Thiel openly stated that he wants to destroy universities, and that he wants to destroy them because they "promote politics he dislikes"? Thanks in advance.
- rms 15y agoThis is filled with disenguous statements, but I'll pick on one of them. You use the word "destroy". Thiel doesn't want to destroy universities. He thinks their product is overvalued and that the price should be lower. One reality where the price of college was revalued would be one where a whole lot less people go to college, unless supply and demand becomes even more borked.