4 ms·
I don't buy the pattern of this argumentation which is basically: "We did something like X a century ago, so X is not chilling new trend; X is quite okay." It
by kazinator 6y ago
I don't buy the pattern of this argumentation which is basically:
"We did something like X a century ago, so X is not chilling new trend; X is quite okay."
It doesn't take much imagination to substitute various behaviors for X.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoYou seem to be creating the pattern yourself. I see: "We did something like X a century ago, history repeats, full stop." Where did "X is quite okay" come from?
- kazinator 6y agoThe tone of the article conveys agreement with the intervention. For instance, the closing remark "in both cases, private business had to step in when the consequences became evident" could be rendered neutrally as "in both cases, private businesses stepped in when the consequences became evident." "Had to step in" has the effect of defending the actions, by insinuating that they had no alternative.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoSubtle, but I agree.