2 ms·
A nationality is always connected to a (system of) government, representing a set of shared values in any democratic system. The best attempt at denationalizat
by jeroenhd 6y ago
A nationality is always connected to a (system of) government, representing a set of shared values in any democratic system.
The best attempt at denationalization right now is the EU and their intent on creating a European superstate, not unlike the USA. Even still, I share a great deal of values with most of the EU citizens and will oppose the formation of an actual unified European state until at least values like "democracy" and the trias politica are shared across the country.
Perhaps total denationalization is a nice end goal for humanity, but it's unattainable as long as there are still significant groups in the world who don't believe in things like "women are equal to men".
I agree that connecting a nationality to words like "true" or "proud to be a" is often problematic, but you cannot ignore that there are differences between regions. You can pretty clearly see the border of Scotland on a Brexit vote map, for example; all of Scotland was, on average, anti-Brexit, and most of England was, on average, pro-Brexit. Does that mean that all Scots are inherently pro-EU? Of course not. But erasing borders will change very little about the attachment and emotions people feel toward the bit of land they were born in.
- PeterisP 6y agoI can't agree with "A nationality is always connected to a (system of) government" - while a nation is a more political thing than simply an ethnic group, the core of many (most?) nations is not a government but rather people united by culture, language, ethnicity and history; territory and government are secondary aspects. If we look at the age of nationalism, Italian and German nations are good examples - the nations formed/consolidated long before they got united governments; the late 19th century pan-Slavic movement was arguably an expression of nationalism that transcended Russian Empire; if we look at nationalism in Latin America, it again precedes formation of the respective governments and survives substantial changes in political values. Etc. Nationality is not formed or defined by a (system of) government, quite the contrary, nations have a certain tendency to obtain a separate (system of) government - the desire for national self-determinism works against government systems that include other nations. The dissolution of Yugoslavia and USSR are some examples, but the instability of various regions in Middle East and Africa are also in part caused by national identities that do not map to the post-colonial set of governments and borders. Furthermore, the national unity and values is not really defined by the current political system. Many nations have had multiple huge changes in political regimes over the last hundred years while unquestionably staying the same nation, and political values generally are not the core thing forming a national identity.