8 ms·
After all that happened, Now it makes sense for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens. That’s said, the primary use is expected to b
by mrtksn 6y ago
After all that happened, Now it makes sense for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens.
That’s said, the primary use is expected to be control of journalism on Youtube.
After Erdogan took over almost all of the media, many of the fired journalists started Youtube channels and got more popular than the media Erdogan has a hold on.
He now wants to impose the same controls that he has over TV channels. The body responsible is called RTUK and recently got regulatory powers over internet broadcasting too. It infamously fines TV channels that are not friendly enough to Erdogan at the smallest mistake and turning blind eye on pro-Erdogan channels. This is because, the fines need to go through the committee in which Erdogan holds the majority.
To what extent you might ask? Well, there’s a talk show host on the TV who got destroyed for having a guest who said “let’s save the kids” when talking about governments dealings with the Kurds and there’s a TV channel who got a slap on the wrist after a public outcry for hosting commentators asking people to keep arms at home and identify potential targets among their neighbours who might be Erdogan’s political rivals.
The double standards are off the charts. Youtube is probably becoming Erdogan’s double standards enforcer.Everything is going to be legal, of course.
If youtube doesn’t behave, more fines will come. The government would usually turn a blind eye to some practices in the industry and will slap fines to those who are not in line. Turkey has strong as GDPR personal information protection laws, probably a land mine field for ad-agencies and that’s how they will get their fines I would guess.
- _pmf_ 6y ago> for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens It's never the country that has this power. It's particular government bodies.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoIn Turkey AKP/Erdogan is the "country". The beef between twitter and Erdogan's AKP is quite old and goes back to at least the times of the coup, and then when the Turkish police got doxxed by CthulhuSec. edit: tone down my own opinion bc toyg is right in their critique
- toyg 6y ago> times of the coup (which is a shame it failed), Please take this as a honest suggestion, without any criticism meant: it's easier to persuade people if you limit the display of bias. By simply rewording that as "times of the attempted coup," you remain an objective observer and carry more authority from the reader's perspective. This said, I know it's difficult and that things are tough when it comes to Turkey. Hopefully things will get better at some point, nobody lives forever.
- ulucs 6y agoYeah Turkey would be better off being ruled by an Islamist cult /s. Thanks for providing me with new perspectives HN
- throwaway313371 6y agoI was here for the coup where 200 people died and another 2,000 were injured. None of us like AKP or Tayipp, but you really need to shut your mouth hoping that a muslim extremist (Fetullah Gülen) should have taken over the country. Really, that's like hoping that the Evangelical white supremacists had succeeded in taking over the USA last week. wtf is wrong with you? Why do you want terrorists to take over the ONLY democracy in the middle-east? (edited for typo)
- pjc50 6y agoThis has been a bit of a problem in the West of backing "rebels" indiscriminately without checking if their politics is actually worse than the politics of those they're rebelling against.
- throwaway313371 6y agoAmericans talk about freedom and democracy a lot. Then we fund coups in democratically run countries who just happen not to want to play ball with us, like Iran, Venezuela and Iraq. When it comes back to bite us, "mea culpa, mistakes were made". Americans really need to stay in our lane and learn to look after our own people instead of demonizing others. We cannot even have peaceful elections, and until we fix gerrymandering we have zero moral high ground to talk about the fairness of foreign elections. Come see an election in Turkiye. Turks dislike it, but thy accept the election results. During the last regional elections, I had friends and family members who were election monitors. Some of them stayed in those rooms, staring at the election boxes without leaving for two weeks to ensure the integrity of the election, and that is not an exaggeration. Tayipp lost Istanbul and Ankara, and he did it fantastically. Istanbul's initial margin was 25,000 votes. When Tayipp had the election results annulled, Turks got pissed and he lost the second election by 800,000 votes. Unlike Americans, Turks really care about their democracy.
- antibuddy 6y agoIt should be noted that the US has the same double standards, but enforced by silicon valley corps themselves in union. Moral of the story: Power currupts.
- fabiospampinato 6y agoI'd say more like: power matters, words on paper not so much.
- golondon 6y agoIt's not the same thing. As long as you don't cause violence or you're not violating the terms of service which you accepted while joining to the service, they wouldn't remove your content or block you. Of course, you can come up with one off examples of ML models screwing things up but it's not the intention while developing those models. Turkish government's intention here is getting content that criticise them removed, by asking to representative in Turkey who by the way must be a Turkish citizen, not just a person from any nationality who can speak Turkish. So that, they can apply Turkish law to this person if they would like to. If Youtube doesn't remove the content, possibly as they did with TV they are going to fine them. I don't see this model working for long time and expecting most of the companies to pull their representatives soon, if they open the door of every country getting content removed however they like, I'm sure there will be other countries who would want that and it would be terrible for freedom of speech.
- mancerayder 6y ago>As long as you don't cause violence or you're not violating the terms of service which you accepted while joining to the service, they wouldn't remove your content or block you. That's both optimistic and naive given that TOS can change at any time, and interpretation aren't subject to appeal with a transparent process.
- golondon 6y agoYes, it can change any time and you can follow what's changed. It's also open to appeal to the company and I have seen mistakes corrected. My point is there is no secret agenda to bring up a content that supports one view. What Turkish gov wants to achieve is that, taking down the content they don't like. They have taken over all mainstream TV channels and you wouldn't see a line of critic on any channel, if you do it's quite likely you will not be invited to debate next time.
- eplanit 6y ago"After all that happened, Now it makes sense for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens." Wow. Fear ushers in tyranny, for sure.