3 ms·
For a 100kWh battery, you're taking 6MW of power to charge the battery to full in a minute. 6MW is a small nuclear reactor or a medium sized hydroelectric dam.
by gambiting 6y ago
For a 100kWh battery, you're taking 6MW of power to charge the battery to full in a minute. 6MW is a small nuclear reactor or a medium sized hydroelectric dam. I cannot imagine a charging station wired for that kind of power being drawn when charging, nor can I imagine a connector that would safely carry this power. It can be done "safely" in the million volt range, but you're not going to charge a battery(typically 400-800V) with that. Just for a "fun" calculation, 6MW at 800V is 7500 amps - the cable for it would be bigger and heavier than the car, if it's even possible at all. And then finally, I can't believe there really exists a battery that just wouldn't boil at those rates, nor that we could effectively cool it.
- londons_explore 6y agoBatteries do exist that can charge that fast. Some RC car batteries are "60C" indicating they can do a full discharge in 1 minute. To achieve that, substantial capacity and lifespan tradeoffs are made, and you're right that cooling becomes necessary. 7500 amps isn't 'bigger than car' territory either. If you're happy to have copper the thickness of your forearm it wouldn't melt at 7500 amps, even with simple air cooling. "Not melting" isn't quite the standard we're after, but shows that it isn't unachievable.
- gambiting 6y agoThat's good to know - I was extrapolating from some 1000amp cables I had to work with, and those were already too big and heavy to move once you had any length of it at all. >>Some RC car batteries are "60C" indicating they can do a full discharge in 1 minute. I mean, plenty of batteries can discharge that quickly, but that isn't synonymous with them being able to charge that fast, no? I can think of several examples of batteries, both Ni-Cd as well as Lithium which can be safely discharged fully at very rapid speeds, but you can't(shouldn't?) charge them that quickly.
- me_me_me 6y agoUgh, you poor people need to get your own hydro dam - simple. In all seriousness, its hard for people to understand the values required and how scary those numbers in reality are. Petrol is great source of energy as it relatively non-violent, only compressed and combusted it will explode. Batteries on the other side are outright terrifying. Google people stabbing their phone batteries and see how violently they discharge. Scale that 4000mAh phone battery to the electric car. I would be terrified if something went wrong with charging station that could do a under 10mins charges. Materials getting older a crack in insulation and you are toasted.
- harg 6y agoJust to nitpick your numbers a bit. 6MW, while a lot of power, is still a lot less than your average nuclear reactor, even a small one (The reactors on the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle are 150MW each), and Hydro schemes are often in the thousands of MW. In fact, many single offshore wind turbines are capable of generating a lot more than 6MW. GW's Haliade-X tubines have an output of 13MW each.
- gambiting 6y agoI was going off of the fact that at least here in the UK more than half of all hydroelectric power dams are less than 6MW[0], actually closer to 1MW than 6MW, and for nuclear power the Bilibiono power station operates 11MW reactors[1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroelectricity_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydroelectricity_in_the_United... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EGP-6 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EGP-6