5 ms·
>You don't need to read books to be literate. You can read magazines, newspapers (paper or electronic) Where, even in the best, you'll find 1/10th the substanc
by coldtea 6y ago
>You don't need to read books to be literate. You can read magazines, newspapers (paper or electronic)
Where, even in the best, you'll find 1/10th the substance you'll find in the best of books, packaged in vacuous snippets for quick consumption, and written to gather advertising...
The person who wont read any of the classic books (be it science, non-fiction, literature, history, etc.) but will still read magazines and newspapers, I'll still call illiterate - even if the magazine was the Economist or the National Geographic, and not Men's Health and Cosmopolitan (which more often than not, is).
- donbrae 6y agoSurely being literate is simply being able to read and write coherently? Whether you read books, the Economist, academic papers, Hacker News, or whatever, I don't see how it matters.
- zo1 6y agoDoes it include "reading comprehension"? I understand being able to read and write, but understanding what you're reading should be part of it I think. And I don't mean "deep thought" level critique and understanding. More like following a paragraph and understanding what is being said.
- wzel 6y ago> Does it include "reading comprehension"? "Literacy"? Not really. AFAIK, there's the "functional literacy" term for that.
- coldtea 6y agoWhat good is literaracy (alone) without reading comprehension? Being able to read road signs and the like?
- wzel 6y agoI'd say that there can be degrees of reading comprehension, and I tend to view functional illiteracy as literacy attrition, kind of secondary illiteracy. I guess it's useful to distinguish it from strict illiteracy (somebody not having learned how to read in the first place), as it requires a different kind of treatment, even if the symptoms of both are similar.
- coldtea 6y ago>Surely being literate is simply being able to read and write coherently? In an idiocracy, it doesn't. Literacy meant more than simple being able to read and write on a technical level. (Not that most people not reading "even a book a year" can read and write coherently or "read the Economist" otherwise).
- noobermin 6y agoWhile I believe I'm sympathetic to you, I think the hang up people have is in your use of the word "literacy." I think most people wouldn't call people who can read a news article illiterate. I do agree it would be better if people read more actual books but this seems like a degree of literacy issue while illiterate tends to mean "completely unable to read."
- tapland 6y agoIt's usually called 'functional illiteracy'. If you can read the words in an article, but don't understand what it says, should you really be considered literate? Understanding what it says is not understanding the meanings of separate words, but the meaning of the text in question.
- noobermin 6y agoSure but even that's a bit of a distance from what they're arguing. I can imagine that someone can totally not read a book every year but still understand context of say a news article they've read. That is nowhere near functional illiteracy.
- Tade0 6y agoWhere, even in the best, you'll find 1/10th the substance you'll find in the best of books That's assuming people read the best books. Let's not forget that Fifty Shades of Grey was the best selling book of the decade (in the US): https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/2019/fifty-shades-of-grey-was-the-best-selling-book-of-the-decade-in-the-us-the-npd-group-says/ https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/press-releases/20...
- coldtea 6y ago>That's assuming people read the best books. Not doing that would still make them illiterate in some degree. But even with mediocre books, at least they wouldn't be reading the attention-killing dopamine chasing snippets of BS on most online websites. Do it sound like these "don't read even a book per year" people read The Well or LessWrong or something of the sort online?
- tapland 6y agoYou don't have to read books at all, and many people who do score poorly on literacy tests. It's not your ability to read words that is relevant, but your ability to understand contexts and meanings.
- alpaca128 6y ago> Do it sound like these "don't read even a book per year" people read The Well or LessWrong or something of the sort online? Your reading preferences are not the gold standard in what makes a good book or makes one "literate". The same applies to every other single individual. At the same time the internet obviously doesn't only contain "dopamine chasing snippets of BS". Online discussions and articles can improve critical thinking or make someone think deeper about their views and motivation just like literature can. Yet you deny that by bluntly saying all people reading no books are illiterate. As a side note, before you start gatekeeping literacy you may want to avoid grammar mistakes in your own writing. Though it will not make your point come across less elitist, unfortunately.
- 6y ago
- tester34 6y agoblogs of strong people, forums tend to be good too