3 ms·
Law is not like code or math: you don't follow an inexorable algorithm in law to arrive at the only possible interpretation of the law. When you do this kind of
by jcranmer 6y ago
Law is not like code or math: you don't follow an inexorable algorithm in law to arrive at the only possible interpretation of the law. When you do this kind of analysis and arrive at this kind of absurdity, more often than not, courts will find that the law actually doesn't permit this absurdity.
In this specific case, it's already possible to move jury trials to other districts for difficulty of finding impartial jurors, so it's almost certain that the courts would similarly rule that doing a similar change of venue poses no constitutional issue whatsoever.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asperous 6y agoYeah, I agree, courts are made up of people are designed to deal with the gray area as best they can. Courts deal with complex cases all the time. One thing they often look to in these gaps is intention. “District and state” was intended to provide a fair trial of your peers. Simply not having a trial would not be a fair trial, however choosing a nearby venue would likely pass the fair and reasonable test.
- giantg2 6y agoBut how do you explain that one knew what they where doing was unlawful? How can they if the law clearly states they cannot be prosecuted? If the law states that you cannot be fairly tried in that location, then to put them on trial would be a violation of rule of law. The people explicitly spoke through their representatives. If it was not specific or too specific, then the law needs to be changed by the legislature. This 'interpreting' the law to the detriment of the defendant is generally bullshit. If you use the basis of reasonable doubt and innocent until proven guilty, then it should result in defendant being dismissed. You can't expect people to telepathically know the law means something contrary to what it literally says.
- jcranmer 6y ago> But how do you explain that one knew what they where doing was unlawful? That doesn't matter. As the maxim goes, ignorance of the law is no excuse.
- giantg2 6y agoYou forgot the second sentence for context: How can they if the law clearly states they cannot be prosecuted? It is if the law is not defined. You can't be in violation of a non-existent law. As the maxim goes, innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
- cortesoft 6y agoIt likely depends on the crime. If the crime committed is obscure and jurisdiction dependent, that argument might hold weight in court. If it is something like murder, the court will likely rule that that is a crime everywhere and it was unreasonable to assume you could get away with murder .
- giantg2 6y agoBut how would they rule on the defendant's rights? If the law says that the person has the right to be tried by a jury in the same state and district, then it seems to be a blatant violation. Just because a crime may be universal, doesn't mean tha people can have their rights violated. The easiest fix for all of this is to have the legislature do their job and amend the law.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoAs discussed above, the ability of a court to change a venue because an impartial jury can't be obtained is well established. A judge would order a change of venue, the defendant would likely appeal, and the appeals court would find that changing the venue isn't an infringement of the defendant's rights.
- 6y ago
- giantg2 6y agoI sort of agree. What I find appalling is that the legislature is aware if the issue and refuses to fix it (do their job). If it's really that clear cut, then surely the people can speak through their representatives to fix this issue.
- hamandcheese 6y agoAs an analogy, how many clear cut bugs do you think are known and exist in a backlog at any given software company? Answer: a lot.
- giantg2 6y agoIf you continue that analogy, how many of those bugs are something they fire the developer over? It's one thing to have a defect. It's another to use it against someone, especially is that dev met the requirements.