4 ms·
> A common argument against the need for privacy that I have definitely heard in my family is “but I have nothing to hide”. Well, neither do I This is complete
by fsflover 6y ago
> A common argument against the need for privacy that I have definitely heard in my family is “but I have nothing to hide”. Well, neither do I
This is completely missing the point of why one should fight surveillance. Surveillance harms journalism and activism, making the government too powerful and not accountable. If only activists and journalists will try to have the privacy, it will be much easier to target them. Everyone should have privacy to protect them. It’s sort of like freedom of speech is necessary not just for journalists, but for everyone, even if you have nothing to say.
- dmje 6y agoWhen people say that to me, I ask them for their phone so that I can give it to a passing member of the public to have a look through. That usually shuts them up.
- samstave 6y agoI initially downvoted you as I read that wrong. Yeah - we are in agreement - fuck surveillance... Did anyone on HN also notice that as soon as Snowden released his thing, Palantir employees stopped wearing swag? And facebook employees are now directed to stop wearing swag?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corty 6y agoI think we do need far more shaming of employees in unwanted companies like Facebook, Google or Palantir. Surveillance damages societies, so we need to act against those who would damage us, small wheels as well as the whole drive train...
- dwild 6y agoHave you ever been naked in front of someone? Will you do it to any passing member of the public? The fact that you trust someone with something doesn't make it that you will trust anyone. I don't have anything on my body to hide to my SO, still won't be nude in front of you. The thing that need to change isn't questioning whether you have anything to hide, it's whether you trust the people involved and on the internet it's a concept so hard for people to grasp. Believe me, whatever Google has access about me, I trust them with it, or else I wouldn't have handed them that information. If there's any single piece of information (or aggregate of information) that you wouldn't trust them with, don't put that there, and that include all the service OP put on his blog post. Personally getting rid of my Google accounts is something I'm slowly working toward, not because of any privacy issue, but because of how they proved that they can't be trusted to keep your account up, and that would screw me up quite a bit more than them abusing my privacy I let them have.
- briandear 6y agoPrivacy is like a vaccine. If everyone has it, it promotes herd immunity that benefits those who are most vulnerable.
- dumpsterdiver 6y agoThat was a very interesting statement, and food for thought.
- ralmidani 6y agoWe’re also less likely to have viable alternatives for journalists and activists if they’re the only people who are privacy-conscious. Getting more people to use Signal and ProtonMail, for example, means more people will see the work of these organizations first-hand, which will lead to more donations, and in the case of Signal there are network effects.
- nbzso 6y agoRecently I switched from Proton to Tutanota. https://privacy-watchdog.io/truth-about-protonmail/ https://privacy-watchdog.io/truth-about-protonmail/
- newscracker 6y agoThis discussion on HN on the news (about two months ago) that Tutanota was forced to monitor and provide emails for an account to law enforcement may be of interest to you. The title of the submission was "German court forces mail provider Tutanota to insert a backdoor". [1] [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25337507 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25337507
- nbzso 6y agoThanks
- blakes 6y agoWhen people say "I've nothing to hide", I usually say it's just like closing the curtains over the windows of your house. You may have nothing to hide, but you still want privacy. It makes sense to most people right away. I don't remember, but it may have been Snowden that said something like that in one of his early interviews.
- beauzero 6y agoPrivacy also protects you from retroactive persecution when ideas change. Many people grow more wise over the years but engage in foolish activities when young that have limiting effects later in life.
- bipson 6y agoYes, and the environment (political, societal) you live in might change. People think something like the (East-Germany) Stasi-State is impossible where they live, but it isn't. You don't have to look far to see societies and governments that make people regret their actions/opinions of the past. You might get reprimanded (e.g. not being able to find employment) because you suddenly live in a society that hates cabbage, and one time, years ago, you said something very extreme about cabbage... This is what most people fail to understand. Every discussion about "privacy rights" and journalists is unfortunately even more abstract to them, because they never lived in a world where this stuff happens or has any importance to them (i.e. they don't see it).
- ttiurani 6y ago“Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” ― Edward Snowden
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rakoo 6y agoMore than that, "I have nothing to hide" is the finest misdirection ever used. There are 2 kinds of things you may want to hide: legal things and illegal things. When the police or the government says "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear", they're technically talking about the illegal things, but 99% of people haven't done illegal things, so it actually is fine to say "I have nothing to hide". What those 99% of people mean is "I have nothing illegal to hide". But by reinforcing the idea that there's nothing to hide, people have now conflated both and now also believe that "I have nothing legal to hide". Which is completely wrong of course: private life is private, it has no business being shown to anyone. Not only do people not understand the difference between the two, they are also not realizing that our analog lives are private by default, but by using tools like Facebook our digital lives become public by default; the switch is invisible, it feels like nothing has changed so we don't really care. I still don't know how to make people understand the boundaries that their data really has once it's stored on someone else's server.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]