3 ms·
> Divorce rates are on their way down in the West. The transition period is definitely rough, but eventually the cultural norms adapt. Divorce rates are down,
by rayiner 6y ago
> Divorce rates are on their way down in the West. The transition period is definitely rough, but eventually the cultural norms adapt.
Divorce rates are down, but so are marriage and birth rates. The "cultural norms" are "adapting," but don't appear to be adapting in a direction that combines modernity with population stability in a steady state.
Much of "the west" is now dependent on people from more traditional cultures (in Europe, Muslims, in the United States, Latinos). That's not an anti-immigration rant (I'm a Bangladeshi immigrant to the United States). My point is that anything we call a "successful culture" should probably be self-sustaining in the steady state. If divorce rates in the west are declining mainly because nobody is getting married (and nobody is having kids) then you don't actually have a successful culture. It might be great for all the freedoms it provides, but on its own it will cease to exist eventually.
In a way it's a sort of arbitrage. If everyone in the world acted like Germans, it would be nice for a while, but humanity would cease to exist. There is an illusion of sustainability that is being provided by people from traditional cultures--with their traditional views on marriage and child-rearing, etc.
- sct202 6y agoBirth rates in Bangladesh are also down below replacement level despite the traditional culture you keep mentioning.
- rayiner 6y agoThere has been a sustained, multi-decade governmental, social, and cultural effort to reduce birth rates to deal with overpopulation. It's a very strong foot on the brake. (My dad was closely involved in this effort in Bangladesh as a public health expert.)
- fulafel 6y agoPopulation stability at current level would be bad, it's higly unsustainable. To make matters worse, we now have instability in the wrong direction: population is predicted to grow for 50-100 years still, peaking at 11 billion. The other variable is resource consumption per capita, both will need to go down after the current spurt to counter severe overpopulation problems globally.
- rayiner 6y agoThere are local overpopulation problems, but globally overpopulation isn’t a problem. https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/12/12/16766872/overpopulation-exaggerated-concern-climate-change-world-population https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2017/12/12/16766872/overpop...
- fulafel 6y agoYeah, thats an opinion piece from an AEI (neocon think tank) pundit.
- rayiner 6y agoHe’s qualified to offer an opinion on the issue > I also approach this problem as a regional economist specializing in migration, so I also think of the American population issue through the lens of population density comparisons. Here’s the same view from Matt Yglesias, solidly left-wing journalist: https://wdet.org/posts/2020/09/24/90064-vox-matthew-yglesias-the-argument-for-massive-population-growth/ https://wdet.org/posts/2020/09/24/90064-vox-matthew-yglesias... Also Scientific American: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-malthus-is-still-wrong/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-malthus-is-st...