3 ms·
What people forget is all the natural junk up there. Space is not "clean". Something like 100 tons of rock, mostly dust, falls onto earth from space every da
by sandworm101 6y ago
What people forget is all the natural junk up there. Space is not "clean". Something like 100 tons of rock, mostly dust, falls onto earth from space every day. That isn't stuff in orbit, but given the capture effects of our moon there is likely a significant amount that does achieve some sort of stability. That amount probably outweighs everything we have ever put up there.
https://astronomy.com/magazine/ask-astro/2014/07/space-debris https://astronomy.com/magazine/ask-astro/2014/07/space-debri...
The real problem isn't that space is getting full of our junk, but that our junk is in a very narrow band of orbits that we use for very specific missions: Sun synchronous polar orbits used by imaging satellites. Look at how these orbits all cross paths at the poles. That's the danger zone. While the military cares deeply about these orbits, civilian infrastructure in space (geosynchronous communications sats, GPS etc) are well beyond any real danger. Or, at least they are in orbits where danger from natural debris is vastly greater than from space junk.
- im3w1l 6y ago> The real problem isn't that space is getting full of our junk, but that our junk is in a very narrow band of orbits that we use for very specific missions: Sun synchronous polar orbits used by imaging satellites. What's the significance of these orbits?
- sandworm101 6y agoA sun-synchronous orbit is a polar orbit where the satellite passes over each part of the earth at the same time every day. That is very useful if you want to photograph things at regular intervals using cameras (stable light, no nighttime) or if your satellite uses solar panels as these orbits can be such that the satellite never falls into the earth's shadow.
- bagels 6y agoThey still go in to shadow once per orbit typically.
- twic 6y agoA dawn-to-dusk sun-synchronous orbit completes most of its orbits in full view of the sun: > This means that, for most of the year, PROBA2 will have a full-time view of the sun, and will not experience eclipses of the sun behind the earth. However, because the orbit does not follow the terminator exactly, PROBA2 will experience brief periods of several weeks when eclipses of the sun by the earth do occur, specifically around December each year. During approximately 80 days (from November until January), visible eclipses occur every orbit with a duration ranging from a few minutes in November up to a maximum of 18 minutes and back to 0. [1] https://proba2.sidc.be/about/launch https://proba2.sidc.be/about/launch
- bagels 6y agoMany of the sun synchronous sats are earth imaging sats and are placed to take pictures at the same time of day when there are short shadows. Thanks for sharing this use use case too though, pretty neat.
- crazygringo 6y agoBut there's an enormous difference between cosmic dust, which generally doesn't pose any threat to satellites or spacecraft, and the man-made "junk" that are essentially destructive whizzing bullets, cannonballs, and worse. The total mass is essentially irrelevant, what matters is the mass of individual objects. > Or, at least they are in orbits where danger from natural debris is vastly greater than from space junk. Are you sure? A quick online search reveals only two satellites appear to have been destroyed -- an Iridium satellite was destroyed in 2009 when it was hit by a junked Russian satellite, while in 1993 the European satellite Olympus was destroyed by a meteor. So it would seem that so far, natural debris and space junk are tied 1-1. Why do you think natural debris is that much more of a risk?
- sandworm101 6y ago>> natural debris and space junk are tied 1-1 There are plenty of sats that have just stopped working, even broken apart, for unknown reasons. Telling the difference between a defect and a meteor impact is mostly impossible. Lots of spacecraft have just stopped working for unknown reasons. Until we start inspecting every failed satellite, as we do aircraft, we won't really know. And note where the 2009 collision happened: over the arctic. This was one polar orbit colliding with a near-polar orbit, right in the danger zone I mentioned above.
- dylan604 6y agoa rock the size of pebble or as small as a grain of sand will cause a very bad day when you realize that some of the objects have incredible amounts of kinetic energy due to the speeds involved (the speed of the rock or the speed of the thing to be damaged).
- giantrobot 6y agoFor many satellites the biggest cross sectional area are solar panels. So the most likely part of a satellite impacts by debris will be there. In terms of probability with debris impacts on satellites the common effect is a slight drop in power output from the solar panels [0]. Keep in mind stuff in orbit is pummeled by micrometeoroids pretty regularly. These are literally dust size grains of material in orbit. They face pretty constant abrasion yet remain fully functional. [0] https://www.space.com/20925-space-station-bullet-hole-photo.html https://www.space.com/20925-space-station-bullet-hole-photo....