5 ms·
I think you are, deliberately or not, leaving out important context (e.g. Twitter did remove the tweet from the Malaysian ex-prime minister), but regardless, ev
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think you are, deliberately or not, leaving out important context (e.g. Twitter did remove the tweet from the Malaysian ex-prime minister), but regardless, even if I fully accept your point that Twitter and FB don't apply their rules fairly, you're still left with the fact that the only people who really need a "free speech" social media platform are folks that are mad that they can't demand the killings of millions or that they can't display fake severed heads. And literally every one of these "free speech" platforms (Parler, Gab, Voat) was immediately turned into a cesspool of conspiratorial rantings, hatred and racism.
Voat was probably my "favorite" of all. Literally the only reason it got any traffic were people were mad they could no longer post to r/fatpeoplehate.
- dc2k08 6y agotwitter didn't remove it initially and must have done so only after backlash pointing out their hypocrisy. Opponents of Trump have had free reign the last four years to incite violence against him and his supporters. Once you label your opponents nazis you can say what you like as far as the tech giants are concerned.
- tsimionescu 6y agoBut, IF your opponents ARE literal swastika-flashing nazis, isn't it a net good to have them harassed wherever they pop their heads?
- esyir 6y agoThis is precisely the sort of water muddying via association
- esyir 6y agoThis is the specific sort of muddying via association that's often used. Suddenly, trump is a literal swastika flashing nazi, and that's why twitter banned him. Associating people with the worst of whatever group you can lump them in, then following up with "they're that guy"
- tsimionescu 6y agoNo, Trump is not a literal swastika-flashing Nazi. BUT, there are literal groups of swastika-flashing Nazis that do support Trump. Targeting these people with harassment should be encouraged, NOT because they support Trump, but because they are Nazis. Trump and non-nazi Trump supporters MUST NOT be harassed by simple association, EXCEPT to the extent that they are themselves protecting the nazis, or trying to muddy the waters. Because a lot of people ARE muddying the waters from the "Trump" side as well: instead of recognizing that many attacks are against literal nazis who happen to support Trump, they act as if the attacks are against Trump supporters in general, or that people are calling a crowd nazis because they support Trump, not because they were chanting "jews will not replace us". Or claiming that Trump, who said about the crowd chanting "jews will not replace us" and the antifa counter-protest "there are fine people on both sides", was not literally defending nazis in this case.
- Veen 6y ago> Trump and non-nazi Trump supporters MUST NOT be harassed by simple association, EXCEPT to the extent that they are themselves protecting the nazis, or trying to muddy the waters. That's the thin end of the wedge though. - Muslims must not be harassed by simple association, except where they muddy the waters to protect Islamists. - Feminists must not be harassed by simple association, except where they muddy the waters to protect transphobes. - Conservatives must not be harassed by simple association, except where they muddy the waters to protect an anti-gay rights agenda. "Muddying the water" is dangerously vague. Who adjudicates between good-faith arguments and those intended to give cover for extremists?
- simonh 6y agoHe's not a Nazi although he's willing to ally with them, but I believe he is a Fascist, on the basis that he has nothing but contempt for democracy and the rule of law (among other things). He pulled exactly the same 'stop the steal' crap in 2016, claiming massive voter fraud then as well, as a pre-emptive strike in case he lost. But hang on, if he actually believed there was massive voter fraud, how come he did nothing about it for four years eve when he controlled both houses? Where were his reforms of the voting system, increased supervision of voting and vote counting? why no improvements to ballot security and statistical analysis to identify the fraud (the current analyses show it's negligible). If he actually believed what he is saying about vote fraud, why didn't he act on it? He did nothing about this for two reasons. First he knows there isn't any significant vote fraud, this is well established and was not a partisan issue before he started talking about it. Second, if he reformed voting security, he would become responsible for preventing any potential fraud and would be unable to blame failings in the system on anyone else, taking away his excuse.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoAnarchists and socialists have been demonetized and banned in wide swathes for years. Crimeth!nc and others are banned from Facebook and Twitter etc. You just don't see it, because it's outside of your bubble of interest.
- throwawayForMe2 6y agoCrimethinc and many Antifa groups are active on Twitter https://twitter.com/crimethinc https://twitter.com/crimethinc
- simonh 6y agoSo are many far right groups, individual examples don't prove anything.
- xupybd 6y agoThere are some bans that do seem target at the right. https://www.newsweek.com/ron-paul-blocked-accessing-facebook-page-over-violating-community-standards-1560639 https://www.newsweek.com/ron-paul-blocked-accessing-facebook...
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgain, keeping with the theme of every single time I hear of some example of conservative censorship, I dig in and find it's 99% BS: https://reason.com/2021/01/11/ron-paul-says-hes-been-locked-out-of-facebook/ https://reason.com/2021/01/11/ron-paul-says-hes-been-locked-... . Ron Paul's page was never banned, blocked or censored in any way for people viewing his content. Admin rights on his page were mistakenly blocked, and reopened a few hours later. I in know way see that targeting the right, especially since I hear plenty of bitching from people on the left who also think it's some sort of conspiracy whenever they get blocked (e.g. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2019/04/24/facebook-while-black-zucked-users-say-they-get-blocked-racism-discussion/2859593002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2019/04/24/facebook-whil... )
- sremani 6y agoThe coincidences keep happening to certain variety of people, especially those who do not belong to 'Corporate Left'.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIt's kind of a truism these days that whenever people are blocked or banned on social media, they blame it on some underlying conspiracy to ban their version of political thought. Another commenter put it best: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25818108 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25818108 "It only seems that way to you because you’re seeing only one side getting arbitrarily suspended."
- sremani 6y agoFor organizations that donate 95% towards one political party, some how they have managed to be extra-ordinarily neutral. If that is your thesis - I disagree.