5 ms·
Samsung ordered to show its new prototypes to Apple
- dhughes 16y agoIsn't there a saying 'You can't excel by being the same as everyone else, you get ahead by being different than everyone else.'
- georgemcbay 16y agoThere's another saying that goes "We have always been shameless about stealing great ideas". http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CW0DUg63lqU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CW0DUg63lqU I guess switching from being the underdog to the new 800 lbs gorilla in a market changes your views on these things substantially.
- danudey 16y agoThere's a difference between stealing great ideas (entirely touchscreen driven internet-enabled smartphone) and stealing great implementations (the hardware form factor, home screen layout, product packaging, product accessories, etc.).
- berntb 16y agoI thought the present version was something about copying what Apple did during the last year? (Phones, tablets, etc.)
- seats 16y agoThis seems to be oddly favorable to apple. Think of the two scenarios. 1- samsung is a complete copycat (likely), and apple has plenty more ammo, which they would get during normal discovery anyway 2- samsung has some novel features, and apple gets advance access to these
- earl 16y agoPlease read the article. "The advanced discovery is limited to "Outside Counsel Eyes Only," meaning that Apple's engineering staff and in-house legal team will not have access to the materials. Apple's legal team handling the suit will determine wether to file for an injunction blocking the devices from being sold."
- seats 16y agoRead it just too fast. I actually missed the exclusion, thanks for the correction.
- danudey 16y agoMaybe it's just me, but it seems like at this point in the game, Apple is probably so deep in development of iOS 5 that there's probably no room to suddenly add a new feature or change direction of an existing one substantially. Even if that weren't the case though, there haven't been a huge amount of innovations from Android that Apple has been interested in stealing; lots of 'ideas' that Apple just didn't implement sooner, and eventually implemented differently (copy and paste) though. I just don't feel like if Apple saw Samsung's new offerings, they'd care enough to bother changing the iPhone 5.
- trotsky 16y ago"the products use icons similar to those used by Apple," according to the report. Can you patent icons? Aren't US software patents business process patents? I've read some number of software patents and can't remember a single one patenting things like a 4x4 grid of icons or colorful square pictures with rounded corners. Didn't Lotus v. Borland set precedent for a lack of look and feel copyright? [1] Said another way, WTF? [1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Lotus_Software#.22Look_and_feel.22_lawsuits https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Lotus_Softwar...
- atlbeer 16y agoThis is a suit about trade dress, not copyright or patent infringement
- trotsky 16y agoReally? So the article has it wrong or am I misreading it? Samsung has been ordered by San Jose Federal Court judge Lucy Koh to provide Apple with samples of its unreleased tablets and smartphones as part of an ongoing patent dispute EDIT: I see the court house news article cited gets it right, quoting the court as specifying the look being directly relevant to their trade dress complaint. Thanks for the heads up. The concept of trade dress is new to me, wikipedia says: "Trade dress protection is intended to protect consumers from packaging or appearance of products that are designed to imitate other products; to prevent a consumer from buying one product under the belief that it is another." It's hard to believe a court would find consumers are in danger of buying a galaxy tab believing it was an ipad.
- msbarnett 16y agoIs it really that hard to believe? If you're a really plugged in technophile you'd never make that mistake, but is the average person really that aware of what a "Galaxy Tab" is, who makes it, and how it differs from one of those "iPads"? We already have prominent news services mis-identifying Samsung phones as iPhones[1], so it's not hard to believe that people even less plugged in are having a harder time of distinguishing these products. [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/opinions/outlook/spring-cleaning-2011/smartphones.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/opinions/outloo...
- rbanffy 16y agoFrom the picture in the article, the 4x4 with a bottom 4x1 fixed row is clearly a rip off. OTOH, the other devices are quite obvious. I remember seeing a keyboard with a connector on top like the one to the right for my Palm (not the WebOS one, the ancient Palm Professional) And, quite frankly, I would really prefer a vanilla Android interface to this.
- mirkules 16y ago"From the picture in the article, the 4x4 with a bottom 4x1 fixed row is clearly a rip of" Didn't we do this dance over two decades ago? Wasn't it decided back then that you can't patent look-and-feel? I don't really understand how this is different.
- danudey 16y agoI think the real issue is that it's possible, at a glance, to confuse the Samsung phone with the iPhone; the home screen is very similar, the form factor is very similar, the icon colours are very similar, etc. Given that no other handset manufacturer (other than iPhone knockoffs) makes a phone that looks so close to an iPhone in pretty much every way, it seems obvious that Samsung is trying to replicate the design. The article also mentions that packaging is part of the suit, which could be another problem for Samsung if it's true.
- chopsueyar 16y agoHow is it obvious they are trying to replicate the design? I am sure you have seen many designs inspired by other designs (websites, cars, buildings, movies). Perhaps other handset manufactures (besides Samsung) do not have the fabricating expertise to create a thin phone with rounded edges profitably? Even at a glance, if both phones are next to another, you couldn't figure out which one was the iPhone, especially with an Apple logo and the word 'iPhone' on the back?
- Locke1689 16y agoIf literally the only thing distinguishing your product from one of the most identifiable brands in the world is a subtly changed brand logo, you have a legal problem.