3 ms·
I'd like to hear grellas' thoughts on this. I think there's a lot to be said for people being trolled to band together, search for prior art, file reexaminatio
by Natsu 15y ago
I'd like to hear grellas' thoughts on this.
I think there's a lot to be said for people being trolled to band together, search for prior art, file reexamination requests, etc., but I'm not sure that you can just find a lot of other people to file declaratory judgement actions with you. At least, not very easily.
IANAL, so if you're going this route, you might want to ask a lawyer to explain MedImmune, Inc. v. Genentech, Inc., 549 U.S. 118 (2007) to you. Patently-O has a nice write-up on that, incidentally, which you can read here: http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2008/05/the-multi-fac-1.html http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2008/05/the-multi-fac-1.html
Basically, you have to have taken meaningful steps to do something that might be infringing. Also, the whole idea of it being a strategy works against you. The statute is permissive, so the court has discretion in terms of whether or not to hear your case. If they think you're doing it to bankrupt your opponent, well, let's just say that they probably won't look upon that favorably. Just because the law gets used as a cudgel doesn't mean that judges approve of this. It's just that some lawyers know how to make fairness really expensive.
I honestly think that the best course of action is to work together to invalidate the patents. Even if you really do bankrupt the troll, they'll probably just sell those patents to someone else, possibly even another troll, during bankruptcy.
- grellas 15y agoI concur with tptacek's (and your) comments on this one. Trolls are pros at one thing and one thing only, and that is working the litigation system (well, maybe also at "monetizing" IP in negotiating forced licenses under threat of lawsuit). To go against them in this way is like sending amateurs out to do a job for which they are highly likely to be overmatched. I thought this piece was thought-provoking and that is why I posted it - but, I am skeptical about an approach like this working, at least when the players are small, independent businesses who have nothing in common with one another besides a desire to resist the threats of the troll. Too much financial pressure, too much risk, too many uncertainties to keep people with disparate interests banded together over a long haul.
- Natsu 15y agoThanks. I think you're absolutely right, which is actually kind of depressing in a way. The NPEs (patent trolls) I've seen in the news are mostly run by lawyers and I don't think they'd just back down from a lawsuit quietly. It's also pretty hard to coordinate with the other people being sued. That said, I don't think people should give up. Even if I don't think that one idea would work, I agree that it's great to see people thinking about how to cooperate on legal defenses. In particular, things like prior art searches should be the same for everyone. So if you happen to know other people being threatened, I think it really might make sense to work together to search for prior art so that you don't all duplicate the same work.