2 ms·
The problem with a shallow dismissal is not just that it's thoughtless, but that it's thoughtless where everyone can read it. A downvote, in contrast, isn't so
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
The problem with a shallow dismissal is not just that it's thoughtless, but that it's thoughtless where everyone can read it. A downvote, in contrast, isn't something that wastes our reading time.
And there's also an element of fairness. Why should a thoughtless, low-effort comment require more effort to respond to?
- blue-dragonfly 6y agoI'm tempted to just say "Q.E.D. (see my unpopular comment above downvoted and greyed out.)". > A downvote, in contrast, isn't something that wastes our reading time. Unless the comments we are reading are decided by mob rule, and the ones that are obscured (and potentially meaningful) are merely unpopular. (I've highlighted greyed out comments on this site.) The truth is we don't know why someone down-votes, unless they annotate it, and even then we'd have to trust their explanation. Such an annotation wouldn't have to be in line. I don't really care, personally, but what did people who down-voted me accomplish? I didn't really learn anything to avoid repeating some behavior--other than re-confirming this is not a place to make waves. > The problem with a shallow dismissal is not just that it's thoughtless, but that it's thoughtless where everyone can read it. With all due respect, this sounds like a well-worn mantra. Everyone can also read admonishments against thoughtlessness, maybe they should be taken off-line too, in the interest of fairness. My personal "Eternal September" is kicking in, so I guess I'll leave it at that. Thanks for your reply.