12 ms·
Something people here are missing is that unless the phishing site uses your credentials right then and there within the existing session, they can't do much ev
by cratermoon 6y ago
Something people here are missing is that unless the phishing site uses your credentials right then and there within the existing session, they can't do much even if they do capture your 2nd factor.
But if the site just captures your credentials and puts them in a database of site/username/passwords, they are useless later, even if they also store your 2nd factor of the moment. The next time someone tries to authenticate with your stolen username and password, and the MFA challenge comes up, they will be stuck. The factor they captured phishing has long expired, and the site has no ability to provide the correct value for your 2nd factor at a later time.
So in other words, 2FA does provide additional protection in this scenario, unless the malicious party has programmed the system to also hijack your session.
I honestly can't say for sure how often the phishing sites use session hijacking vs. just collecting for later use. If the first scenario is most common then no, 2FA doesn't help much. If the second scenario is typical, then 2FA provides significant additional protection over just username/password.
- ecesena 6y agoThis is true for all 2FA methods but not for FIDO security keys. With FIDO, the hostname of the site you're browsing is signed in the assertion, therefore the attacker -even with automation- can't reuse it on the target site. This is why FIDO claims protection against phishing. What the author says is that the attacker, when you're using a FIDO security key, can simply say it's not working and force the user to switch to a different 2FA method, therefore in the end phishing the user.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoSession jacking can also allow disabling MFA unless sites are careful to re-verify the MFA before doing so. Or before changing the password or adding additional tokens / generating backup codes. Security is hard. And features make it porous.
- cratermoon 6y agoYeah, a site needs to issue an MFA challenge to any MFA change attempt.