6 ms·
My absolute favorite example of a reporter willfully twisting words is the following. A reporter was trying to interview my mother about my sister. My mother
by btilly 16y ago
My absolute favorite example of a reporter willfully twisting words is the following.
A reporter was trying to interview my mother about my sister. My mother said, "It's not that we don't think you're important but ...". This wound up in print as, "It's...that we dont think you're important."
Remember, it is the job of the media to get a compelling story out there. They don't care about the truth. They don't care about informing people. They want to create interesting stories that suck people in, and punish people who fail to give them access to information that they wanted (whether or not they had any right to pry).
When we see subjects that we understand misreported in the media, we invariably cringe. When you see subjects you don't know anything about reported in the media, your default assumption should be that if you knew the subject better, you would cringe, and the only reason you're not cringing is that you don't know better.
- thomasgerbe 16y ago"Remember, it is the job of the media to get a compelling story out there. They don't care about the truth." Both Reuters and Al-Jazeera come across as attempting to be as objective as possible about the stories they cover. In fact, the former has been criticized for the policy of objective language.
- btilly 16y agoI've never had the experience of interacting with Reuters or Al-Jazeera. Based on my experiences with other forms of media, I am pessimistic that they live up to their attempted reputation, but do agree that their product does seem more informative.
- mkelly 16y agoIt depends on the subject matter. Reuters and Al-Jazeera are by no means objective on all subjects -- the obvious example is Al-Jazeera and anything to do with Israel. (They immediately begin frothing at the mouth and spouting angry gibberish, just like, e.g., Fox news does in the US when reporting on Democrats.) But Al-Jazeera has useful reporting on other subjects. I think the key is to try to figure out who's useful for what subject matter. Vanity Fair is probably not reliable for anything.
- barrkel 16y agohttp://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aenglish.aljazeera.net+israel http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aenglish.aljazeera.net+... I'm not really seeing this frothing at the mouth you're speaking of, particularly when you leave out Opinion articles rather than reporting. (But HN is really not the place for this conversation...)
- burgerbrain 16y agoSupposedly they tone it down in their english publication. I only speak english though, and Al Jazeera FUD is hardly unheard of over here, so who knows.
- lurker19 16y agoIt is certainly harder for the FUD to be unheard of when someone makes a point of spreading it.
- mkelly 16y agoIf others haven't had the same experience w.r.t Al-Jazeera, it's possible I got confused about reporting vs. opinion.
- protomyth 16y agoReuters has been caught faking photos.
- hugh3 16y agoIndeed: http://zombietime.com/reuters_photo_fraud/ http://zombietime.com/reuters_photo_fraud/ Though it seems that the photos were faked by low-level partisans on the ground, not by high-on decree from Reuters itself. Reuters isn't significantly better or worse than anyone else, in the scheme of things, but it's a bad idea to have too much faith in any news outlet, regardless of how sophisticated it may currently make you sound when you brag about how you get all your news from Al Jazeera. (Personally I get all my news from Taiwanese animations.)
- skunkworks 16y agoSerious wow at Lebanon war photo fraud. That is just appalling.
- jrockway 16y agoA reporter was trying to interview my mother about my sister. My mother said, "It's not that we don't think you're important but ...". This wound up in print as, "It's...that we dont think you're important." Honestly, whoever did this is a failure at their job. This can't be a common practice because it's so blatantly wrong. Even Reddit commentors don't get upvoted for crap like this.
- btilly 16y agoI have no idea how common that is. However that incident taught me why people say, "No comment" to the media. Short. Sweet. Can't be misquoted out of context.
- vyrotek 16y ago"Do you agree?" - "No ..."
- hugh3 16y agoAh, but they have a way around that as well. Journalist: btilly, would you ever rape a child? btilly: No comment. Headline: btilly refuses to rule out raping children Next week they'll ask whether you're running for president, and if you don't comment on that then the cover of Time will be a picture of your face with the caption "Is America Ready For a Child-Raping President?"
- btilly 16y agoAh yes. The Glenn Beck approach. I'm very glad to have never had to deal with it.
- Eliezer 16y agoSo far as I can tell, you're simply wrong. So far as I can tell, this is pretty much how standard journalism works.
- chc 16y ago
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- andywood 16y agoIn every case where I read or viewed a news story on a subject I had specialist or insider knowledge of, I've been dumbstruck by how much journalists get wrong. Simple facts have been mixed up. Statements that I gave or heard first-hand have been misquoted. Terms and pseudo-jargon are misapplied, or made up out of thin air. So I absolutely do assume that most of the stories where I do not have special knowledge are just as wildly inaccurate. I think of journalists as chatty laypeople with an unsuspecting audience. Not that I think it's an easy job to have to always be talking, while not knowing what you're talking about. I just think it's wrong that it's always portrayed as delivering facts, when it must be closer to hastily jotting down a lot of disjoint words, phrases, and half-quotes, and then trying to reconstruct a plausible-sounding story from it later.
- stretchwithme 16y agoWhen they ask if they can record the interview, ask if you can record the interview. Maybe the fact that a simple link can prove they are distorting things will make them more honest.