3 ms·
I think his point is about transfer. The typical argument about the value of humanities is that it teaches "critical thinking." This argument has to be made be
by scott_s 15y ago
I think his point is about transfer.
The typical argument about the value of humanities is that it teaches "critical thinking." This argument has to be made because a humanities education does not teach many skills which are directly useful in a job. For example, not many people are going to get a job where they are asked to write a critical analysis of a book. So, the argument is that the critical thinking skills required to do that analysis will transfer to tasks that are part of a job. I don't disagree with this argument. That is, the critical thinking skills will transfer, even if the specific skills will not.
irahul's point is that a CS education requires developing critical thinking skill as well. And if we're going to argue that the critical thinking skills required to write an English essay will transfer, then we must also argue that the critical thinking skills required to design a compiler will also transfer.
By the way, what you said is condescending, and I don't know how it could not be.